California Trainers Pledge $150k To Race-Day Surveillance

by | 08.31.2015 | 4:39pm
Security at work on the Churchill Downs backstretch

The leadership of California Thoroughbred Trainers (CTT) has voted unanimously to pledge $150,000 from its reserves to initiate and assist in leading a comprehensive race‐day camera surveillance and security program in stable areas at Thoroughbred tracks in California.

The decision was made at a special meeting of its Board of Directors held Saturday, August 29, at Del Mar, and by teleconference with all its directors statewide.

“While CTT has supported proper third‐party or independently supervised race‐day administration of Lasix since 2011, and continues to do so, we have always pointed out that backstretch security must be tightened at the same time,” said James Cassidy, president.  “Administering Lasix takes a few minutes, at most,” he said, and continued, “What we really need is to take steps to be sure nothing improper happens with any horse during all the many hours the rest of race day, not only when Lasix is administered.”

The California Horse Racing Board (CHRB) held a well‐attended and very informative meeting on camera surveillance in March 2015 at Los Alamitos, but since then, despite a previous $150,000 pledge by Thoroughbred Owners of California (TOC), no significant steps forward have been taken to apply new digital camera technology to the backstretch in California.

“Any perception that the trainers' governing organization is tolerant of misbehavior or outright cheating has to end,” stated Alan F. Balch, executive director of CTT. “Unfortunately, that perception has been fostered, whether or not intentionally, by some regulatory officials and others through gratuitous comments about Lasix and its administration. We want to put a stop to that by tackling the problem properly, not only as to Lasix administration itself, but even more important, by monitoring everything that goes on in the stalls of all horses entered on race day.

“To think that any trainer would be willing to turn a blind eye to cheating by a fellow trainer is ridiculous. What trainers want is a level playing field, where horses shipping and horses on the grounds are all competing under the same circumstances, with the same rules, insofar as is possible.  No trainer wants any other trainer to have an advantage.  If any trainer is using any impermissible medication or drug, that must be stopped,” Balch said, although he emphasized that by the CHRB's own reporting, the incidents even of impermissible medication are at an all‐time low, and there is no evidence whatsoever of cheating.

“Nevertheless,” he admitted, “to the extent there is even a perception of the possibility of misbehavior, we have said all along that backstretch security must be drastically improved.  It is nowhere near what it once was. We believe our pledge, added to the TOC's previous pledge, will stimulate the racing associations and the CHRB also to do their parts to launch this program with urgency.”

CTT's leadership envisions that the latest portable high‐definition camera technology, coupled with increased backstretch security personnel, will provide the potential of thorough camera surveillance of every stall of horses throughout race day, whether shippers or stabled on the grounds.

“No matter what happens with rules governing third‐party Lasix administration, which we support and always have,” Balch said, “the present proposed rules are a long way from being approved administratively and becoming effective. Since the lengthy regulatory approval process worsens the perception problem, we believe the increased surveillance, as well as supervised administration of Lasix, can be accomplished without any rule changes and may be able to be implemented much, much sooner. We hope to be able to take a leading role in creating a task force on security, with all stakeholders, with the goal of beginning the new program as early as the Del Mar Fall meeting.”

Balch said he did not underestimate the practical problems the CTT initiative faces. “If instituting such a program were a simple matter, it would have been done long ago. I think everyone agrees that we need far better backstretch security. But the first problem is always affordability. So that's the first reason we've made our pledge.  The most important reason, however, is that we can't afford not to do it. What we need even more than money is will, the will to solve the difficult practical problems we face, to bring the latest digital and automation technology to bear, and to make the process of surveillance far more efficient and affordable than it ever has been.”

The California Racing Law places the general responsibility of negotiating with racing associations over issues relating to the backstretch with the trainers' organization, so CTT believes it is fitting that it offer to spearhead the initiative and bring a sense of urgency to it. Balch said the CTT will be communicating its ideas to the CHRB formally and in more detail this week, in advance of and at the Medication and Safety Committee meeting noticed to be held at Del Mar on Friday, September 4.

  • Tinky

    “There are no American infidels in Baghdad. Never!”

    – Baghdad Bob

    “…there is no evidence whatsoever of cheating.”

    – Alan F. “Baghdad” Balch, executive director of CTT

    • SteveG

      Cynic! Didn’t you realize California trainers have a corner on integrity & rectitude. It’s simply our misconception that anyone among that angelic group would take advantage of swiss cheese security & no 3rd party administration of lasix. Doesn’t happen, Tinky.

      • David Juffet

        Lol! Gotta love it!

    • David Juffet

      Good one Tinky. The watchman lay there dreaming at 45 degrees he dreamed horse racing was sinking bending to her knees.

  • Racing Fan

    Races are not won by what’s given on raceday, they cheaters win by the doping they allegedly do with synthetic drugs which are undetectable with the awful labs being used in the United States.

    If you want to crack down on cheating, do searches of the vets trucks and don’t allow them to have unmarked vials of drugs in their possession.

  • Peyton

    If the trainers are responsible for security on the backside, it seems to me the California Racing Law needs to be changed. Maybe I misunderstood the last paragraph. I think it would be more appropriate for the track operator/owner/franchisee to be responsible for such issues.

    • ScottSloan

      On behalf of CTT’s leadership, Peyton, thanks for drawing attention to the last paragraph of the release. The Racing Law says specifically, “the trainers’ organization shall generally be responsible for negotiating issues related to the backstretch, track safety, and the welfare of backstretch employees.” We’re planning to update the release accordingly.

      • Peyton

        I guess the operative word is ‘negotiating’. With track management and the CA commission I assume? Thanks for the reply.

  • gus stewart

    if you really want to fix the problem…lmao, really cameras, how about a few vets only, meds in a pharmaceutical office monitored on the backside office, autos checked, barns with cameras as a deterrent, and if caught with any improper stimulates a nice 10 to twenty year vacation.( of of course not taking 2 years to decide) it would cost much less then 150,000 and your smoke and mirrors discussions . Either your all in competent in the meetings or………….. hmmmmmmmm I will take the latter reason….. lets not chase the high priced owners out,,,, my money goes on that answer, but the intellect in the meetings is still up for discussion

    • As I keep saying – put the owner in the dock along with the trainer. End of problem

  • This group covered itself in glory when they successfully stalled off implementation of third-party Lasix shots last month at the CHRB meeting. Their actions on important issues have only served to isolate California on the desert island it has already become. I cannot believe that Alan Balch works for these misfits.

    • David Juffet

      I was born at night Barry,but not last night. These people make me sick.

Twitter Twitter
Paulick Report on Instagram