ARCI Panel: Out-Of-Competition Testing, Additional Investigators Among Best Ways To Stop Cheating

by | 04.19.2017 | 8:53am
Dr. Scott Palmer

Increased out-of-competition testing, investing in additional investigators and re-search into emerging threats is the most effective way to catch — and, more importantly, deter — cheating in horse racing.

That was the big take-away from the drug-testing forum on opening day of the Association of Racing Commissioners International's 83rd annual conference on Equine Welfare and Racing Integrity at the Charleston Marriott.

The panel featured Dr. Scott Stanley of the University of California, Davis, which conducts that state's horse-racing testing; Dr. Anthony Fontana of Truesdail Laboratories; and, speaking via teleconferencing, Dr. George Maylin, the longtime director of the New York Equine Drug Testing and Research Laboratory. Also on the panel was Brice Cote, a former standardbred driver and detective in New Jersey State Police's racetrack unit who heads the integrity efforts at The Meadowlands, Tioga and Vernon Downs harness tracks.

Even if the panelists expressed varying beliefs on the prevalence of rules-violators, they all emphasized the importance of out-of-competition testing — taking samples from horses in between races — as a way to detect substances that no longer show in traditional blood or urine tests from samples taken immediately after a race but still could have an impact on a horse's performance.

“The only way we're going to stop this is by intelligence-based policing and out-of-competition testing,” Cote said.

“Most jurisdictions have very good drug testing,” Stanley said afterward. “We do robust testing, and most of the labs are accredited as well. Now we look at big challenges. And when you look at big challenges, you can make those mountains into molehills, or you can take them off one at a time and get them knocked down. We are doing both. We are taking the ones that have legitimate concerns for the industry, like cobalt when that came up. We found that, set a threshold, established rules and made that go away — quickly. Steroids, anabolic and corticosteroids, those now are well-regulated. This are big wins for the industry. They weren't low-hanging fruit either. We still have some challenges that have now climbed the tree, they're higher up. And we need to knock those off.”

Stanley discussed the potential of “biological passports” as a tool, in its infancy of development for equines, that could be used in out-of-competition testing. The test-ing would provide a baseline result to which subsequent testing both pre-race and between races could be compared.

“If they change abruptly, if the bio-markers tell us this horse was given an anabolic agent, we don't have to detect it,” he said of the exact substance. “We'd be able to say, ‘This horse cannot naturally produce this profile. It has to be enhanced.'”

“Informed testing, focused testing and targeting testing is something we need to put more emphasis on,” said ARCI president Ed Martin. “Out of competition testing should be expanded, but it's real value doesn't come until you've expended the re-search dollars to be able to detect the substances not being detected in the exist-ing out-of-competition testing.”

Also Tuesday:

A panel of administrative veterinarians discussed keeping horses' treatment rec-ords and the trust issues that arise among equine practitioners, horsemen and regulators as to proper use.

Dr. Scott Palmer, New York's equine medical director, said that regulators getting horses' treatment records can benefit horsemen and veterinarians because of the research made possible. He noted that Depo-Medrol was the most popular corti-costeroid used in joint injections up until 2012. Unknown at the time, the medica-tion could pool in other tissue and stick around longer when used in hocks and sti-fles, trickier joints than ankles, Palmer said.

“We discovered that Depo-Medrol could be found in the joint in a blood test of a horse as long as 100 days after the administration period,” he said. “The idea that you go on the (Racing Medication & Testing Consortium) guidelines and see 21 days for Depo-Medrol is a risky business. It wasn't accurate, because there was such a variation in the amount of time that the Depo-Medrol would be discoverable in a post-race blood test.”

Palmer said that, with what was learned from knowing the location of injections and the timing of administration, veterinarians were cautioned about using Depo-Medrol in the first place. He said that today in New York if a veterinarian uses Depo-Medrol, the horse must be tested for the substance before running.

“That's a good example how we can use the research findings from the medical records, the treatment records to protect people and help create a better regulatory policy,” Palmer said.

A morning panel brought various perspectives on how to promote the good in horse racing while not ignoring issues facing the sport.

Wagner to players: ‘Regulators do strive to get it right'

Judy Wagner, outgoing ARCI chair and horse racing's First Lady of Handicapping, had a message for her fellow horseplayers.

Wagner is the 2001 National Horseplayers Championship winner, the horseplayers' representative on the board of the National Thoroughbred Racing Association and the vice chair of the Louisiana Racing Commission. With her one-year term as ARCI chair ending Thursday, she'll hand the baton to chair-elect Jeff Colliton of the Washington Horse Racing Commission.

“As a horseplayer — and this is a message that I want to get across to horseplayers: Regulators do strive to get it right,” she told the audience at the Charleston Marriott for the three-day conference. “We really want to make the players, everybody in the industry, feel that we have an industry of integrity.

“Let handicappers know that they have a product that they can respect; they don't have to handicap the rumors that this trainer is doping horses or whatever. And saying that, I wish that we could educate the public that there is a difference between d-o-p-e and legal medication to help the horse. There is a place for therapeutic drugs.”

Committee recommends banning Clenbuterol for Quarter Horses

The Quarter Horse Racing Committee voted 5-3 to recommend amending the ARCI model rule to prohibit the bronchodilator Clenbuterol in Quarter Horse and mixed-breed races, with testing in blood serum and plasma, urine and hair permit-ted. The recommendation now goes to the Drug Testing Standards and Practices Committee for consideration, then the Model Rules Committee and ultimately the ARCI board, if approved at each step.

Clenbuterol is a useful therapeutic medication to treat respiratory ailments, but its abuse to build muscle mass sparked American Quarter Horse Association officials to request that it be completely banned in their breed. The abuse is not seen with Thoroughbreds, for which such muscle build-up could impede running that breed's longer distances, officials said.

The AQHA officials requested that the rule be breed-specific. “We don't feel it is our job to take it away from other breeds,” said Janet VanBebber, the AQHA's chief racing officer. “But we readily acknowledge that there is abuse within our breed of the sport.”

The three racing jurisdictions voting against the recommendation said they thought it should be banned for all breeds.

  • Ed Martin will never get it. Researching for illegal drugs is not the way to stop cheating. When policing and investigating are successful in snatching samples as evidence, these substances can be sent to a lab, analyzed and can be identified for future testing. This how it is always done. As for the prevalence, I don’t think the numbers of cheaters is relevant, but the impact at the very highest level of competition. Anybody that competes at these levels knows exactly what I mean. As soon as people realize that the world is not flat, but that it is actually round, we will be closer to doing things that make a difference. Too many of these ostrich types are slowing doen the fight to identify the cheaters so that they can be kicked out of the game.

  • Bryan Langlois

    I wonder if horsemans groups would be in favor of having slightly decreased purses over the course of a meet IF that money instead went to funding a more substantial investigative division of the Commissions, which would allow for hiring of more people and bringing in more resources to combat things. Since states are all strapped for cash, it seems like the only way funds could be made available for increasing this type of investigative work.

    • disqus_wZUB6w9ANy

      Depending on the track, I’d say yes. Certainly at Parx, I would take at 5% decrease in total purse for more investigators, but!! only if penalties are real!! No running in different names, real financial deterrents-$5000 minimum fines and 1 month suspension during meets, etc.
      Also, states are not strapped for cash, they just spend it like it’s not theirs, building Taj Majhals for elementary and middle schools, outlandish pension promises, etc.

      • Figless

        without punishment nothing else matters.

  • Bryan Langlois

    In regards to the Clenbuterol statement of ” The abuse is not seen with Thoroughbreds, for which such muscle build-up could impede running that breed’s longer distances, officials said.”


  • McGov

    I don’t know anything really about this technology…..but just putting it out there…..
    Could biochips not be used to develop a horses background or “normal” profile and indicate changes such as doping etc ? Why can’t this technology be a consideration towards not only cheating but horse identification ( ie no more tatoos ;)…..and perhaps trainers might also use to keep a closer eye on things with their horses etc.
    Or is this too intrusive ?

    • Bryan Langlois

      I think that the background part is what they are looking at in bio passports. It is a very viable option but in the DRF story on this the guy who talked about the biopassports said many years and millions of dollars for dedicated research is needed to make it work mainstream on a large level. Right now that funding is not there apparently, and much more work needs to be done to make it legitimate in the racing world. As for the ID part, the Jockey club has mandated that all foals born now have to be microchipped for ID purposes, so eventually the lip tattoo will be going away.

  • Figless

    Wrong. The best way to deter cheating is to increase the punishment in cases of obvious cheating, as opposed to accidental overage. Punishment should include referral to appropriated law enforcement agencies for prosecution for attempted race fixing of a pari-mutual event.

    While the steps mentioned are helpful if they receive a slap on the wrist nothing will change.

    • Figless

      Jail is a deterrent, a 30 suspension during slow season is not.

      • Figless

        And you are banned from the backstretch, for life, ruled off. No taking a job as an assistant trainer or foreman.

    • Jack Frazier

      Wrong. Look at the list of trainers who continually have an overage knowing all they will get is a small fine, a wink and a nod and keep doing it. I have actually looked at the CHRB website, which lists this stuff and it is the usual suspects who do this week in and week out. Something a bit more drastic needs to done. First offense:$1,000 fine; second offense $10,000 fine and thirty day suspension and loss of being able to go on the backside and third offense, a hefty 50,000 fine and an eighteen month suspension which includes having to disperse their stables. That would get their attention.

  • Jack Frazier

    In a word, this is just stupid. Severe penalties should be assessed on ANYONE who has an overage of bute, Lasix or any authorized drug instead of just fines. Just do something simple because this is not as complex as the pencil necked geeks in this ARCI joke fest want people to believe. I’ve watching this three ring circus of nitwitdom saying but doing nothing for too many years to actually believe they want to fix the corruption except in a few cases. What they are doing is akin to Al Capone say their is a drinking problem in Chicago and he is forming a committee to fix it. These jokers are as useless as tits on a boar hog. They need to just quit spouting BS and say they are just going to let it go on while racing dies a slow, painful death all across the country.

Twitter Twitter
Paulick Report on Instagram