Cosequin Presents Aftercare Spotlight: 12-Year-Old Boy Claims 12-Year-Old Horse For Retirement

by | 07.13.2016 | 11:47am
12-year-old Fredrick Spanabel with Good Credentials, the 12-year-old horse he claimed for retirement

“What you do makes a difference, and you have to decide what kind of difference you want to make.”

Jane Goodall

It takes some people the better part of a lifetime to figure out what type of lasting mark they want to make on the world. Twelve-year-old Fredrick Spanabel seems to be ahead of the curve.

Fredrick has a heart for animals and a mind for business. In his family's Hazel Park shed row, you can find Finn B Cool, who is Fredrick's racehorse (with “Fredrick Ryan Spanabel” listed as the owner) among his father's 25 horses in training. You can also find a menagerie of other animals, including pigeons, chickens, rabbits and a raccoon, in Fredrick's makeshift animal rescue and rehabilitation area.

While Fredrick is saving most of the earnings from Finn B Cool and any other horse he owns for his future college expenses, exceptions are made when a situation warrants it, as was the case on July 2nd. With his dad listed as the trainer, Fredrick claimed 12-year-old Good Credentials with the sole intention of permanently retiring him from racing.

When Plan A and B Don't Work, Try Plan C
Bred in Kentucky by Pin Oak Stud, Good Credentials spent his career in the claiming ranks at tracks like Evangeline, Hawthorne and Thistledown and made an honest living, retiring at age 7 with a record of 56-5-12-8 and earnings of $47,402.  

But, on June 18th of this year, Good Credentials ran in the fifth race at Hazel Park in Michigan for a $4,000 claiming price. The gelding finished sixth, nearly ten lengths behind the winner.

His entry caught the eye of several people, including Jennifer Wirth, a lawyer and founder of One Last Race, a non-profit that raises and distributes funds to Thoroughbred aftercare organizations.

“I saw something on Twitter about Good Credentials coming off of a five-year layoff to run at age 12 and felt something needed to be done, so I contacted Gail Hirt at Beyond the Roses in Michigan and told her about the situation, hoping we could make something happen,” said Jennifer. “Gail is in close proximity to the track so she went up to the backside one morning to talk with a friend about the situation.”

Gail spoke with Kelly Spanabel, whom she had known for years and worked with in the past to help rehome horses. Kelly offered to speak with the horse's trainer, Ernesto Scarpetta, to let him know that Beyond the Roses would be willing to take in the aging gelding if he were inclined to retire him, but the trainer declined. That was Plan A and it was a fail.

Gail moved onto Plan B, which was to contact the horse's owner about retiring him, but she too declined, stating that she loved the horse and wanted to run him a few more times before retiring him.

“I do think she loved the horse, but I believe she had a different opinion of what was in his best interest than myself, Jennifer, and the rest of us did,” said Gail.

Gail needed a new plan. She was in the shed row of Kelly and her longtime partner, trainer George Iacovacci, hoping they might have some insight or ideas about the situation.

“I met George and Kelly about twelve years ago when I was with another aftercare group and kept up a relationship with them when I started Beyond the Roses,” said Gail. “I was talking with them about the horse and the situation.”

George and Kelly were of the same opinion that the horse should not be back at the races after such a lengthy layoff and at his advanced age.

“I know the horse's prior connections. Five years ago, his trainer retired him to be a riding horse. He wanted to make sure he had a good life after racing,” said Kelly Spanabel.

The group felt that something needed to be done and it looked like claiming him was the way to do it, but the question of how to pay for it was a big one.

“I cannot in good conscience take four-thousand dollars, which to us is a large sum of money that can sustain our herd for some time, to pay for a claim for a single horse – it is against our policy for how we use our funds,” Gail said.

Little did they know, but George and Kelly's son, Fredrick, had been listening intently to the conversation and developing a plan of his own.

“I'll claim the horse,” said Fredrick, who has amassed roughly $15,000 dollars in winnings from Finn B Cool in 2016.

The words hung in the air for several seconds.

As the trio grasped the reality of what the 12-year-old was suggesting, he explained his reasoning, stating that maybe if the horse can be recuperated and retrained, he could even eventually be sold as a riding horse, as the family does with many of their own horses. It was a business decision as much as an ethical one.

“He went on to explain to us that he had made some money with his racehorse this year and he would like to use some of it to help a horse in need of being helped,” said Gail.

And with that, the group had their Plan C.

A Good Day for a Claim
On July 2, 2016, Good Credentials went to post in the second race at Hazel Park, a $4,000 claiming event going four furlongs for 3-year-olds and upward which had not won a race in 2015 and 2016. He was the oldest of six horses by several years and finished fourth by just under ten lengths.

There was a lone claim submitted for the race. As Good Credentials crossed the wire that day, the claim was validated and he became the property of Fredrick Ryan Spanabel – who was the same age as the horse he'd just bought – with his father, George A. Iacovacci listed as the new trainer of record.

Fredrick and his father took possession of the horse when he came back after the race and the family was celebrating with hugs, high fives and photos.

“Fredrick, his parents and sister were all there celebrating and showering their new horse with affection and peppermints,” said Gail, who also attended the race. “But the horse's former owner and trainer were very angry that the horse had been claimed. The trainer was yelling at George, the owner was yelling and upset. It was quite a scene.”

Rumors quickly began circulating that Good Credential's former connections were going to lodge a formal complaint with Hazel Park's stewards to contest the claim.

“How can you contest a claim? Both the owner and trainer were licensed. It is valid,” said Jennifer Wirth, who is not only an equine advocate and attorney but has also owned racehorses. “Soon after, George was told that there was indeed going to be a stewards' hearing regarding the claim of Good Credentials. I offered to represent him for free. I wanted to set a legal precedent that you can claim a horse for retirement purposes.”

The Stewards' Hearing
The hearing took place in front of the Hazel Park Stewards on July 8th and lasted roughly an hour. George appeared with Jennifer Wirth as his representative.

Prior to the hearing, Wirth visited the stable to talk to the family.

“It's a nice family stable. They all work together to get things done. Kelly and her daughter, Skylar, exercise the horses in the mornings, Kelly's dad acts as the shed row foreman, George trains and they all pitch in to clean stalls, rub horses, feed and whatnot,” said Jennifer. “As they showed me around and introduced me to their horses, they let me feed them treats and told me stories about each one. They were all very friendly and well cared for. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but I was definitely impressed.”

She also got the grand tour of Fredrick's menagerie of patients – animals he has found or people have brought to him that need help.

“This kid is awesome. He's running a critter rescue out of the stable, taking care of pigeons who break their wings or a raccoon who lost its mom. He feeds them and nurses them back to health and they love him. It's really cute,” said Jennifer.

When the hearing began, Fredrick, Kelly and Skylar waited outside in case the stewards wanted to call them as witnesses.  Wirth wanted to make sure all parties were available for questioning.  

“It wasn't until the hearing that we actually learned the grounds for the complaint for the first time,” said Jennifer. “George had horses running the next evening and was worried that they had inadvertently done something wrong by doing what he and his family felt was the ethical and right thing to do – claim the old horse. He knew he could potentially have his trainer's license suspended or revoked and wouldn't be able to run his horses or earn a living to support his family and their stable.”

The stewards asked George questions about the motivation and validity of claim, and why, of all of the horses at Hazel Park and elsewhere, some of which are 12 years old or even older and still racing, his client/son chose to claim this particular horse.

“George explained to them that he and Kelly teach their children to be kind and respectful to animals and find their best use. This horse was retired five years ago for a reason. In his and his owner's/son's opinion, Good Credentials was not fit to race. He may well be ideal for, and from a business standpoint, even someday hold increased value for a different use,” said Jennifer.

Good Credentials enjoys his new surroundings

Good Credentials enjoys his new surroundings

The steward's decided that, based on the information and testimony given, the claim was legal and would be upheld. 

When contacted, the Michigan Gaming Control Board offered the following statement:

The MGCB reviewed and denied a horse claim challenge following a July 2 claiming race at Hazel Park Raceway. Stewards held a hearing July 8, and the horse's former trainer was served with their decision upholding the claim July 12. The former trainer has 10 days to appeal the stewards' ruling.


The 12-year-old horse, Good Credentials, was entered in the July 2 claiming race.

“The stewards did an excellent job,” said Jennifer. “The majority of the stewards' questions focused on what Fredrick intended to do with the horse, where the horse was currently located – they were very concerned about the well-being of the horse. To ensure the horse would never run again, part of the stewards' ruling was that George and Fredrick will fill out the Permanently Retired from Racing paperwork with The Jockey Club, which they are happy to do.

“A lot of people undermine what this trainer went through to do this. He put his license on the line for this issue, and his son's license, and they were both very aware of the possible ramifications of that. That's a big thing to do to put your entire livelihood on the line to do the right thing for a horse.”

The Future is Bright
After the hearing, it was back to work for George and his family, as they had five horses running that weekend at Hazel Park, including Fredrick's filly, Finn B Cool. With his mom in the saddle and his dad by his side, Fredrick cheered his filly to a 3/4-length victory on July 9, which added just over $3,000 – the winner's share of the purse – into his owner's account.

As for Good Credentials, he is enjoying his second retirement at the farm of Gail Hirt. Hirt, in an effort to help the boy, has allowed him to let the horse down from racing at her stable.

“He's just a good old boy – really easy-going and just a good guy,” said Gail. “He didn't look to be racing fit when he arrived and already looks and acts like he's been off of the track for a while. He has a little bit of arthritis, but no major health issues. He's going to get the next few months to just relax and then we'll see what he might enjoy doing as a second career.”

Fredrick is looking forward to playing a part in the retraining process with Good Credentials when the time comes.

“We are so proud of him and what he did – everyone at the racetrack is,” said Kelly. “He has integrity. He loves animals. He has a passion for doing what is right by them and wants to be a vet when he grows up. I could not be more proud of him.”

Jen Roytz is a marketing, publicity and comprehensive communications specialist based in Lexington, Kentucky. A native of Cleveland, Ohio, her professional focus lies in the fields of equine, health care, corporate and non-profit marketing. She holds board affiliations with the Make a Wish Foundation, Thoroughbred Aftercare Alliance and the Retired Racehorse Project, among others. While she currently has no plans to build an arc, she is the go-to food source for two dogs, two cats and two off-track Thoroughbreds.

Email Jen your story ideas at [email protected] or connect with her on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Twitter Twitter
Paulick Report on Instagram