McIntyre Comes Out On Top In 2016 NHC Tour

by | 01.06.2017 | 1:36pm
Cheryl McIntyre, winner of the 2016 NHC Tour

Cheryl McIntyre of Massillon, Ohio, won three National Handicapping Championship (NHC) qualifying contests this year and earned 19,898 points overall to win the 2016 Daily Racing Form NHC Tour, which ended Sunday at the close of on-track qualifiers at Monmouth Park and Del Mar's Surfside Race Place. The first female NHC Tour winner, McIntyre earned $75,000, a trophy, and an automatic berth to NHC 19 in 2018. She also is eligible for a $2 million bonus should she go on to win the world's richest and most prestigious handicapping contest, the Daily Racing Form/NTRA National Handicapping Championship (NHC), Jan. 27-29, at Treasure Island Las Vegas.

Rick Broth of Dunwoodie, Ga., near Atlanta, finished second with 19,196 points, good for a $20,000 payday, followed by Tony Zhou of New York City with 18,698 points, worth $15,000.

The top 20 finishers on the NHC Tour shared $175,000 of prize money. An additional $100,000 in NHC Tour prize money went to the top five “First-Half” and “Second-Half” finishers on separate six-month leaderboards. McIntyre was the only player to earn two $10,000 checks for top-five “First-Half” and “Second-Half” efforts, bringing her cumulative 2016 NHC Tour earnings to $95,000. Broth was among the “First-Half” leaders and earned $30,000 for the year.

Overall NHC Tour standings are determined by totaling a player's top six scores from eligible qualifying contests, which must include at least one live, on-site event. The top 150 finishers on the NHC Tour not previously qualified earned automatic berths to this month's NHC in Las Vegas. The top 40 NHC Tour finishers will compete for a $25,000 Tour Bonus, which goes to the individual within that group with the highest finish at NHC 18.

McIntyre's six scoring contests for NHC Tour purposes included three outright wins – the Champions Tournament at Laurel Park in March (worth 4,461 points), a second straight win in the Mid-Summer Challenge at Woodbine in July (3,016 points), and an online contest in December (3,594 points). She also accrued significant points with a runner-up finish on in October (2,215 points), a third at Keeneland's NHC-BCBC Challenge in October (2,436 points), and a seventh on in November (2,676 points).

“I can't really put my finger on what exactly I did differently this year or why,” said McIntyre, a NHC veteran whose remarkable run in 2016 also included earning five berths to the Breeders' Cup Betting Challenge (although she could only play the allowed maximum of two). “I just kept doing the same things I've always done and it seemed every once in a while I'd have a great day and come in first place.”

McIntyre and her husband, Mike, are among the Tour's most serious and committed players, traveling to as many on-track contests as possible while also competing in online qualifiers. “If there are three or four contests every weekend, multiply that by however many weekends there are in a year and that's how many we played in,” McIntyre said.

McIntyre is the ninth NHC Tour champion and the first female to join that exclusive group of elite horseplayers.

“It hasn't really sunk in yet,” McIntyre said. “It's kind of cool, especially being a woman and knowing that not as many women play this game. But I'm seeing more of us every year.”

The NHC Tour top five was rounded out by Joseph Costello (18,545 points; $10,000 prize) and Joe Pettit (18,217; $7,500).

NHC Tour results became official upon completion of a review period and audit that concluded Thursday. Full standings for the NHC Tour and bonus divisions can be accessed online via the NTRA website at

The 2017 NHC Tour kicks off Jan. 28, the Saturday of NHC 18, with an online contest, the details of which will be announced in coming weeks. NHC Tour membership is $50-$95 and participants can sign up online at

Alipio Wins “Second-Half”
Sam Alipio of Palos Verdes, Calif., near Los Angeles, led all players on the NHC Tour “Second-Half” leaderboard, based on results posted after August 1, with 11,267 points. All of the top five “Second-Half” finishers earned $10,000. The others getting checks are McIntyre (10,921 points), Costello (10,876), Zhou (10,602), and Robert Gilbert (10,296).

Chute Earns Inaugural “Cyber Stars” Bonus
George Chute came in 15th overall on the NHC Tour but topped all players in points accrued on, earning him a $10,000 prize in the first-ever $25,000 “Cyber Stars” bonus pool and the chance at a $1 million bonus should he win NHC 18. The remaining Cyber Stars prize money went to Robert Gilbert ($6,000), Pettit ($4,000), Costello ($3,000), and Kevin Engelhard ($2,000).

Dresens Tops Rookie Standings
Peter Dresens (15,904 points) earned a $5,000 “Rookie” bonus as the leading player that signed up for the NHC Tour for the first time in 2016. The rest of that $15,000 prize pool went to Daniel Zaretsky (8,390 points; $4,000 bonus), Richard Trobaugh (6,733; $3,000), Cory Hodskins (3,320; $2,000), and Steve Gould (2,784; $1,000).

  • JM

    Just out of curiosity, how do they spend to win this? is it even worth it to chase first place?

    • garret

      she won a lot of money 5 bc seats + $85,000 plus laurel and woodbine cash wins! don’t pity her . She did all right!

  • Steve

    They played multiple entries every weekend in on-site and online contests, something most people can’t afford to do

    • Trumpet

      waah, waah, waah – always some crybaby loser finding an excuse to make themselves feel better. She put in the time, sounds like more time than anyone else, and made it to the top – good for her. I have a feeling her and her husband can afford to play these contests because they both likely spent their lives working just as hard and saving money. But someone like you always comes along and tries to sully it with your ‘income inequality’ propaganda. Hard work often pays off, whether or not you like to admit it.

      • Steve

        I’m just stating the facts. I could care less about the tour. Congratulations to her, it IS an accomplishment to beat everyone else, no matter what the circumstances

  • MyKey

    The best part of this story, and the NHC Tour itself is that it is a shining example of what can be accomplished when serious horseplayers are allowed to take part in the decision making and architecturing of a facet of the sport.
    Unlike those shortsighted, egocentric racetrack management types that seem to put all their efforts into crafting new and inventive ways to selfishly serve the needs of their own demographic, the Player’s Committee has selflessly created this Tour which takes into careful consideration the available time and monetary resources of every level of horseplayer and creates a level playing field for all involved.
    It is critical to the future of this sport to rid ourselves of selfish track management and put groups like the Player’s Committee in charge, for only they are enlightened enough to put the needs of their brethren aside and put the game back in the hands of the sports true foundation, the $2 bettor.

    • Steve

      The $2 bettor? Are you kidding me? You got it right in the first sentence – serious players, the kind who bet much more than $2

      • MyKey

        The tone of the entire post was meant to be sarcastic, so yes, I was kidding you. The Player’s Committee took what was at one time a really balanced, positive idea and made it the domain of their ilk. As such I believe they lose the right to point the finger at track management for being self-serving and short sighted when, given the opportunity, they acted in the same exact manner.

Twitter Twitter
Paulick Report on Instagram