Posts Tagged ‘tracy farmer’
Tuesday, October 28th, 2008
Ray Paulick will be live blogging the meeting of Kentucky Gov. Steve Beshear’s Task Force on the Future of Horse Racing at 1 p.m. Eastern today. The Task Force meeting takes place at Keeneland. Following is the agenda:
Opening remarks from Task Force chairman Tracy Famer
Discussion regarding Proper Staffing and
Funding Levels of the KHRC Ellen Hesen
Discussion regarding Industry Financial Matters Nick Nicholson
Discussion regarding Integrity of Racing
and Pari-mutuel activities Edward Bonnie
Discussion regarding Laboratory Facilities
in Kentucky Robert Beck Jr.
1:15 p.m. … Late starting, but Task Force chairman Tracy Farmer calls the meeting to order and announces that there is a quorum, Steve Sexton of Churchill Downs being the only apparent no show. That’s better than the last Task Force meeting I covered, when a subcommittee on integrity failed to attract a quorum.
1:20 p.m. … Quarter Horse racing now has a representative on the Task Force, Ed Ashcraft, who talked briefly about a Quarter Horse meeting held on the Polytrack at Turfway Park this year. He called it a success and said something about people like Wayne Lukas and Bob Baffert, who used to train Quarter Horses. Relevance?
1:25 p.m. … Sexton arrives. Must have got a speeding ticket on I-64 coming over from Louisville.
1:28 p.m. … Ellen Hesen reported on the proper staffing and funding levels for the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission and source of funding. She’s not talking loud enough for anyone to hear her, but we know what she’s saying: the commission needs more staff and more money.
1:29 p.m. … Someone in the audience asks the speakers to talk louder so that people can hear what they are saying. Amen!
1:29 p.m. … Correction on Sexton. No speeding ticket. He went to Fasig-Tipton instead. Keeneland president Nick Nicholson hopes that’s not an omen.
1:30 p.m. … Speaking of Nicholson, he takes the floor to offer his report on the subcommitte on industry financial matters. It’s a huge industry, he says, with $4 billion in economic impact and between 80,000-100,000 jobs. He’s done this PowerPoint thing before. Very professional. (Click here to read his entire report.)… "It should not surprise us that other states are coming after what we have," says Nicholson. "The competition for horses in other jurisdictions is probably at an all-time high. … Racing secretaries (in other states) are pressuring trainers not to ship their horses to Kentucky. … Alternative gaming has fueled dramatic increases in purses in other states. .. Breeders are moving broodmares and stallions to others states." In short, we are headed straight to hell.
1:35 p.m. … In big bold type: "PURSES ARE KEY MEASURE OF COMPETITIVENESS," say Nicholson. They lead to better horses, higher quality racing, which attract more fans and betting handle and a better simulcast product that people bet more money on. Total purses in Kentucky have not grown in recent years, Nicholson says. All states where purses are growing have alternative gaming, he adds."Slot machines at New York tracks will dramatically alter Kentucky racing. … Illinois racetrack will soon begin receiving riverboat subsidies…of $75 million. … The Illinois condition books will be stronger than they have been in years. … Purses in Indiana will double from slots from 2006 to 2008."
1:40 p.m. .. Nicholson puts up a map like one of those red states/blue states maps showing the electoral count, in the presidential except its slots states and hobo states. The slots states are taking over racing.
1:43 p.m. … If you like bar graphs and electoral maps, Nicholson’s presentation is a dandy. But it’s also downright depressing. It’s clear that our wagons have to be removed from horses and hitched to slot machines.
1:45 p.m. … More depressing news. Pennsylvania will be the center of the Thoroughbred world by 2009. Purses will be $166 million, a 400% increase from 2006. Pennsylvania’s purses will even be better than New York’s. Looks like Kentucky polilticians better legalize moonshine or medicinal marijuana to replace the lost Thoroughbred business that’s a comin’ round the corner.
1:48 p.m. … Still, Nicholson says Kentucky is the only "exporter" of Thoroughbreds in the U.S., that other states focus on having their horses competing against each other in restricted state-bred races, and that Kentucky-bred horses are competitive on a world stage. Check mark to Kentucky.
1:49 p.m. … The Kentucky Thoroughbred Development Fund is shrinking like a horse coming off steroids, one chart shows. The amount of awards have dropped by 25% from over $8 million in 2002 to less than $6 million this year. Erase that check mark.
1:51 p.m. … Pennsylvania again. Their breeders funds have jumped from $8 million to $15 million. Nicholson runs through other states with breeders fund programs. Louisiana and New Mexico up. New York heading up soon. There is a saying here in Kentucky about the national ranking of our state’s education system: "Thank God for Mississippi." Nicholson doesn’t say it, but when he shows how pitiful the California bred breeding fund is, you can almost hear the people in the room say, ‘Thank God for California."
1:55 p.m. … "This subcommittee’s been a wakeup call for us," Nicholson concludes. He talks about a deluge of competition from other states and says, "We cannot afford the status quo." Ellis Park owner Ron Geary talked about all the new slot machines at Indiana tracks he saw on a visit there. Then he said he went to Philadelphia Park to see the slots. "I came back completely stunned about what kind of competition we have," Geary said. "We’d better get on-track or we’re going to get left behind."
2:00 p.m. … Ned Bonnie, the attorney who chairs the subcommittee on integrity, gave a lawyerly report on his panel’s meeting that focused on how to make sure wagering is stopped when it’s supposed to (i.e., once a race begins). He reviewed the presentations from the meeting and then moved on to talking about backstretch "shakedowns" of trainers and veterinarians. He seems to intimate that harness tracks are doing a better job of surveillance and searches, citing a recent search at the Red Mile of two veterinary trucks during which some prohibited substasnces were found. "The responsibilities on the integrity issues vis a vis medication issues have been delegated to the Equine Drug Council," Bonnie said, "and they have assumed the responsibility of talking about integrity related to the medication issue."
2:05 p.m. … Another attorney, Bob Beck Jr., is head of the laboratory facilities subcommittee. "There is a great deal of support for establishing a (drug testing) laboratory in Kentucky," he says. "If we’re not going to do a lab that isn’t world class, it isn’t worth pursuing," he added. Beck said it will be important to hire a lab director, he added.
2:10 p.m. Chairman Farmer thanks all of the committee chairs for their reports and says, "The task force is moving forward very forcefully. We intend to meet Nov. 25 in Frankfort, hopefully with a conclusion of all these committees and combine them into one report, which we will give to the governor."
Meeting adjourned.
Copyright © 2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world.
Tags: bob beck, churchill downs, edward bonnie, ellen hesen, Keeneland, kentucky horse racing task force, ned bonnie, nick nicholson, racinos, robert beck jr., ron geary, Slot machines, steve beshear task force on the future of horse racing, steve sexton, tracy farmer
Posted in Kentucky, Regulatory Issues | 10 Comments »
Tuesday, October 7th, 2008
By Ray Paulick
People are making and cancelling bets on horses after races have begun. Let me repeat that: PEOPLE ARE MAKING AND CANCELLING BETS ON HORSES AFTER RACES HAVE BEGUN. Does anyone have a problem with that?
Apparently, several members appointed to a subcommittee on integrity that is part of a Task Force on the Future of Horse Racing in Kentucky aren’t all that concerned about the issue. The integrity subcommittee couldn’t even muster a quorum when three of its six voting members failed to show up for the panel’s first meeting at the offices of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission on Monday afternoon.
At the outset of the meeting, subcommittee chairman Ned Bonnie (a member of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission) said the panel was poised to take action on integrity issues until he was reminded by the commission’s executive director, Lisa Underwood, that a quorum wasn’t present.
Bonnie was joined by subcommittee members Robert Beck Jr. (an attorney and chairman of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission) and Robert Vance, the secretary of Kentucky’s Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet. But missing were racing commission vice-chairman Tracy Farmer (chairman of the Task Force on the Future of Horse Racing and a Thoroughbred owner and breeder), Louisville real estate developer Brian Lavin and Paducah, Ky., attorney Duncan Pitchford.
It’s no wonder that some are referring to this entire exercise proposed by Kentucky Gov. Steve Beshear as a “task farce.”
Bonnie was disappointed at the no-shows, to be sure, but how do you think horseplayers feel? They are the ones, after all, whose confidence has been eroded by an archaic totalizator system with flaws that are being exploited by techno-savvy thieves; off-shore rebate shops that are virtually unregulated; a patchwork network of simulcast sites that answer to 38 different regulatory bodies; and ineffective rules, many of which were written for the good old days when the only bets made took place on track with a live teller.
For anyone not paying attention, the volume of pari-mutuel handle on horse racing is down this year by roughly 5%. It’s not just a Kentucky problem. By year’s end, total pari-mutuel handle in the United States may very well dip below $14 billion for the first time since 1999. That’s 10 years of stagnation.
We can blame the economy or competition from other forms of entertainment and gambling. Or we can ask our customers, which the National Thoroughbred Racing Association recently did, as to why they are not pushing as many dollars into the pari-mutuel pools as they used to. According to Keith Chamblin, the NTRA executive who outlined the consumer research at an industry conference, the attitudes of racing’s best customers can be summed up in five words: “Our core fans are pissed.”
Consumers are pissed because they feel cheaters continue to win races at an alarming rate by using performance enhancing drugs. They are convinced people are making or cancelling bets after races begin. And they see racing commissions and task forces and blue ribbon panels as pointless exercises conducted by mindless political appointees who are too out of tune to understand the problems or too apathetic to fix them.
That may or may not be the case with Kentucky’s Task Force and its various subcommittees. It should be noted that a majority of the ex officio non-voting members of the integrity subcommittee were on hand, including owner-breeder Gary Biszantz, professional horseplayer Mike Maloney and businessman Frank Kling, who spent a great deal of time and effort working on wagering integrity issues as a member of the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority, a panel dissolved by Beshear earlier this year and replaced with the current racing commission. All three spoke up in ways that indicate they understand the problems and sense the urgency in addressing them.
But the ex officio members can’t vote on any action items addressed by the integrity subcommittee. That’s up to the six voting members to do – if and when they show up for a meeting.
In the meantime, the entire Task Force should remember those five chilling words repeated by Chamblin: “Our core fans are pissed.”
The ball is in the court of the Kentucky Task Force and regulators, track operators, account wagering companies and others throughout this country.
What are they going to do address the concerns of racing’s best customers?
Copyright © 2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world.
Tags: brian lavin, duncan pitchford, frank kling, gary biszantz, Horse Racing, integrity subcommittee, keith chamblin, kentucky horse racing, kentucky horse racing commission, kentucky racing, lisa underwood, mike maloney, National Thoroughbred Racing Association, ned bonnie, NTRA, pari-mutuel betting, pari-mutuel handle, pari-mutuel wagering, pari-mutuels, Paulick Report, Ray Paulick, robert beck jr., robert vance, steve beshear, task force on the future of horse racing, totalizator, Tote System, tracy farmer
Posted in Horse Racing, Industry Organizations, Industry Reform, Kentucky, National Thoroughbred Racing Association, Regulatory Issues, Simulcasting, Wagering | 16 Comments »
Tuesday, September 30th, 2008
By Ray Paulick
The horse business is Kentucky’s signature industry, employing tens of thousands of people, generating over a billion dollars of revenue throughout the year, and putting the international spotlight on the Commonwealth each spring at the Kentucky Derby. Yet, in many ways, legislators and other government officials have been dealing with the industry almost as an afterthought.
Tax breaks given to lesser industries have not been granted to farmers whose agricultural product happens to be a horse instead of a cow. Kentucky’s legislature was late to the party to create an incentive fund to reward breeders for doing business in the Bluegrass State rather than shipping their breeding stock (and jobs) out of state where more lucrative incentives have been created. And now, one of the most troublesome challenges the racing industry faces – questions about the integrity of the sport and its pari-mutuel wagering foundation – has been hampered by ongoing budgetary shortfalls at the state agency that regulates racing.
Simply put, the integrity of racing in Kentucky is being jeopardized by indifference by some at the legislative and executive level to properly fund the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission.
The problem goes back nearly eight years ago to the administration of Gov. Paul Patton, who cut $1 million dollars – nearly one-third – out of what was then known as the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority. Frank Shoop, then the chairman of the regulatory body, told the Paulick Report he thought the cuts were temporary and would be restored; they weren’t. Instead, the Racing Authority began assessing racetracks as much as $3,500 a day to pay for many of the functions that would previously have been funded by the state. “It’s so important to the signature industry of the state,” Shoop said. “They should have proper money to regulate the industry: transportation, insurance and other departments have proper regulatory budgets. This department has been short of money and short of money for years.
“I don’t know what the proper funding action should be,” Shoop added, “but something needs to be done that the legislature and governor can agree on.”
If something isn’t done, the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission will run out of money by Jan. 1, according to Tracy Farmer, a Thoroughbred owner and breeder and high-level operative in the Democratic Party that helped elect Gov. Steve Beshear last November. Farmer was named by Beshear to the current horse racing commission, where he serves as vice chairman, and is heading up a special Task Force on the Future of Horse Racing examining numerous issues related to racing and breeding.
Farmer told the Paulick Report that Kentucky’s General Assembly had $2 million set aside for the racing commission for the current fiscal year but they subsequently “raided our accounts to balance the (state) budget.” Farmer said he and others are looking at ways to fund the commission through such revenue items as the tax on claiming horses, which he estimated generates $2 million per year. “Money is being generated that’s not being put back into the industry,” Farmer said. “We’re looking at several different methodologies and will recommend one of them. This is the largest industry in the state. We have to fund the people who oversee it.”
State Sen. Damon Thayer, a Republican from Georgetown and a consultant in the racing industry who helped create the breeders’ incentive fund through existing revenue drawn from the tax on stallion seasons, pushed for legislation that would have Kentucky’s General Fund provide for the commission’s budget. That legislation failed, Thayer said, despite bi-partisan efforts to get it passed.
“The racetracks are struggling, the commission is without money, and the state is in a budget crisis,” Thayer said. “We need more money for the commission to have boots on the ground to do their job. And we were saying this before Eight Belles and Big Brown.”
The death of Eight Belles in this year’s Kentucky Derby and the admission by trainer Rick Dutrow that Derby winner Big Brown raced on anabolic steroids (then legal) has prompted an outcry for tighter regulations, stricter medication rules, and more comprehensive drug testing. Anabolic steroids have recently been banned in Kentucky and several other states, and that ban requires additional testing be added to the existing drug testing program.
Thayer plans to introduce new legislation during the next session of the General Assembly.
“What needs to happen is Gov. Beshear needs to get behind legislation drafted by Sen. Ed Worley (D-Richmond) and me that would set up a reliable, recurring source of revenue for the racing commission so the tracks do not pay for drug testing and their own regulation. The racing commission needs to be funded by the pari-mutuel excise tax so we can expand drug testing to a respectable level.”
According to Thayer, the pari-mutuel tax currently helps fund the Kentucky Thoroughbred Development Fund, equine drug research and the University of Louisville’s equine business program.
The lack of funding came to a head at a recent meeting of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission when it was disclosed testing was not conducted for performance-enhancing milkshakes (TCO2 levels or bicarbonate loading) at Ellis Park this summer because of a personnel shortage. Since that disclosure, the commission’s chief veterinarian resigned his position.
“We were shocked to learn that no testing was conducted,” said Farmer.
It may have taken weeks for commission members to learn that there was no testing for milkshakes, but trainers probably knew instantly, permitting cheaters to prosper. The absence of testing shook the confidence of many horseplayers about whether the state is doing enough to stop performance-enhancing drugs from giving an edge to some trainers.
The racing commission’s executive director, Lisa Underwood, who was hired during the previous administration of Republican Gov. Ernie Fletcher, has plans to expand the size of the staff if funding is provided. She has submitted a plan to add investigators, state veterinarians and other full and part-time staff to better regulate racing and ensure its integrity.
Ed Martin, president of the Association of Racing Commissioners International, told the Task Force on the Future of Horse Racing when he became aware of how little was committed to Kentucky’s commission that he was “shocked at how low a priority the integrity of racing apparently was, especially considering how important the racing industry is to the state’s economy and identity.”
Martin compiled a study of how much is committed to integrity issues in other major racing states and found that Kentucky, “instead of being first, is last.”
His study showed Kentucky commits $7,692 per race day, less than half of the $17,948 committed by Florida for integrity enforcement. Martin said the Kentucky commission is sorely lacking investigators to monitor backstretch activities. Kentucky has two investigators, he said, compared with 14 in New York, 15 in Pennsylvania, 17 in Florida, and 18 in California.
“ Perhaps the most glaring weakness in the funding can be seen in the fact that no resources have been dedicated to policing the pari-mutuel system,” Martin said.“Kentucky in the past has dedicated nothing in this area while other major racing states have made a considerable commitment in this area, not only in terms of staff, but to ensure that an independent computerized monitoring system is deployed to protect against past posting, odds manipulations, cyber crime, and larceny. In public forum after public forum, large bettors have expressed a growing concern about the lack of commitment to wagering security.
“ While some states have committed as many as six people to wagering security and made arrangements for independent monitoring, Kentucky has yet to commit one.”
Many bettors are convinced the technology used in today’s pari-mutuel wagering system is archaic and able to be exploited by techno-savvy players who are making bets after the gates to a race have been opened. One member of the Kentucky Racing Commission who asked not to be named agreed: “There is no question people are betting after the horses are out of the gate,” he said. “They are somehow getting into the pool. It’s frightening.”
Copyright © 2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world.
Tags: association of racing commissioners international, bicarbonate loading, Big Brown, bluegrass state, churchill downs, damon thayer, drug testing, ed martin, ed worley, eight belles, ellis park, ernie fletcher, frank shoop, Horse Racing, Keeneland, kentucky horse racing, kentucky horse racing authority, kentucky horse racing commission, kentucky thoroughbred development fund, lisa underwood, pari-mutuel wagering, paul patton, Paulick Report, Ray Paulick, RCI, steve beshear, task force on the future of horse racing, tco2, thoroughbred racing, tracy farmer, turfway park, university of louisville equiine business program, wagering integrity
Posted in Horse Racing, Industry Organizations, Kentucky, Medication, Regulatory Issues, Tote System, Wagering | 2 Comments »
Sunday, July 27th, 2008
By Ray Paulick
Saratoga opens, and so do the skies.
That sums up the first several days of the upstate New York Spa’s business, which is not good news for a bankrupt organization that says it will need more bailout money from the state sometime in the next couple of months. Heavy rains washed away numerous turf races and showers even made an unscheduled appearance on Whitney day.
The NYRA has survived far worse weather patterns, including the near-perfect storm of a federal indictment, bankruptcy and a franchise renewal drama whose end-game could have led to a game of "musical boxes" on the front row of those cherished clubhouse seats at Saratoga. In the end, power and tradition won the day for the old guard, thanks to some new guard knee-capping by the dynamic NYRA chairman, Steve Duncker, a Wall Street fightin’ man originally from the anything but hardscrabble suburbs of St. Louis (west, not east St. Loo).
Fortunately for NYRA’s trustees and executives, there are some people around who make them look human, led by the husband-wife team of John Hendrickson and Marylou Whitney, who took backstretch philanthropy into their own hands (with assistance from a group of local businesses and horsemen) by providing weekly banquets and nightly movies for the stable hands.
BUT THE EARTH DOESN’T ACTUALLY CIRCLE around Saratoga in July and August (though some may think it does). There’s also Del Mar, whose first-week business declines had the guys in Hawaiian shirts and sandals looking very grim until a gigantic wave of Pick Six mania washed ashore on the July 26-27 weekend, contributing (along with a free concert and micro-brew festival) to the ninth-highest handle in track history. No one picked all six winners and $1.5 million carries over into Sunday’s Pick Six, promising to make that program a big one, too.
Purse cuts looked imminent, but maybe the surge can work where the Turf meets the Surf.
Incidentally, Del Mar won the head-to-head battle of the gate against Saratoga on Saturday, 32,291 at Del Mar to 29,655 at Saratoga. Saratoga won the handle bout, $25,017,333 at Saratoga to $20,531,679 at Del Mar. Del Mar’s numbers were way up from 2007, when just 24,873 attended on the same day. Saratoga’s were down 9.7% in handle and 5.9% in attendance from 2007 when 31,510 were on hand for the first "Win and You’re In" day and handle was $27,708,217.
HIALEAH PARK’S John Brunetti was among those in the large Del Mar crowd on Saturday (he lives in nearby Rancho Santa Fe). Brunetti told the Paulick Report that he is hoping to bring live racing back to Hialeah Park on his own accord and doesn’t need the help of Halsey Minor, the cash-rich, Internet-savvy Virginian who actually is willing to invest tens of millions of his own cyber dollars into not only reopening Hialeah Park but making it a showplace.
Poor old Mr. B (it could stand for "beleaguered") just doesn’t get it. Brunetti seems to be a very nice man, but he’s been consistently outfoxed by Doug Donn, Ken Dunn, Churchill Downs and even Frank Stronach in the South Florida racing wars, and his same old "woe is me" song to state legislators isn’t going to change things for the better. He hasn’t run a live race at Hialeah since 2001, and he ran many horseplayers years earlier when he jacked up the takeout to unprecedented rates following deregulation.
But there is an unmistakable opportunity to bring Hialeah Park back if Brunetti is willing to put his ego and bluster aside. He could ride off into the sunset a hero as the man who kept the Hialeah Park dream alive long enough for the new sheriff to come into town and clean up.
The Paulick Report will have more on Hialeah and Halsey Minor in the coming week.
DID I MENTION EGO AND BLUSTER? That leads me to Aurora, Ontario, Canada, home of Magna Entertainment, which lost another top manager last week with the resignation of Scott Borgemenke, the vice president of racing. This management change was another in a long line of executive exits in Frank Stronach’s empire detailed in the Paulick Report.
Stronach does some things right … breeding horses, for example. His champion filly, Ginger Punch, was one of the on-track stars at Saratoga during the Breeders’ Cup’s "Win and You’re In" telecast on ABC Saturday afternoon (which featured an entertaining back-and-back forth between Michael Iavarone and Rick Dutrow, the owner-trainer team that handles Big Brown). In winning the Go for Wand under tough circumstances (every jockey in the race tried to keep her boxed up), the daughter of Awesome Again displayed the kind of guts and determination every breeder would like to see in his or her horses. She was impressive.
So was Tracy and Carol Farmer’s 7-year-old Commentator, who ran away with the Whitney in powerful fashion. Hall of Fame trainer Nick Zito said the win was one of the high points of his own career and puts the New York-bred gelding by Distorted Humor in the same league as Kelso and Forego, two legendary geldings from the past.
Heady company indeed.
Copyright ©2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for the Paulick Report’s Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick.
Tags: Breeders' Cup, commentator, Del Mar, Frank Stronach, ginger punch, Halsey Minor, Hialeah Park, john brunetti, john hendrickson, Magna Entertainment, marylou whitney, Michael Iavarone, New York Racing Association, nyra, Paulick Report, pick six carryover, Ray Paulick, rick dutrow, saratoga, steve duncker, tracy farmer, win and you're in
Posted in Week in Review | 2 Comments »
Monday, July 14th, 2008
On the surface, it seems unfathomable that the 40-some members and trustees, founding members and officers of the Breeders’ Cup who select the organization’s operating board of directors could have rejected Richard Santulli, whose business acumen is such that he is on the short list of candidates to succeed Warren Buffett, the “oracle of Omaha,” as chairman of Berkshire Hathaway. But that’s what they did on Friday, when the group voted to fill seven positions on the 14-member board. Neither Santulli, a New Jersey-based Thoroughbred owner and breeder, or Hill ‘n’ Dale Farm owner John Sikura received enough votes to secure a board seat.
The members and trustees re-elected all five of the candidates who sought re-election to two-year terms: Breeders’ Cup board chairman Bill Farish of Lane’s End Farm, Antony Beck of Gainesway Farm, Terry Finley of West Point Thoroughbreds, racetrack and casino owner R.D. Hubbard, and Satish Sanan of Padua Stables. Two open seats, made possible when board members Robert Clay and Joseph Shields Jr. were voted off the board of members and trustees by Breeders’ Cup nominators, were filled by Helen Alexander of Middlebrook Farm and Roy Jackson of Lael Stables.
Those seven are joined on the Breeders’ Cup board by the following individuals who were elected to two-year terms in 2007: Reynolds Bell Jr., Donald Dizney, Tracy Farmer, B. Wayne Hughes, G. Watts Humphrey Jr., and Robert Manfuso. The 14th board position is filled by the Breeders’ Cup CEO, Greg Avioli.
It is widely believed that the xenophobic duo of Farish and his father, Will, the vice chairman of the Jockey Club, lobbied heavily with the members and trustees to keep Santulli and Sikura off the board. Ironically, Santulli has been a client of Lane’s End, keeping mares at the Versailles, Ky., farm. Both Santulli and Sikura have been outspoken in their criticism of various aspects of the Breeders’ Cup in recent years. NetJets, the company Santulli founded and which is now part of the Berkshire Hathaway empire, was a Breeders’ Cup sponsor for several years but did not renew its sponsorship in 2008.
New Jersey-based Thoroughbred Daily News publisher Barry Weisbord, a close associate of Santulli, is believed to have lobbied to get Santulli elected. In addition, a number of Kentucky-based members and trustees pushed for the election of Sikura.
Simply put, Farish had the most juice in this election, and sources say it wasn’t even close.
The two new board members, Alexander and Jackson, represent old money. Alexander is an heir to the massive King Ranch, which raced 1946 Triple Crown winner Assault. She is widely respected for her independence and toughness, and support for her candidacy likely reached across the various factions.
Jackson, an heir to the Standard Oil fortune through his grandfather, William D. Rockefeller, is best known as the owner-breeder with wife Gretchen of Barbaro, the Kentucky Derby winner whose injury in the Preakness and unsuccessful battle to survive was a closely followed national drama two years ago. Having the conservative and low-keyed Jackson seek election was a stroke of genius by whoever convinced him to run. He and his wife, along with trainer Michael Matz, jockey Edgar Prado and veterinary surgeon Dean Richardson, were the human elements in the Barbaro story, and the Jacksons received plaudits from all corners for their handling of the horse’s post-Preakness struggles.
I’ve never heard anyone compare Jackson’s business experience with that of Richard Santulli, or his knowledge of the horse industry with John Sikura. But he is without enemies in the business and doesn’t make waves: a sure-fire qualification for an endorsement from the Farishes.
The respect for Alexander and the affection for Jackson notwithstanding, the rejection of a highly successful businessman like Santulli is mind-boggling. If he is good enough to be a candidate to run Berkshire Hathaway, it’s almost comical to think he would not be an asset on the Breeders’ Cup board.
The only conclusion I can make is that the most influential board members, led by Bill and Will Farish, are interested only in maintaining power by preventing individuals with different points of view from getting elected.
“Billionaires run the industry,” one horseman said to me after the election. “The only way to beat them is on the racetrack.”
By Ray Paulick
Copyright ©2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick.
Tags: Antony Beck, b. wayne hughes, Barbaro, berkshire hathaway, Bill Farish, Breeders' Cup, donald dizney, g. watts humphrey jr., Greg Avioli, Helen Alexander, Horse Racing, John Sikura, Joseph Shields, king ranch, lael stables, netjets, Paulick Report, R.D. Hubbard, Ray Paulick, reynolds bell jr., richard santulli, Robert Clay, robert manfuso, Roy Jackson, satish sanan, Terry Finley, tracy farmer, Warren Buffett, Will Farish
Posted in Breeders' Cup | 7 Comments »
Thursday, July 10th, 2008
It’s become something of a tradition in Kentucky politics for newly elected governors to dissolve the regulatory body for horse racing and create their own racing board. It’s something Brereton Jones, Ernie Fletcher and now Steve Beshear have done.
Governors in most other states are content to merely fill racing commissions with their hand-picked appointees as terms expire. In Kentucky, where horse racing is the number one industry and racing commissioners can wield considerable clout, there is more of a sense of urgency by governors and their allies.
The downside to this maneuvering is continuity in the regulation of the sport, and this latest iteration by Gov. Beshear to dissolve the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority and create the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission left no indication as to whether people like John Veitch, the chief steward for racing, and executive director Lisa Underwood have job security in the new regime.
There was good work being done by some members of the KHRA, and we can only hope that it will not go by the wayside. For example, one of the Authority members who was not retained on the new board, Franklin Kling, put considerable time and effort into issues related to wagering security, particularly past-post betting, or perceptions of past-post betting. It is common now, because of delays in communications from wagering hubs to the host track, for odds to change midway through a horse race. Clearly, the tote systems are not on par with the technologies in place for online banking and securities transactions, and there remains the potential for fraud and pool manipulation.
Many horseplayers are concerned that bets are being made after the start of a race, and some racetrack executives privately fear the same thing. There have been instances in Kentucky where that’s happened on simulcast races, and professional horseplayer Mike Maloney was brought in by the Authority to advise them on the issue. The latest example appears to have occurred at Philadelphia Park recently, when the Scientific Games totalizator system malfunctioned, allowing simulcast bettors at Tampa Bay Downs and possibly other locations to place wagers during and after the running of the fourth race June 28.
Kling provided at no cost to the commission information technology personnel from his company to examine the issue of tote communications and past posting, and according to sources there was progress in that area. This is a serious issue that needs attention, and there is no reason to discard the work that Kling and other members of a wagering security committee have done.
Fortunately, the man who advised Gov. Beshear on the appointments to the new commission, Thoroughbred owner-breeder Tracy Farmer, is a sharp and highly ethical individual, knowledgeable about the industry, and perceptive about what the public expects from a regulatory body. Farmer and his wife Carol have been strong supporters of horse rescue and retraining operations, something that many people in the industry have ignored for too long.
The commission includes some members whose background does not appear to have any connection to racing and is probably nothing more than political patronage. However, the retention of attorney Robert Beck as chairman was a wise move, as was the appointment of several people with both knowledge and experience in racing matters.
One example is attorney Ned Bonnie of Louisville, who is an expert in the medication field, having helped develop regulations for the sport horse world. Bonnie has been involved in numerous industry committees and has strong opinions about cleaning up the game. His involvement in the Thoroughbred industry goes back many year and includes a close friendship and association with the late Kent Hollingsworth, the esteemed, longtime editor of Bloodhorse magazine whose "hat, oats and water" mantra Bonnie had emblazoned on a sweatshirt that he frequently wore while jogging.
Farmer appears to have advised Beshear to balance the board with diverse views. Trainer John Ward has fought for tighter restrictions on medications while heading the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association and Frank Jones has been a voice for the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, which tried to keep Kentucky’s permissive medication rules intact. The inclusion of a veterinarian, Foster Northrup, is another move that will diversify the board’s makeup.
The best news came on Wednesday, when the new commissioners were sworn in, and Beck and Farmer indicated that they intend to pursue regulations for anabolic steroids.Steroids have been one of the sport’s dirty little secrets. There will be efforts to keep their use legal in Kentucky, and some veterinarians may say that their use benefits the health and welfare of the horse. But public perception is very important, and right now horse racing is losing that battle in a very big way. It’s time for steroids to be banned: period.
The political tradition by newly elected Kentucky governors to dissolve racing commissions and create new spots for political supporters can lead to problems. Fortunately, the people involved in the process in 2008 have the best interests of racing at heart.
Let’s hope there is a seamless transition. People who regulate Kentucky racing should be looked upon as national leaders. That hasn’t always been the case.
By Ray Paulick
Copyright ©2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick.
Tags: brereton jones, ernie fletcher, foster northrup, frank jones, franklin kling, john veitch, john ward, kent hollingsworth, kentucky horse racing authority, kentucky horse racing commission, lisa underwood, mike maloney, ned bonnie, past-posting, Paulick Report, ray paulick horse racing, robert beck, steve beshear, tracy farmer
Posted in Industry Organizations, Kentucky, Regulatory Issues | Comments Off
Wednesday, July 9th, 2008
Phone lines in Central Kentucky have been burning up among the nearly 50 incumbent and newly elected members and trustees of the Breeders’ Cup, who will be responsible for electing seven individuals to the 14 member operating board of directors in Lexington, Ky., on Friday.
Five members of the board — Antony Beck, current board chairman Bill Farish Jr., Terry Finley, R.D. Hubbard and Satish Sanan - are up for re-election, and all five are expected to seek a new two-year term. There are two open positions previously held by Robert Clay and Joseph Shields Jr., who lost re-election bids to the members and trustees board, voting for which was conducted in June among all Breeders’ Cup program nominators. Clay was vice chairman of the Breeders’ Cup board of directors.
John Sikura is the only new name that has surfaced as a "declared" candidate for a board seat, though others will certainly will develop by Friday’s meeting.
In the meantime, numerous phone calls are being made by members of two distinct camps seeking proxies and support in advance of what figures to be a hotly contested election for control of the Breeders’ Cup. In previous elections
Here are the members and trustees listed on the Breeders’ Cup web site or last week’s election results: Josephine Abercrombie, Helen Alexander, John Amerman, Gregory C. Avioli, James E. Bassett III, Antony Beck, Reynolds Bell Jr., Boyd Browning Jr., Doug Cauthen, Alice Chandler, Brownell Combs II, Donald R. Dizney, William S. Farish, William S. Farish Jr., Tracy Farmer, Terrence P. Finley, James E. Friess, Thomas Gaines, Lucy Young Hamilton, L. William Heiligbrodt, R.D. Hubbard, B. Wayne Hughes, G. Watts Humphrey Jr., Roy Jackson, Brereton C. Jones, John T.L. Jones Jr., John T.L. Jones III, Tom Ludt, Wayne G. Lyster III, Robert T. Manfuso, Robert McNair, Clem Murphy, Maria Niarchos-Gouaze, Charles C. Nuckols III, J. Michael O’Farrell Jr., Bill Oppenheim, James A. Philpott Jr., Ogden Mills Phipps, Dan Pride, Don Robinson, Satish K. Sanan, Richard T. Santulli, John G. Sikura, Frank Stronach, Mark Taylor, D.G. Van Clief Jr., Charlotte Weber, Barry Weisbord, and Christopher Young.
By Ray Paulick
Copyright ©2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick.
Tags: Alice Chandler, Antony Beck, b. wayne hughes, Barry Weisbord, Bill Oppenheim, Boyd Browning Jr., Breeders' Cup, Breeders' Cup board of directors, Brereton C. Jones, Brownell Combs II, Charles C. Nuckols III, Charlotte Weber, Christopher Young, Clem Murphy, D.G. Van Clief Jr., Dan Pride, Don Robinson, Donald R. Dizney, Doug Cauthen, Frank Stronach, g. watts humphrey jr., Gregory C. Avioli, Helen Alexander, J. Michael O'Farrell Jr., James A. Philpott Jr., James E. Bassett III, James E. Friess, John Amerman, John G. Sikura, John T.L. Jones III, John T.L. Jones Jr., Josephine Abercrombie, L. William Heiligbrodt, Lucy Young Hamilton, Maria Niarchos-Gouaze, Mark Taylor, Ogden Mills Phipps, Paulick Report, R.D. Hubbard, Ray Paulick, reynolds bell jr., Richard T. Santulli, Robert McNair, Robert T. Manfuso, Roy Jackson, Satish K. Sanan, Terrence P. Finley, Thomas Gaines, tom ludt, tracy farmer, Wayne G. Lyster III, William S. Farish, William S. Farish Jr.
Posted in Breeders' Cup | Comments Off
Thursday, July 3rd, 2008
The startling election results for the Breeders’ Cup board of members and trustees conducted among nominators to the program teaches us one thing about this relatively new process: no single farm or entity can stack the board with its own candidates.
That is driven home by the fact that Robert Clay of Three Chimneys Farms, the current vice chairman of the Breeders’ Cup board of directors (the 14-person board elected by the 48 members and trustees), did not receive enough votes to retain his spot as a member/trustee. It is confirmed again by the election loss of James McAlpine, a longtime Magna executive associated with Frank Stronach, who presumably would have thrown the considerable clout of his Adena Springs Farm behind McAlpine in the Breeders’ Cup election process that Stronach himself helped bring about through reforms in governance several years ago. (Those reforms were detailed in a two part series in the Paulick Report: Part 1, Part 2). In voting conducted during the month of June, Breeders’ Cup nominators received one vote for every $500 they paid in foal or stallion nominations. Stallion farms with the high-end stud fees obviously hold the most votes, since a $100,000 stud fee would give a farm 200 votes in the process. Yet even with a Three Chimneys stallion roster that currently includes $460,000 in annual “published” stud fees (and, thus, 920 votes, theoretically), Clay was unable to secure enough votes to retain his seat on the board of members and trustees.
As a result, Clay, who has served on numerous industry organization boards over the last 25 years, will not be eligible to run for re-election to a two-year term on the 14-member Breeders’ Cup board of directors, the group that makes the key operational decisions for the organization. That election will be held during a meeting of the newly elected board of members and trustees in Lexington July 11. To be eligible to run for the board of directors, an individual must be on the larger board of members and trustees. Just as consensus building is necessary to get federal legislation passed in Congress, individuals seeking seats as Breeders’ Cup members/trustees must build coalitions among different groups of nominators. Clay apparently did not do that; nor did three others seeking re-election on the board of members and trustees: Robert Cromartie, Leverett Miller, and Joseph Shields, Jr.
Elected to the board of members and trustees were Helen Alexander of Middlebrook Farm; Doug Cauthen of WinStar Farm; Bill Farish Jr. of Lane’s End; Terry Finley of West Point Thoroughbreds; Lucy Young Hamilton of Overbrook Farm; Maria Niarchos-Gouaze of Poseidon Services Inc; Charles Nuckols III of Nuckols Farm; Bill Oppenheim, a bloodstock agent who writes for Thoroughbred Daily News; Don Robinson of Winter Quarter Farm; Mark Taylor of Taylor Made Farm; Charlotte Weber of Live Oak Stud; and Barry Weisbord, publisher of Thoroughbred Daily News. Of that group, Alexander, Farish, Young Hamilton, Niarchos-Gouaze, Nuckols, and Taylor were re-elected.
In addition to Clay, Cromartie McAlpine, Miller and Shields, the following nominees to the board of members and trustees did not get enough votes for election: Bobby Flay, Arnold Kirkpatrick, Allan Lavin Jr. and Ric Waldman.
Seven of the 14 board of director seats will be open for nomination during the July 11 election, including the seats that have been held by Clay and Shields, whose terms expire. With their required departure, there will be at least two new members elected. In addition, the two-year terms of Antony Beck, current board chairman Bill Farish Jr., Terry Finley, R.D. Hubbard and Satish Sanan also expire, with each eligible for re-election.
The smaller board of director positions are staggered, and the following six individuals were elected to two-year terms in July 2007: Reynolds Bell Jr., Donald Dizney, Tracy Farmer, B. Wayne Hughes, G. Watts Humphrey Jr., and Robert Manfuso. The 14th board position is filled by the Breeders’ Cup CEO, Greg Avioli.
It may be noteworthy that Clay, Miller and Shields were considered part of the “old guard,” as each are members of the Jockey Club, which for decades has tried to assert control over many industry organizations. Not everyone newly elected or re-elected to the board of members and trustees can be classified as “old guard” or “new guard,” but victories by Doug Cauthen, Bill Oppenheim and Barry Weisbord clearly indicate that efforts were made by nominators with large blocs of vote to inject new blood into the organization that runs the two-day championships scheduled to be held for the next two years during the Oak Tree Racing Association meeting at Santa Anita Park in Southern California.
What new alliances are formed among the newly seated board of members and trustees will determine who is retained, newly elected or rejected from the smaller board. That new board, to be seated in September, will determine whether Bill Farish will remain chairman and will also elect a vice chairman of the board. More importantly, the new board will control the fate of the Breeders’ Cup—at least until the next election.
By Ray Paulick
Copyright ©2008, The Paulick Report
Tags: Allan Lavin Jr., Arnold Kirkpatrick, b. wayne hughes, Barry Weisbord, Bill Farish Jr., Bill Oppenheim, Bobby Flay, Breeders' Cup, Breeders' Cup board of directors, Charles Nuckols III, Charlotte Weber, Don Robinson, donald dizney, Doug Cauthen, Frank Stronach, g. watts humphrey jr., Greg Avioli, Helen Alexander, Joseph Shields Jr., Leverett Miller, Lucy Young Hamilton, Maria Niarchos-Gouaze, Mark Taylor, Paulick Report, Ray Paulick, reynolds bell jr., Ric Waldman, Robert Clay, Robert Cromartie, robert manfuso, Terry Finley, tracy farmer
Posted in Breeders' Cup, Industry | Comments Off
|
|
