Bloodlines: A Cowboy And His Students

by | 12.19.2017 | 8:19am
Fear the Cowboy wins the Harlan's Holiday

The victory of Fear the Cowboy (by Cowboy Cal) in the Dec. 16 Harlan's Holiday Stakes at Gulfstream Park poked holes in the aspirations of some horses looking at next month's $12 million Pegasus World Cup.

But the 5-year-old's victory brought cheers from fans and partisans as far apart as Kentucky and South Korea.

Fear the Cowboy was bred in Kentucky by the University of Kentucky, raised at UK's Maine Chance Farm on Newtown Pike north of Lexington, and then sold at Fasig-Tipton's Kentucky winter mixed sale across the road from Maine Chance in February 2013 when Fear the Cowboy was a short yearling.

The leggy bay didn't bring much, selling for $1,500 to Alexandro Centofanti.

Laurie Lawrence, professor of animal and food sciences at UK, noted that “unlike most of the other farms, our horses aren't the principal product. Instead, the primary focus and end goal are our students. Each semester, we employ eight to 10 students to work on the farm. They handle the mares, clean the stalls, fix the fences, go on breeding shed runs, and do foal watch.”

Those skills are an important part of UK's contribution to educating these young people, Lawrence said, because “few of the students come from a Thoroughbred background, and it's a good introduction to Thoroughbreds.” The Maine Chance operation raises 15-20 yearlings annually and sells them at Fasig-Tipton “because it's right across the road, and the shorter sales fit into the students' schedules more easily,” Lawrence said.

The education for and introduction of young people to the Thoroughbred business is one reason the farms and owners in the region support UK, its Maine Chance Farm, and the overall equine program so enthusiastically.

In the case of the Harlan's Holiday winner, both the dam and the season to the sire were donated to the program.

Lawrence said, “Jeffrey Morris at Highclere Farm donated Whom Shall I Fear,” an unraced daughter of the Dehere stallion Soto, who stood at Highclere.

Morris said, “One of the motivations for donating the filly was Ned Morrison, a really nice guy who got interested in Soto and bought into that filly, but we ended up not getting her to the starting gate. The mare was a maiden, and I donated her near the end of 2009, when she was an unraced 3-year-old.

“Her dam (Leh She Run) was floundering with her produce at that point,” Morris continued. “I wasn't getting any traction with her yearlings at the sales, and it seemed wiser to donate Whom Shall I Fear and allow my partner to take a tax deduction.”

Morris, however, had bred a foal out of the Pulpit mare Leh She Run in 2009 that turned out to be O'Prado Again (El Prado), winner of the 2011 Remsen Stakes and a $350,000 Keeneland September yearling in 2010.

That made Whom Shall I Fear a nicer-looking prospect for UK when considering her next mating, and Lawrence said “the big success of First Samurai (two-time G1 winning juvenile by Giant's Causeway) in the mare's second dam led us to look for a Giant's Causeway stallion, and Pin Oak was generous enough to donate a season to Cowboy Cal,” a young son of Giant's Causeway who was fairly popular at the time.

In the interim, Cowboy Cal was sold to stand in South Korea and Fear the Cowboy dawdled his way through the Fasig-Tipton sale. That was, however, the last time the bay colt was caught dawdling.

Lawrence said, “Whom Shall I Fear is pretty big, and her babies tend to be late developers, tall and leggy. When he sold, Fear the Cowboy was a tall, somewhat gangly colt, but he was a perfectly nice colt and has ended up in good hands.”

Repaying sensible management, the competitive bay has been on a consistent upward trajectory throughout his career. Fear the Cowboy won a maiden at 2, then became a stakes winner at 3, repeated with a stakes victory at 4, and has won a pair of Grade 3 events this season at 5, with total earnings of $570,869.

That's a hefty return on a $1,500 horse the students, staff, and management at UK and Maine Chance have many reasons to be proud of. As Lawrence said, “A lot of our horses have gone to end users,” like the owners of Fear the Cowboy, and that has the advantage of benefitting both the buyers and the young men and women who are learning the ropes in an uncertain game.

Frank Mitchell is author of Racehorse Breeding Theories, as well as the book Great Breeders and Their Methods: The Hancocks. In addition to writing the column “Sires and Dams” in Daily Racing Form for nearly 15 years, he has contributed articles to Thoroughbred Daily News, Thoroughbred Times, Thoroughbred Record, International Thoroughbred, and other major publications. In addition, Frank is chief of biomechanics for DataTrack International and is a hands-on caretaker of his own broodmares and foals in Central Kentucky. Check out Frank's lively Bloodstock in the Bluegrass blog.

  • whirlaway

    Now this is a real bargain and a very appealing story. I realize in 2016 FTC sold for $145,000
    as Fasig Tipton summer select horses of racing age but certainly humble beginnings. I have to
    hope he gets a place hopefully in the top four of the Pegasus. Already at 27 starts and running
    At 5 yrs old nice horse, be cheering for him and his UK students.

    • Fear the Cowboy was bought back for $145,000, but it is a great story. Thanks.

      • whirlaway

        Poor fear the Cowboy RNA, I thought he sold, Yes he is a very nice story the other I also loved was Don’t Tell Sophia sold for $1,000 the only bid and she was a nice race mare as an in foal mare sold for over a million. There are numerous happy successes in racing. Enjoy those stories.

  • Mare Croft

    I enjoyed the information about UK’s breeding program. I didn’t know they raised so many foals each year. Glad to see a nice runner come out of the program for students to be proud of. Thanks for the fun article.

  • Carrie Basham

    Wow…. I love this story!!!! I love the name and really live the College kids lives being impacted in such an awesome way! Way to go!

  • Always Curious

    Thank you Frank for the great story. Now I have a horse to root for in the Pegasus besides the favorites. They truly caught “lightening in a jar.”

Twitter Twitter
Paulick Report on Instagram