Posts Tagged ‘Summer Bird’

AND THE WINNER IS …

Monday, January 18th, 2010
By Ray Paulick
Just down the road from the Four Seasons Beverly Wilshire Hotel, site of tonight’s Eclipse Awards dinner, is beautiful downtown Burbank and the world-famous studio where the “Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson” was produced for many wonderful years after Carson and his entourage moved West from New York City. (I’ll bet NBC executives wish Johnny were still around today, given the problems the network is currently experiencing with the “Tonight Show” franchise.)

One of the most famous “Tonight Show” characters was Carnac the Magnificent, the all-knowing soothsayer and divine psychic who provided answers to questions contained in "hermetically sealed envelopes kept in a mayonnaise jar on Funk & Wagnalls porch since noon that day."

I’m no Carnac, and I’m far from magnificent, but I do know where Funk & Wagnalls live. So, after peering into the mayonnaise jar, here are my fearless predictions for tonight’s Eclipse Awards:

 
SLAM-DUNK WINNERS
- Lookin At Lucky, 2-year-old male
- Summer Bird, 3-year-old male
- Rachel Alexandra, 3-year-old female
- Zenyatta, older female
- Informed Decision, female sprinter
- Gio Ponti, turf male
- Goldikova, turf female
- Mixed Up, steeplechase
- Steve Asmussen, outstanding trainer
I suppose it’s a bit of a risk to say that Gio Ponti is a slam dunk in the male turf category, given the fact the defending champion and two-time Breeders’ Cup Turf winner Conduit will get considerable support, especially from those who voted for Gio Ponti in the wide-open older male (all surfaces) category. But I think Gio Ponti’s four Grade 1 victories at Santa Anita, Arlington and Belmont Park will get him the necessary votes to defeat Conduit.

PRETTY, KINDA SURE WINNERS

- She Be Wild, 2-year-old female
- Kodiak Kowboy, male sprinter
- Juddmonte Farms, breeder
 
I think the best performance of 2009 by a 2-year-old of either sex came from Blind Luck in her explosive victory in the Grade 1 Hollywood Starlet Stakes on Dec. 20, but the National Thoroughbred Racing Association staff was in such a rush to start their Christmas holiday they didn’t include this race (or the Grade 1 CashCall Futurity for colts) in the past performances distributed in the mail to voters. Too bad. Blind Luck had previously finished third after a troubled trip in the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Fillies, beaten three-quarters of a length by the likely champion, the once-beaten She Be Wild.

Kodiak Kowboy and Zensational each won three Grade 1 races in 2009, though two factors are going against Zensational: 1) the suspicion is that he beat up on the same horses in all three races; and 2) he was not really a factor in the Breeders’ Cup Sprint, his biggest test of the year. Kodiak Kowboy was forced to miss the Sprint after getting sick before the race, but he bounced back with a strong win in the Cigar Mile Handicap later in November. But is a one-turn mile really a sprint?

I’m going against my best judgment in picking Juddmonte, since it is the most deserving candidate among the three finalists as outstanding breeder. Voters usually don’t get this one right, but I’m counting on this year being an aberration.

TOSS-UP CATEGORIES
- Gio Ponti, older male
- Mr. and Mrs. Jerry Moss, outstanding owner
- Ramon Dominguez, outstanding jockey
- Luis Saez, outstanding apprentice jockey

Where is Carnac when I need him?

Eclipse Award voters don’t like giving the older male championship to turf horses or sprinters, but I think the addition of synthetic surfaces over the last few years has blurred the distinction somewhat. Gio Ponti clearly had the best year of the three finalists (Einstein and Kodiak Kowboy are the others), but I think he is still thought of as a turf horse, so there is a built-in resistance against him by some voters. But Einstein’s two victories were turf and synthetics, so he’s not a “dirt” horse, either, and Kodiak Kowboy’s wins were all at a mile or less. If there was ever a year to not give out the award in this division, this might be it.

I’ve written about the split personality that Eclipse Award voters have shown in the outstanding owner category, sometimes giving the award to the owner with the most wins and money won and occasionally to the owner with one “big horse.” There is no definition. In my opinion, the outstanding owner of 2009 was the Godolphin/Darley entity of Sheikh Mohammed, but I think I’m in the minority here, and voters are likely to go with the feel-good story of the year and support Zenyatta’s owners, Jerry and Ann Moss.

Handicapping the jockey race is more about handicapping the voters. New Yorkers and East Coasters will vote en masse for Ramon Dominguez, Midwesterners for Julien Leparoux and Californians for Garrett Gomez. Any of the three are deserving, but I’ll give the slight edge to Dominguez. On the apprentice front, I don’t have a clue, and the information provided voters is so useless there should be consideration given to eliminating this category.

AND FINALLY, HORSE OF THE YEAR GOES TO …

People who are looking for brevity in the Horse of the Year acceptance speech are pulling for Zenyatta and the Mosses. Jess Jackson can be expected to give his “state of the industry” speech if Rachel Alexandra wins, and no one there will have the nerve to give him the hook after 10 minutes of lecturing us on what we need to do to turn things around. (But, hey, someone struck up the band when Frank Sinatra went on for too long when getting a lifetime achievement award at the Grammy’s one year, so there’s always hope!)

But back to the issue at hand. Rachel Alexandra will win Horse of the Year because of her historic campaign that had her beating members of her own age and sex by a furlong; taking the Preakness over the Kentucky Derby winner; taking the Haskell Invitational over the Belmont and eventual Travers and Jockey Club Gold Cup winner; and beating older horses in the Woodward. It was a remarkable campaign. I don’t think the vote will be that close, either.

My vote would have gone to Zenyatta, however, despite everything Rachel Alexandra did. I believe in the Breeders’ Cup being the most definitive event in determining champions, and think that what Zenyatta did in beating a world-class field of males at a mile and a quarter in the Classic trumps Rachel Alexandra – barely.

Wouldn’t it be nice if the 2010 Horse of the Year title is settled on the racetrack.

I hope you’ll check back tonight, for my live blog of the Eclipse Awards telecast from Beverly Hills. If you decide not to, as Carnac would say: "May the fleas of a thousand camels nest in your shorts."

Copyright © 2010, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

ECLIPSE AWARD FINALISTS ANNOUNCED; RACHEL AND ZENYATTA LEAD LIST

Wednesday, January 6th, 2010

It’s finalist day for the 2009 Eclipse Awards. With perhaps the exception of Dolphus Morrison as a finalists for breeder, no real surprises among the list of candidates. Headlined by Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta as the only two listed in the Horse of the Year category, the complete list of the finalists are listed below.

- Bradford Cummings

Female superstars Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta lead an all-star cast of finalists for the 2009 Eclipse Awards, recognizing excellence in Thoroughbred racing. Winners in all categories will be announced at the 39th annual Eclipse Awards ceremony, to be held Monday evening, January 18, at the Beverly Wilshire Hotel in Beverly Hills, Calif.

The announcement of the finalists was made today by the National Thoroughbred Racing Association (NTRA), National Turf Writers Association (NTWA) and Daily Racing Form (DRF), the three presenting organizations of the Eclipse Awards.  

The three-year-old filly Rachel Alexandra, winner of all eight of her starts in 2009, including the Preakness Stakes; and the five-year old mare Zenyatta, who won all five of her races last year and culminated her undefeated career by becoming the first female to win the Breeders’ Cup Classic, are the two candidates for Horse of the Year. Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta were the only two horses to receive votes in the Horse of the Year category.  

The Eclipse Awards finalists (in alphabetical order) are:

·          Horse of the Year:                Rachel Alexandra, Zenyatta        

·         Two-Year-Old Male:               Lookin At Lucky, Noble’s Promise, Vale of York (IRE)

·         Two-Year-Old Filly:                Blind Luck, Hot Dixie Chick, She Be Wild            

·         Three-Year-Old Male:             Mine That Bird, Quality Road, Summer Bird

·         Three-Year-Old Filly:              Careless Jewel, Flashing, Rachel Alexandra

·         Older Male:                             Einstein (BRZ), Gio Ponti, Kodiak Kowboy                      

·         Older Female:                         Life Is Sweet, Music Note, Zenyatta

·         Male Sprinter:                        Dancing in Silks, Kodiak Kowboy, Zensational

·          Female Sprinter:                    Informed Decision, Music Note, Ventura

·         Male Turf Horse:                    Conduit (IRE), Gio Ponti, Presious Passion          

·         Female Turf Horse:                Goldikova (IRE), Midday (GB), Ventura

·         Steeplechase Horse:             Mixed Up, Red Letter Day, Spy in the Sky

·         Owner:                       Godolphin Racing, Juddmonte Farms, Mr. and Mrs. Jerome S. Moss

·         Breeder:                                 Adena Springs, Juddmonte Farms, Dolphus C. Morrison   

·         Trainer:                                 Steve Asmussen, Bob Baffert, John Shirreffs       

·         Jockey:                                 Ramon Dominguez, Garrett Gomez, Julien Leparoux

·         Apprentice Jockey:               Luis Batista, Christian Santiago Reyes, Luis Saez  

The Eclipse Awards are named after the great 18th-century racehorse and foundation sire Eclipse, who began racing at age five and was undefeated in 18 starts, including eight walkovers. Eclipse sired the winners of 344 races, including three Epsom Derbies.  

The 2009 Eclipse Awards ceremony will be held on January 18 at the Beverly Wilshire Hotel in Beverly Hills, Calif., and televised live on TVG.

 

JAPAN DIARY, DAY HACHI: 007 A LUCKY NUMBER?

Thursday, December 3rd, 2009
By Ray Paulick
OSAKA
, Japan—Trainer Jim Bond had only arrived a little more than 12 hours earlier when he faced the Japanese press for the first time on Thursday morning at Hanshin race course near Osaka to talk about Tizway, the 4-year-old son of Tiznow he’ll be saddling for William Clifton in Sunday’s Japan Cup Dirt.

One of the questions of Bond and Clifton had to do with a preferred post position. “Seven, is my lucky number,” said Bond, James Bond, though I’m not sure the Japanese press quite understood his reference to the 007 character, especially after the translation.

A few hours later, when post positions were drawn, guess what happened? Tizway ended up in post position seven for the $3-million race.

Bond and Clifton (pictured, left, during the press conference) will need plenty of luck, and even that might not be enough, when Tizway takes on a field of 15 Japanese runners in the nine-furlong race run on the clockwise track at Hanshin. Only one of the 24 previous runners from outside of Japan has won the race, and that was on the counterclockwise Tokyo race course, where the Japan Cup Dirt had been run from 2000-’07. The lone non-Japanese winner was Fleetstreet Dancer, trained by Doug O’Neill and ridden to victory by Jon Court, in the 2003 renewal, held on a racetrack tightened up considerably by heavy rain. This year’s running is expected to be on a dry track, and that’s bad news for horses who have not competed here, since running on a Japanese dirt track is like running on the dry portion of a sandy beach: it’s very deep and very tiring.

Tizway is far from being the most accomplished American horse to compete here. Among those who have failed to hit the board in previous years are major stakes winners Lido Palace, Lava Man, Student Council and Frost Giant. Tizway has never finished better than third in a stakes race, that coming in his last start, when beaten 5 1/2 lengths by Summer Bird in the Jockey Club Gold Cup. Summer Bird came to Japan and suffered a hairline fracture while training and has been shipped home where he will require surgery.

Tizway’s career has two distinct chapters. In the first, beginning in November 2007 and running through June 2008, it took him six races to break his maiden, that finally coming at Woodbine on the Polytrack. After that win, he was sidelined for nearly a year, Bond said, to recover from soundness problems that were never specifically identified. He speculated on Thursday that Tizway might had some bruising in the area where the cannon bone connects to the ankle. “That kind of thing can happen on Polytrack,” he said. “We had five vets look at him and nothing ever came up on X rays. So we sent him to the farm and gave him plenty of time."

The time off helped. Tizway came back with a strong allowance victory at Aqueduct in April, finished second in another allowance in late May and then romped by 7 1/2 lengths over 2008 Belmont Stakes winner Da’ Tara in July. Bond jumped him from there to the Grade 1 Whitney at Saratoga, where he finished fourth of six runners behind Bullsbay, then third in the Jockey Club Gold Cup. Any thoughts of going in the Breeders’ Cup Classic were thwarted by a fever.

The local horses are far from being chumps. Espoir City is considered by some to be the strongest of the home team, but then there’s the veteran Vermilion, who finished fourth in the 2006 Japan Cup Dirt, won it in 2007 and finished third last year. The 7-year-old son of El Condor Pasa set a JRA record by winning eight Grade 1 races during his career. He will be ridden by the 40-year-old champion jockey Yutaka Take, who is coming off a stinging disappointment when booted off race favorite Vodka in the Japan Cup. French jockey Christophe Lemaire was given the mount and rode Vodka perfectly to win by a nose.

SPEAKING OF YUTAKA TAKE, I had the opportunity to speak with him at Thursday evening’s Welcome Party for the Japan Cup Dirt and this weekend’s World Super Jockeys Series, which is being held for the 23rd consecutive year. (Click here to see details of the event.)

Take holds virtually all Japanese riding records, including career wins, money won, and victories in a single season. He’s been riding 22 years and has been leading jockey on 16 occasions. He burst onto the scene when Japanese racing was becoming extremely popular, and his appeal, good looks and charisma are credited for a significant part of the sport’s growth in the late 1980s and early 1990s.

But now Take is a 40-year-old veteran, and the competition is nipping at his heels. He told me that he plans to ride at least until he’s 50 and believes he has many good years ahead of him. “My experience has made me a better rider than I was in my younger days,” he said in an interview that was part English and partly through a Japanese interpreter. “ I don’t feel as though my physical skills have declined at all. Of course I hope to be able to stay on top. I also want to try California again.”

Take had previously spent a block of time in California but without much success. His attempt to showcase his skills to California horsemen and racing fans came at a time when speed was king on the dirt tracks there, and Take’s style in Japan had always been more patient, come-from-behind to win. I think he would be much more successful now, with the synthetic tracks putting more of a premium on horses coming from off the pace.

CALVIN BOREL AND GARRETT GOMEZ will be representing the United States in this weekend’s World Super Jockeys Series. Both were on hand at the Welcome Party and took turns dipping into the sushi trough.

“I love sushi!” Borel told a group of inquiring Japanese racing journalists, though he shied away from chopsticks, attacking the raw fish with a fork instead. To their credit, the writers were more interested in learning about Rachel Alexandra, the super filly he rode to eight straight victories in 2009, including three over male competition.

“What makes her so special?” one of them asked.

“Her stride,” the Louisiana native said. “She has an incredible stride, longer than any other horse I’ve ever ridden. They say that only Secretariat had a stride as long as Rachel Alexandra.”

Another asked if Borel was sorry that Rachel Alexandra never faced Zenyatta, who beat colts in the Breeders’ Cup Classic and is in a tight race with her for Horse of the Year. “Or course I’m disappointed,” he admitted, but said he agreed with owner Jess Jackson not to run on the synthetic track in California. He said he looks forward to being reunited with the filly at the Fair Grounds, which Borel described as one of the fairest tracks in America, and wishes the two super fillies could somehow meet there.

This was Borel’s “first time out of the lower 48,” as his wife, Lisa, put it, and the two of them plan to soak it all in. They’ll have something to put in their scrapbook, along with two Kentucky Derby victories, and a state dinner at the White House honoring England’s Queen Elizabeth. (And, unlike some recent White House dinner guests, Calvin and Lisa received official invitations.)

Gomez came to Japan last year but left disappointed when the Bobby Frankel-trained Mast Track was scratched from the Japan Cup Dirt with a foot injury. He’s got a busy weekend ahead of him, riding six horses on Saturday, including two in the jockeys’ competition, and more on Sunday. Gomez said he loves the Japanese culture and would be very interested in riding in Japan on a short-term basis, something Kent Desormeaux has done in the past, as have a number of European jockeys, including Lemaire and Olivier Peslier. With the JRA opening up ownership licensing to foreigners, the opportunities for someone like Gomez may be greatly expanded.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value.
Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

JAPAN DIARY, DAY ROKU: DEALING WITH DISAPPOINTMENT

Tuesday, December 1st, 2009

By Ray Paulick
TOKYO, Japan—I’ve been coming to the Japan Cup every year but one since 1993 and have yet to see an American-trained horse win. The first couple of years were promising: Kotashaan finished second, a length and a quarter behind Legacy World in 1993, and Paradise Creek was nosed out by Marvelous Crown in ’94. Since then, only one American-trained horse has even hit the board—that being Sarafan, who was beaten a nose by Falbrav in 2002.

I’m beginning to wonder if an American horse will ever win this race again. Americans won three of the first eight runnings from 1981-’88 and took a fourth Japan Cup when the Charlie Whittingham-trained Golden Pheasant won the 1991 renewal. But that was the last American victory in this major international race.

The Breeders’ Cup, inaugurated in 1984, has certainly had an impact on the Japan, with most of the best American turf horses staying home. So has the introduction of the early December international race meeting at Hong Kong. But there’s more to the story; Japanese runners have simply gotten better, the result of a concerted effort in the 1980s to improve the breed, when the American bloodstock market was in a down cycle and the Japanese yen was strong against the dollar.

We have a similar condition today.

THE DISAPPOINTMENT I have felt watching one American horse after another go down to defeat in the Japan Cup is nothing compared to the feeling I experienced Sunday morning at the Tokyo race course when a representative of the Japan Racing Association told me that Summer Bird was injured and would be forced to miss this Sunday’s Japan Cup Dirt.

The Birdstone colt, the probable 3-year-old male champion of 2009 in North America, is almost certainly the best horse sent from the U.S. to Japan for the Japan Cup Dirt. The race was inaugurated in 2000 and has been won just once by an American horse—the longshot Fleetstreet Dancer in 2003.

This is a race American horses should be able to win, since the best Japanese horses compete on turf and there have been virtually no European contenders in the Japan Cup Dirt. Yet the winner’s share of the $3-million prize is not likely to go to an American runner this year, unless the Tiznow colt Tizway, fourth in the Whitney and third in the Jockey Club Gold Cup, pulls off a big surprise.

Some horsemen go through an entire career without having the opportunity to train a horse the quality of Summer Bird. Tim Ice had the good fortune of having Summer Bird in his barn shortly after going out on his own as a head trainer. Ice took the injury in stride, saying you have to accept the bad with the good that comes along, but you know the injury had to hit him like a punch to the gut.

Ice did an outstanding job with Summer Bird all season long. Let’s hope surgery is successful on the colt’s injured leg and he returns as good as ever in 2010. If not, as Ice said, Summer Bird “owes him nothing.”

Japan Racing Association officials were devastated by news of the injury, too. Summer Bird was a heavily promoted international star in the Japanese media and his defection from the Japan Cup Dirt will have an impact on both on-track attendance and handle, two economic indicators that have been trending in the wrong direction for a dozen years in Japan.

Over the last several years, the JRA has added new bet types, and plans to introduce a pick five wager in 2011. But nothing the JRA has attempted so far has boosted business.

Despite the grim economic news (if attendance of 98,000 and handle of over $300 million for the Japan Cup is grim!), Japanese racing fans continue to show an incredible affection for the sport and its equine and human stars. On Japan Cup morning (and on almost all days when important Grade 1 races are run), the gates of the JRA tracks open at 8 a.m., and there is a ritualistic “mad dash” to desirable spots along the rail just past the finish line by hundreds of amateur photographers, many of whom have camped outside the track for several days to be first through the gate, The enthusiasm of these fans is infectious and can serve as a tonic to jaded souls who feel racing has lost its connection with the public.

Tomorrow, I’ll be heading to Osaka and Hanshin race course in anticipation of Sunday’s Japan Cup Dirt. I’ll report from there on Thursday.

A FINAL NOTE: There have been some unfortunate rumors floating through the internet that this reporter was spotted at a Tokyo karaoke studio on Sunday night, warbling with a trio of Japanese racing journalists. Unless you have pictures or a recording of the event, it is nothing more than a rumor. What happens in Tokyo…well, you know the rest.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value.
Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

SUMMER BIRD TO UNDERGO SURGERY AFTER RETURN TO U.S.

Sunday, November 29th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
Trainer Tim Ice said he hopes to ship Summer Bird back to the United States Wednesday on a flight that would also include Marsh Side, one of the American starters in Sunday’s Japan Cup. Summer Bird came out of a Sunday morning workout at Hanshin racecourse in Osaka, Japan, with a vertical, non-comminuted fracture of a bone in his right front leg that will require surgery. A decision has not been made whether to retire the three-time Grade 1-winning son of Birdstone or put him back in training in 2010.

“One of the surgeons we’ve consulted with (in the United States) has already seen the X rays and says the prognosis is excellent,” Ice told the Paulick Report Monday morning (Japanese time). “It will take one screw to put it together and should be no problem.”

Ice explained how some confusion over the type of injury Summer Bird suffered may have occurred in the racing press. The Paulick Report, which first reported on the injury, referred to it as a medial fracture of the carpal bone after speaking with the trainer Sunday afternoon. Other news outlets, which contacted Dr. K.K. Jayaraman, who bred and owns Summer Bird with his wife, Vilasini, called it a bone chip, based on early information provided to the Jayaramans. The Jayaramans had arrived in Tokyo shortly before the injury occurred and had not yet had the opportunity to travel to Osaka and see the horse or look at the X rays. Ice confirmed Monday that the injury is a fracture to the medial, or inside, front portion of the right ankle. The Jayaramans were to arrive in Osaka later Monday.

“The first impression I got was that there was a chip,” said Ice, who relayed that information to the Jayaramans. “Once I was able to see the X rays myself, I could see that it was a fracture, not a chip. I don’t think the communications was real clear between the (Japanese) interpreter and myself.”

Summer Bird is resting comfortably and in no distress, said Ice, who said a cast was applied to the leg as a precaution.

“I’ve been out with him all morning, and checked on him last night,” Ice said. “He’s able to lay down and takes care of himself. He’s always been an intelligent horse and I think knows to take weight off it. He knows something happened. He’s a horse with a very good attitude. We have a cast on him right now, but he probably doesn’t need it. We’re just giving him extra protection.”

The 35-year-old Ohio native took a minute to reflect back on a year that included wins by Summer Bird in the Belmont Stakes, Travers and Jockey Club Gold Cup, victories that make the colt the favorite to win an Eclipse Award as 3-year-old male champion. “These horses are hard to come by and what he’s done for me this year and for my career is something that I can’t really put into words. But you’ve got to take the good with the bad and this is part of the business we are in.

“I’m thankful for the year I’ve had with him. If he doesn’t come back to run again he doesn’t owe me anything.”

Ice said Summer Bird was doing very well in his training in preparation for the the Japan Cup Dirt, which is to be on a very sandy racetrack whose surface he compared with Belmont Park. One challenge would have been the clockwise-style of racing done at Hanshin, in contrast to American racing, which is all counter-clockwise. “He had adjusted to the turns,” Ice said, “and handled both turns well in Sunday’s breeze.”

Summer Bird worked five furlongs in 1:02 4/5 Sunday morning and pulled up without incident. It was only after being unsaddled back at his stable that Summer Bird began showing signs of the injury that will require surgery back in the United States. Ice could not confirm who would be performing the surgery or where it would take place.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value.
Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

SUMMER BIRD INJURED IN JAPAN

Saturday, November 28th, 2009

By Ray Paulick
Multiple Grade 1 winner Summer Bird suffered a fracture to his right front leg while training at Hanshin race course Sunday morning in preparation for next Sunday’s Japan Cup Dirt. The injury is not life threatening but could end the racing career of the 3-year-old Birdstone colt, who captured the Grade 1 trio of the Belmont, Travers and Jockey Club Gold Cup and is the favorite to win an Eclipse Award as champion 3-year-old male.

Summer Bird is owned and bred by Drs. K.K. and Vilasini Jayaraman.

Trainer Tim Ice, who has been at Hanshin in Osaka to oversee Summer Bird’s training, said the colt worked five furlongs in 1:02 1/5 without incident and walked back to the barn without any apparent lameness.

“It was a very good breeze, exactly what we wanted,” Ice told the Paulick Report Sunday afternoon. “He finished up strong. Once we got him off the track and unsaddled him he showed a slight limp and the further he went the more he started limping. We immediately put him in his stall, put him on ice, and took X rays an hour later.”

Ice described the fracture as going “straight up” the medial carpal bone (click here for a diagram) and speculated the fracture might require surgery and the implant of a screw into the bone.

“It’s definite that he will not run in the Japan Cup Dirt,” Ice said. “Once we get him back to the States and get him to the veterinarian of our choice we’ll further evaluate whether he’ll have a 4-year-old campaign or not. We’re taking every precaution we can to get a safe and comfortable trip home for him.

“Dr. J. will decide whether we’ll need the surgery,” he said. “The plans were to bring him back as a 4-year-old as long as he was sound. We just need to sit down and figure out what to do. The one thing we don’t want to do is put him through everything and waste a year of racing if he’s not 100%.”

Ice said it hasn’t been determined how soon Summer Bird will travel back to the U.S. and where he will go for evaluation, though he mentioned Kentucky and Colorado (where renowned orthopedic surgeon Wayne McIlwraith is based) as the most likely possibilities. Ice said Summer Bird will need to spend a couple of days in quarantine at Hollywood Park.

“Everything was going good, and I was looking forward to the race,” the trainer said. “I check his legs every morning and this morning before his breeze he was ice cold. There was nothing to indicate something was wrong. He did stumble slightly for one step when he turned around to begin his gallop, but there was no indication at all in the work.”

Summer Bird would have been the first winner of an American Triple Crown race to contest the Japan Cup Dirt.

“I’m feeling very, very disappointed,” said Ice, “not because we didn’t make this race but because this had to happen to this horse. He’s been a very good horse all summer long and into the fall and for something like this to happen is devastating.

“It’s been a whirlwind experience. This is the letdown of the sport. I have to accept this just as I accept the good. The one thing I’m thankful for is he does have a future. I’ll always remember this horse. Once he gets into the breeding shed I hope he’ll reproduce what he showed as a racehorse.”

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value.
Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

LIVE BLOGGING SUPER SATURDAY STAKES

Saturday, October 3rd, 2009

By Ray Paulick
Belmont Park offers five Grade 1 races today, beginning with the Beldame (you remember, the race where TVG boosted the purse in hopes of getting Zenyatta and Rachel Alexandra, connections for neither of which appeared to take very seriously). I’ll be writing a live blog providing results of Belmont’s races (following the Beldame is the Vosburgh for sprinters, the Flower Bowl for fillies and mares on turf, the Joe Hirsch Turf Classic Invitational for male turf horses, and the Jockey Club Gold Cup, which pits the top-class 3-year-olds Summer Bird and Quality Road against Macho Again, who nearly caught Rachel Alexandra in the Woodward Stakes. I’ll provide some of the other day’s graded stakes activity from Hawthorne, where the Grade 2 Hawthorne Gold Cup is being run, as the serious final prep races for the Breeders’ Cup World Championships get under way.

(All photos by Eric Kalet.)

Here is a link to today’s Belmont Park Equibase charts.

Post time for the Beldame is 3:23 p.m. Eastern.

The rains came midway through the Belmont card, and though the main track was still called fast when Music Note entered the gate as the 1-5 favorite in the Beldame, it was a very wet, fast track. Music Note may have had a few nervous moments, as track announcer Tom Durkin said, when she was pinned down on the rail in the long run down the backstretch while tracking pacesetter Unbridled Belle.  But jockey Rajiv Muragh, moved the daughter of A.P. Indy to the outside around the turn and she wore down Unbridled Belle to get the win by 2 1/4  lengths, covering the distance in 1:48.49.  Unbridled Belle (who set soft fractions of :24.24, :47.99 and 1:11.66) held second, with Copper State third and Captain’s Lover fourth in the five-horse field. Captain’s Lover and Unbridled Belle were coupled, and Captain’s Lover and John Velazquez did their best to keep Music Note down on the rail, but Captain’s Lover couldn’t keep up after five furlongs.

Music Note was winning for the seventh time in 11 starts for Godolphin. This was just her third start of the year, following a fifth-place finish in the Ogden Phipps at Belmont Park and a victory in Saratoga’s Ballerina. She finished third behind Zenyatta and stablemate Cocoa Beach in last year’s Breeders’ Cup Ladies’ Classic (formerly the Distaff). The Saeed bin Suroor-trained filly paid $2.50 for the win.

Couple of college football notes: Michigan State upset previously unbeaten Michigan, 26-20, in overtime. Alabama crushed the University of Kentucky Wildcasts 38-20.

3:58 p.m. … The rain at Belmont has gotten worse, making it tough to even pick up the horses on the television feed. Good luck Tom Durkin, though the fact the Vosburgh is a four-horse field makes it a lot easier for him.

Kodiak Kowboy got up in the final strides to beat odds-on favorite Fabulous Strike by a half-length in the six-furlong Vosburgh under Shaun Bridgmohan. The 4-year-old son of Posse owned by Rick Porter Fox Hill Farms and Tom Simon’s Vinery Stables was back in the care of trainer Steve Asmussen for the Vosburgh after being transferred from Asmussen to Larry Jones a little over a year ago.

Fabulous Strike got a stalking trip, settling just off the pace of Go Go Shoot, with Munnings in third and Kodiak Kowboy the trailer. Go Go Shoot went a quick opening quarter-mile in :22.33 over a very rain-soaked track. Fabulous Strike moved to the lead on the turn under Ramon Dominquez, but Kodiak  Kowboy was beginning his rally before straightening out for the stretch run. He appeared to have all the momentum, but hesitated when he was getting the muddy kickback from Fabulous Strike. Bridgmohan shifted Kodiak Kowboy to the outside and he quickly regained his best stride and went on to win by a half length. Munning was third after never really threatening.

This was the 10th win from 22 starts for Kodiak Kowboy and the second in a Grade 1 race, following his victory earlier this year in the Carter Handicap at Aqueduct. He had finished second to Pyro in the Forego and third behind Fabulous Strike and Go Go Shoot in the Aflred G. Vanderbilt Handicap in his previous two starts. Kodiak Kowboy ran third for Jones in last year’s Vosburgh.

Kodiak Kowboy covered the six furlongs on a sloppy main track in 1:10.08 and paid  $11.60.

4:15 p.m. … When Matt Carothers sings Happy Birthday to Ken Rudulph on TVG, that can mean one of two things: mute button or HRTV. We’ll go for the latter. I have a feeling I’m not alone.

4:30 p.m. … Congrats to Equibase for putting together a useful late changes/scratches service. I won’t ask what took so long. Here is the link to Belmont’s late changes. Presious Passion wasn’t listed as a scratch from the Joe Hirsch last time I looked, but that was the word from the television talking heads.  Carribean Sunset has been scratched from the Flower Bowl, while Gio Ponti’s entrymate Winchester and Ready’s Echo have been scratched from the Hirsch.

The rains are still falling heavily at Belmont Park as the field of fillies and mares heads toward the gate for the Flower Bowl.

4:40 p.m. … Julien Leparoux gave the ever-consistent Pure Clan a perfectly timed ride in the Flower Bowl, getting up in the final sixteenth of a mile, then pulling away to beat Criticism by 2 3/4 lengths over a boggy Belmont turf course. Queen of Hearts was third and Moneycantbuymelove fourth.

Leamington took the early lead in the Flower Bowl, putting up very slow splits of :26.81 for the quarter, :53.81 for the half-mile and 1:20.43 for six furlongs on the soft turf, with Criticism tracking her. Leparoux had  Pure Clan in good position in fifth, then rallied on the final turn and took dead aim at Criticism and jockey Javiar Castellano. 

It was the eighth victory in 15 starts and 14th 1-2-3 finish for the Lakland Farm runner trained by Bob Holthus. The daughter of the Storm Cat stallion Pure Prize was coming off a third in the Beverly D. Stakes at Arlington and had one previous Grade 1 victory in last year’s American Oaks on the Hollywood Park turf course. Pure Clan was never a factor in last year’s Breeders’ Cup Filly &  Mare Turf at Santa Anita.

Final time of the 1 1/4 mile Flower Bowl was 2:12.43 after a mile fraction of 1:46.63. It was a bog out there, but Pure Clan didn’t seem to mind it one bit.

5:08 p.m. … It’s true that you don’t see the Phipps Stable silks at Thistledown that often, but the trip by Gone Astray from Belmont Park to Cleveland was well worth it as the son of Dixie Union sat off the early pace set by War Fighter, moved to the lead at midstretch and drew away impressively by 2 1/4 lengths. The Shug McGaughey-trained colt was coming off a big win in the Pennsylvania Derby. Gone Astray covered the 1 1/8 miles in 1:50.56 War Fighter was second, with Ice Road third. Gone Astray was the 2-5 favorite.

5:15 p.m. … Gio Ponti looked like a winner in the Joe Hirsch Turf Classic Invitational when he cruised up alongside pacesetter Interpatation at the top of the stretch, but the Bobby Barbara-trained 7-year-old gelding by Langfuhr found a second wind in the final furlong and rerallied to beat Gio Ponti by 1 3/4 lengths on an extremely soft turf course.

Robbie Albarado rode the winner, who was getting just his sixth career win from 50 starts for owner Elliot Mavorah. He set all the fractions of :26.01, :54.22, 1:22.20 and 1:48.77 for the opening mile After a mile and a quarter time of 2:14.59, Interpatation completed the 1 1/2 miles in 2:41.22, about 17 seconds slower than the course record.

Interpatation hadn’t finished in the top three in his last seven starts. His last in the money finish came when second to Grand Couturier in the 2008 Joe Hirsch Turf Invitational. Gio Ponti, on the other hand, came into the Joe Hirsch off four consecutive Grade 1 victories, but the 1 1/2 miles of the race and the soft conditions may have exposed the 4-year-old son of Tale of the Cat’s distance limitations, as he had never raced farther than 1 3/8 miles. 

Interpatation paid $89.50 on a $2 wager to win. Telling, the original third-place finisher, was disqualified and placed fourth behind Grand Couturier for interference.

5:30 p.m. … Awesome Gem and David Flores ran down Nite Light to win the $500,000 Hawthorne Gold Cup going away at Hawthorne Park, giving West Point Thoroughbreds the first leg of a big potential parlay that could culminate with a victory in the Jockey Club Gold Cup only a few minutes from now with Macho Again. Going Ballistic was third and You and I Forever fourth in the mile and a quarter Gold Cup, a Grade 2 event. 

5:50 p.m. … The rain  has subsided as the field entered the gate for the Jockey Club Gold Cup, which begins midway around the clubhouse turn on this 1 1/2 mile oval.  

Summer Bird and Quality Road put on a show, racing together the length stretch while well off the rail, but Summer Bird prevailed by one length to win the Jockey Club Gold Cup on a sloppy dirt track. Pacesetting Tizway was third, with Macho Again never really getting untracked and finishing fourth.

Summer Bird only has four career victories to his credit, beginning with a maiden win at Oaklawn Park in March. But the son of Gainesway stallion Birdstone, owned and bred by Drs. K.K. and Devi Jayaraman and trained by Tim Ice, has built quite a resume with the other three victories, all Grade 1–the Belmont Stakes in June, the Travers in August, and now the Jockey Club Gold Cup in early October–to make him the clear leader for an Eclipse Award in the 3-year-old male division.

Kent Desormeaux allowed Summer Bird to settle off the early pace set first by Tizway through the opening quarter mile in :24.96 and then by Quality Road through a half mile in :49.73 and six furlongs in 1:13.12.  Sensing that Quality Road might have it too easy on the front end, Desormeaux moved Summer Bird toward the lead before hitting the far turn, and engaged Quality Road in earnest when the pair hit the top of the stretch, the mile in 1:37.62. With Summer Bird on the outside, the pair raced together to the final sixteenth, when Summer Bird edged away gradually for the win, the 1 1/4 miles in 2:02.51 on the sloppy track. 

There were plenty of  other races on the day that I didn’t blog about, but George Jacob and Jill Baffert’s Misremembered won the Grade 2 Indiana Derby, which offered a $500,000 purse. Victor Espinosa rode the winner, a son of Candy Ride. Giant Oak finished second, a half length back, with Karama third. Win Willy, the slight favorite over Misremembered, finished fifth.

 

POST RACE COMMENTS, COURTESY OF THE NEW YORK RACING ASSOCIATION MEDIA RELATIONS OFFICE

BELDAME QUOTES
Saeed bin Suroor winning trainer of favored Music Note (No. 2): "She was really happy, relaxed, in condition. She showed her good turn of foot. I was waiting for him to take her outside. When he did, I was happy. We’ll take her to the Breeders’ Cup. Nine furlongs (in the Ladies Classic) will suit her. She looked better than ever."
Rick Mettee, assistant to winning trainer Saeed bin Suroor of favored Music Note (No. 2): "It was good race riding on the part of the entry’s riders. It wasn’t unexpected, but luckily she got separation off the turn. I was a little concerned about how well Unbridled Belle was traveling. When they got head-to-head, Ramon (Dominguez, jockey on Unbridled Belle) had gone to the stick and Rajiv (Maragh, jockey on Music Note) had not. This is the fifth Grade 1 for this filly and four of them are here (at Belmont)."
Rajiv Maragh, winning rider aboard favored Music Note (No. 2):  "I was comfortable because I didn’t want to go too early. I wanted to get my filly to relax. Once I was behind the horses, she was getting into a nice, high cruising speed. I was pretty happy. I knew they were going to spread out at some point in the race. Once they did, that’s when I made a move to get clear. There was a lot of racetrack left by the time I got open."
Ramon Dominguez, rider aboard runner-up Unbridled Belle (No. 1a): "I had a good trip. My filly was relaxed and the other filly was just much the best."
 
 
VOSBURGH QUOTES
Scott Blasi, assistant to winning trainer Steve Asmussen, of Kodiak Kowboy (No. 4): "It set up great for him. There was plenty of speed up front. He’s been such a top horse his whole career."
Shaun Bridgmohan, winning jockey aboard Kodiak Kowboy (No. 4): "I was on him when he won the Saratoga Special. He was a pro even back then. When he was transferred to Steve Asmussen’s barn, I was excited because I knew I had a shot at getting back on him. Today, when I hit him left-handed, he really dug in gamely."
Todd Beattie, trainer of favored runner-up Fabulous Strike (No. 5): "We’re disappointed with the way he broke through the gate. I thought we were home free until Kodiak Cowboy caught him. Kodiak Cowboy is a tough customer. We have been battling with him for quite a long time. It was obvious he ran well today. You cannot knock my horse’s effort. He made a good, solid effort. I knew he handled the off going. I was surprised they finished in 1:10. I will have to talk to the owner about the Breeders’ Cup."
Ramon Dominguez, rider aboard favored runner-up Fabulous Strike (No. 5): "Tough beat, unfortunately it didn’t work out our way today.  We had an ideal trip.  I sat right off [Go Go Shoot] in front and made the lead with ease when I wanted, I just couldn’t hold off the winner."
 
FLOWER BOWL QUOTES
Bob Holthus, winning trainer, Pure Clan (No. 3):  "She ran a great race. I’m glad it’s over. She showed more speed today than normal. She was in the race all the way. [Jockey] Julien [Leparoux] had confidence. It’s always good to get Grade 1’s."

Julien Leparoux, winning rider aboard Pure Clan (No. 3):   "She ran well today. We wanted her behind the pace so she would make a big run at the end. The turf course was really soft and she had to work hard at it in the stretch. Still, she got the job done."

Tom Albertrani, trainer of runner-up Criticism (No. 5): ""We were pleased with her. She came back to her previous races [and] found her best stride. We were really happy with the way she had been coming into this race since she was training so well. Today, she fired her shot. She is definitely better going longer. We are considering bringing bring her to the Breeders’ Cup Filly and Mare Turf."

 Javier Castellano, runner-up jockey, Criticism (No. 5): "I’m very satisfied with the way she ran. She was stalking, just like we wanted. Unfortunately, she was second best, but I’m very happy."

 
JOE HIRSCH TURF CLASSIC QUOTES
Bobby Barbara, winning trainer, Interpatation (No. 3):  "It was great. Great!  I just loved the way he looked going down the backside. In front of me, over here, he was just galloping on the lead and Robby just said he was having fun doing it.  I was waiting for him one day to pick his head up and do it right. He did it right, on the perfect day.  This horse made $700,000 the hard way, and now he’s over a million in one day!  I don’t know what’s next for him."
Robby Albarado, winning rider aboard Interpatation (No. 3): "I had never ridden him before. Bobby said in the paddock, he’s a stayer. He said a mile and a half is his distance, he ran his best race here last year, when he was second. I had the intention of being forwardly placed, and I ended up on the lead, galloping, in a canter. At every point, I had plenty of horse. When Gio Ponti ran up to me, I thought, ‘Gee, maybe I can get second.’ But he didn’t get away from me, and my horse hit his stride."
Christophe Clement, trainer of beaten favorite and runner-up Gio Ponti (No. 1): "Second best in that one, but I thought he ran a very good race - he really tried.  The idea is to go from there to the Breeders’ Cup, use the race and move on."
Ramon Dominguez, jockey aboard beaten favorite and runner-up Gio Ponti (No. 1): "He handled the going well. He just got a little tired at the end."

 JOCKEY CLUB GOLD CUP QUOTES

Tim Ice, winning trainer of Summer Bird (No. 3): "When Kent swung him to the outside I knew he had the spot he wanted. He had said in the paddock the inside wasn’t that good so he wanted him about four or five off the rail. When Summer Bird took the lead I was very confident that no one was going to get in front of him. Summer Bird was hanging a little bit on him; Kent said it was easier than it looked. He was in no doubt he was going to win the race. [The last sixteenth] I was thinking no one was going to get by him. He’s that kind of a racehorse. He’s going to dig back in. I was feeling pretty confident."
"It means a lot to win the three races in New York. It’s been 20 years since a three-year-old won the Belmont Stakes, the Travers, and the Jockey Club Gold Cup. I think it puts him in an elite group and he should be named [champion] three-year-old colt."
"The goal is the Breeders’ Cup [Classic]. We’ll take a couple of days and see how he is."

Kent Desormeaux, winning rider aboard Summer Bird (No. 3): "Unlike the Travers, he was completely off the bridle, just cruising along. Once I positioned him, he was floating, completely turned off. I think he was idling in the stretch. At the quarter pole, he spit past Quality Road and he was idling. He’s trying to be the best horse I’ve ever ridden. [Best effort yet?] "By far. He was awesome today. He pulled up quietly like nothing had ever happened."

Todd Pletcher, trainer of runner-up Quality Road (No. 7): "He ran well. I don’t think [his acting up] before the start had any bearing on the race. I think he’s better on fast track. Summer Bird relishes this kind of surface. [Breeders' Cup?] We will talk with Mr. [Edward] Evans. It’s run on synthetic so we have some thinking to do."
John Velazquez, rider aboard runner-up Quality Road (No. 7): ""He put in a good effort. I don’t think we’ve seen the best of him yet. I’m not knocking the other horse [Summer Bird]. The other horse ran a great race, too. I think my horse is better on a dry track. I would like to see both horses on a dry track to see which one is the best horse. [Summer Bird] had an advantage over my horse. He had been running all summer long. My horse was stopped twice and came back at 6 1/2 [furlongs] then went to a mile and a quarter over a wet track. I’m not frustrated. I just think my horse is better than [he was today]."

H. James Bond, trainer of third-place finisher Tizway (No. 4): "A good effort. The other horse just loves the mud."

Rajiv Maragh, rider aboard third-place finisher Tizway (No. 4): "My horse earned respect for finishing third. We had a clear shot with a nice pace. The race really took off at the half-mile pole and he couldn’t keep up with the top two. We were clearly third best. This was a good group of horses. To be third-best in this race, it’s not disappointing because there were good horses behind us."
 

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

WEEKEND STAKES: WHERE TO WATCH brought to you by KBC HORSE SUPPLIES

Friday, July 31st, 2009

(UPDATED)

If you can’t get to the track this weekend, there will be plenty of outstanding races to watch on television both Saturday and Sunday, headlined by a pair of important races for 3-year-olds: Saturday’s West Virginia Derby at Mountaineer Park and Sunday’s Haskell Invitational.

The Grade 1 Haskell Invitational, with its $1,250,000 purse, is the richest race of the weekend and the highlight of the big 14-race program at Monmouth Park. Rachel Alexandra will try to extend her winning streak to eight as she takes on colts and geldings for the second time in her last three starts. Though the daughter of Medaglia d’Oro comes off a 19 π-length victory in the Mother Goose at Belmont Park, the nine-furlong Haskell will not be a walk in the park for the Steve Asmussen-trained filly. She’ll have Belmont Stakes winner Summer Bird to contend with, along with Munnings, an impressive winner of the Tom Fool Handicap recently. For good measure, there are two other Derby winners in the race, Papa Clem, who won the Arkansas Derby, and Iowa Derby winner Duke of Mischief.

TVG will provide coverage of the Haskell, which has an estimated post time of 6:15 p.m. Eastern.

The Kentucky Derby winner, meanwhile, goes in Saturday’s West Virginia Derby, which will be shown on Fox Sports Net, where Chris Lincoln, the former host of so many ESPN racing telecasts over the years, will make his return to the airwaves. TVG will also show the West Virginia Derby.

Mine That Word’s trainer, Chip Woolley, chose the West Virginia Derby over the Haskell because he felt the Monmouth Park strip is a speed-favoring track that would be disadvantageous to the late-running gelded son of Birdstone. It is a shame that the three Triple Crown race winners—Mine That Bird, Rachel Alexandra and Summer Bird—aren’t meeting at Monmouth, put perhaps they will hook up in the Travers at Saratoga later in August.

The appearance of a Kentucky Derby winner at Mountaineer Park is historic, but that won’t keep the competition from trying to knock him off. Big Drama, the disqualified Swale Stakes winner who set the pace before finishing fifth in the Preakness, is the only other graded stakes winner in the field for the nine-furlong West Virginia Derby. Steve Asmussen sends the quick Soul Warrior to Mountaineer in hopes of pulling off an upset.

Post time Saturday for the West Virginia Derby is approximately 5:43 p.m. Eastern.

That’s just a start of this weekend’s major races. There’s the Grade 1 Diana Handicap on TVG and HRTV  at 5:14 p.m. Eastern Saturday featuring Breeders’ Cup Filly & Mare Turf winner Forever Together and the hard-hitting Criticism, followed a half-hour later by the Grade 2 Jim Dandy for 3-year-olds. Kensei and Charitable Man headline that field. Sunday’s Saratoga program includes the Grade 1 Go for Wand Handicap. Cocoa Beach, second to champion Zenyatta in last year’s Breeders’ Cup Ladies Classic, tops that field, which goes to the post at 5:30 p.m., also on HRTV and TVG.

Out west on Saturday, the Grade 2 San Clemente Handicap at Del Mar goes off at 8:30 p.m. Eastern on TVG. Sunday’s Grade 2 San Diego Handicap features the return of Dubai World Cup winner Well Armed against 2008 Hollywood Gold Cup winner Mast Track and a horse named Kelly Leak. Who is Kelly Leak, you might ask. That’s the horse that won this year’s Sunland Park Derby, a race where Mine That Bird finished fourth. This will be Kelly Leak’s first start since that March 29 race Well Armed’s win in Dubai was March 28. The 1 1/16-mile San Diego Handicap goes at 8:30 p.m. Eastern.

UPDATE: TVG sent the following note regarding its coverage of the Haskell on Sunday: TVG’s coverage of the Haskell will also be simulcast on FSN Prime, FSN Ohio, SUN Sports, Comcast Sports Illinois and Altitude Network, making the total reach of the race through  SN Prime, FSN Ohio, SUN Sports, Comcast Sports Illinois and Altitute Network, making the total reach of TVG’s coverage of the race to over 70 million homes across the U.S. This is made possible through the local affiliate relationships that TVG has made with various networks. This is often the case with many of the bigger races TVG covers as well as some regional tracks in areas where TVG is not offered.

PAULICK’S THOUGHTS FROM A TRIPLE CROWN NOTEBOOK

Monday, June 8th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
This was a Triple Crown for the little guys, and I’m not talking about jockeys.

We had a Kentucky Derby won by a 50-1 longshot, Mine That Bird, a gelding that once sold for $9,500 as a yearling. He was trained by Bennie L. "Chip" Woolley Jr.,  a black hat wearing cowboy from New Mexico who some years earlier befriended Mark Allen, one of Mine That Bird’s owners, in a bar fight. The trainer had saddled just one winner this year before the Derby. Anyone outside of New Mexico who knew him was probably a relative.

The Preakness was won by Rachel Alexandra, a filly bred by Dolphus Morrison, a retired businessman from Alabama with a modest breeding and racing operation. That’s right, Alabama, not exactly horse country. But it puts an addendum on the old adage that a good horse can come from anywhere. So can a good horse breeder, and Morrison has enjoyed success as a breeder even before Rachel Alexandra became a national star.

The Belmont winner, Summer Bird, was bred and owned by a couple from India who are retired medical professionals. Dr. Kalarikkal Jayaraman was a cardiologist and wife Vilasini was a pathologist who discovered a love of horse racing in Arkansas and eventually bought a farm in Ocala, Fla., where Kalarikkal Jayaraman trains the young horses before sending them to the racetrack. Summer Bird’s trainer, Tim Ice, is in his first year as a head trainer. His earliest memories of racing come from Waterford Park in West Virginia, a track that used to be the poster child for the leaky roof circuit until West Virginia got slot machines and the track was transformed into Mountaineer Park.

The only “spoiler” in the little guy Triple Crown was Jess Jackson, a billionaire winemaker from California who bought Rachel Alexandra from Morrison and a partner after her 20 ¼-length win in the Kentucky Oaks. Morrison is a traditionalist when it comes to racing, saying he didn’t think fillies belong in the Classic races, which he believes should be a showcase for future stallion prospects (that would seem to preclude geldings from running in them, too). But Morrison is also a capitalist, and was willing to sell his prized filly for the right price.

Jackson, despite his many years as a racing fan (as a young child he saw Seabiscuit run in Northern California), is not a traditionalist. He likes to see the best run against the best, especially if he has a stake in the outcome. He swooped in to Baltimore and won the Preakness with Rachel Alexandra, then exited center stage with the Medaglia d’Oro filly. Where or when she’ll resurface is anyone’s guess, but let’s hope it brings on the same dramatics as the Preakness.

Among the beaten in this Triple Crown were Dubai’s ruler, Sheikh Mohammed, who in addition to being a leading buyer at virtually every major sale throughout the world, purchased the top two 2-year-old colts in training in North America last year, Eclipse Award winner Midshipman and runner-up Vineyard Haven (shouldn’t Jess Jackson have bought a horse with that kind of name?). The sheikh, for reasons of pride, insists on training his horses in Dubai each winter and dispersing them to major races like the Kentucky Derby, a program that hasn’t yet been very successful. To Kentucky he came, he saw, he failed to conquer.

Triple Crown training king D. Wayne Lukas failed to hit the board in the three Triple Crown races, but it was good to have him back on the beat after a drought. Bob Baffert came to Churchill Downs in search of his fourth Kentucky Derby win with a live contender, Pioneerof the Nile, but after finishing a distant second behind Mine That Bird was left repeating the line from the movie “Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby”: “If you ain’t first, you’re last.” And Nick Zito, who talks of Triple Crown glory in almost Biblical terms, made appearances in the Derby and Belmont, but couldn’t muster much of a run in either race. These three Hall of Famers help make the classic races something special.

Then there is Todd Pletcher, a future Hall of Famer and multi-Eclipse Award winning-training who seems to be followed by a dark cloud whenever he comes to Churchill Downs in the springtime. Pletcher started three in this year’s Derby, failing to hit the board with any of them, and is now 0-for-24 in America’s most famous horse race. Hang in there, Todd. As a Chicago Cubs fan who was not around for their last World Series championship in 1908, I feel your pain. Cub fans have an expression that might work for you, too: Wait till next year.

Some additional thoughts from a Triple Crown notebook:
- Major stakes at Oaklawn Park produced two Triple Crown race winners, Rachel Alexandra, who won the Grade 2 Fantasy Stakes as her final prep before the Kentucky Oaks, and Summer Bird, who was third behind Papa Clem and Old Fashioned in the Grade 2 Arkansas Derby. It is amazing to many people (except for those on the Graded Stakes Committee) that the Arkansas Derby remains a Grade 2 race after producing Triple Crown races winners like Smarty Jones, Afleet Alex, Curlin and now Summer Bird in recent years.

- Sunland Park races deserve closer examination in the grading process as well. Mine That Bird came to Kentucky after two races at the New Mexico track: second in the Borderland Derby and fourth in the Sunland Derby. Gabby’s Golden Gal, winner of Saturday’s Grade 1 Acorn on the Belmont undercard, won the Sunland Park Oaks. No Sunland Park races have ever been graded by the committee, but since the addition of slot machine revenue they have dramatically increased purses and improved the quality of runners the races attract.

- Breeders should be excited about the emergence of two young Kentucky-based sires, Birdstone and Medaglia d’Oro, whose first crop of foals are now aged three. Birdstone, who upset Smarty Jones in his Triple Crown bid at the 2004 Belmont and also won the Champagne and Travers, sired Mine That Bird and Summer Bird. He stands at the Beck family’s Gainesway Farm. Medaglia d’Oro, a top racehorse over several seasons who finished a close second to longshot Sarava in the 2002 Belmont before winning the Jim Dandy and Travers, sired Rachel Alexandra. Medaglia d’Oro, who started his career at John Sikura’s Hill ‘n’ Dale, then moved to the Haisfield family’s Stonewall Stallions, was the subject of a recent bidding war involving several stallion farms, with Sheikh Mohammed’s Darley emerging last week as the winner.

- “Practice? We’re talking about practice.” Did Calvin Borel move too soon in the Belmont aboard Mine That Bird? Would some practice runs on the mile-and-a-half Belmont oval in preliminary races on Belmont Day or earlier in the week have benefited the lovable Cajun, who shrugged off his lack of experience at Belmont Park as not important while boldly guaranteeing victory for Mine That Bird? Borel became a media darling during this year’s Triple Crown, which he nearly swept on two horses. He jetted to California for the “Tonight Show With Jay Leno,” made an appearance on “Late Night With David Letterman,” was a hit during a Triple Crown luncheon and never seemed to stop talking. He did everything but ride during the week of the Belmont. But if someone had asked Calvin about practicing over the Belmont Park strip before the race, is it possible he would have said something like this?

- Business on the Triple Crown was strong in light of the poor economy. Betting on the Derby was down, not surprisingly. The morning line favorite, I Want Revenge, was scratched and wet track conditions such as those horseplayers found on Derby Day generally lead to wagering declines. Preakness betting was up significantly from 2008, though attendance took a huge hit when Magna officials changed their policy and prohibited fans from bringing their own beer into the infield. The Belmont, whose numbers boom when there is a Triple Crown on the line, did not have that advantage this year, but did well in comparison to the last non-Triple Crown year, 2007. Adding to the good news was increased television ratings for the Derby and Preakness on NBC. ABC’s Belmont Stakes telecast will almost certainly have a smaller audience than in 2008, when Big Brown was going for a Triple Crown.

How much handle from the Triple Crown is leaking to offshore bookmakers offering online wagering is anyone’s guess. These businesses do not have contracts with racetracks or horsemen’s organizations, and pay nothing to support the game. It’s beyond me why anyone who cares about horse racing would do business with these sites or  (whether they are established publications, web sites, or fan blogs) accept advertising from them. They are aggressive in seeking places to advertise, and are willing to pay top dollar to market their products. Again, they put nothing back into the game. The Paulick Report refuses to accept advertising from these businesses and applauds all the other web sites and publications who have a similar policy.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

SUMMER BIRD UPSETS THE BELMONT

Saturday, June 6th, 2009

By Ray Paulick
A late-running son of Birdstone won the 141st Belmont Stakes, but it wasn’t Mine That Bird, the Kentucky Derby winner, Preakness runner-up and Belmont favorite. Instead, making the last run under Kent Desormeaux, 11-1 longshot Summer Bird–a troubled sixth in the Kentucky Derby in what was just his fourth lifetime start–got up in the final furlong to beat Dunkirk and Mine That Bird  by 2 3/4  lengths in the mile and a half "test of the champion" at Belmont Park on Saturday. Charitable Man was fourth, followed by Luv Gov, Flying Private, Brave Victory, Mr. Hot Stuff, Chocolate Candy and Miner’s Escape.

There was an inquiry involving the second and fourth-place finishers (Charitable Man checked inside the eighth pole when Dunkirk may have drifted out) but stewards allowed the original order of finish to stand.

Belmont Stakes chart

Video of the Belmont.

Summer Bird, who was winning his first stakes race, covered the 1 1/2 miles on a fast track in 2:27.54, well off the 2:24 track record set by Secretariat in 1973, but the fastest Belmont since his sire, Birdstone, ended the Triple Crown hopes of Smarty Jones in 2004. Birdstone, a son of Kentucky Derby winner Grindstone, was clocked in 2:27.50.

Bred and owned by Kalarikkal and Vilasini Jayaraman and trained by Tim Ice, Summer Bird settled into fifth position early under Desormeaux, saving ground for the first mile as Dunkirk galloped through fractions of :47.13 for the opening half-mile, 1:12.43 for six furlongs and 1:37.86 for the mile. Miner’s Escape and Mr. Hot Stuff were his closest pursuers early, with Charitable Man not far behind.

Mine That Bird and Calvin Borel trailed the field early, but began their run with about five furlongs to go. Summer Bird was shuffled back to ninth as the field bunched up on the front end around the far turn, but Desormeaux bided his time and didn’t panic. Borel, meanwhile, was asking Mine That Bird for his best and he moved toward the leaders as the field rounded the final bend and into  the long stretch. Desormeaux came off the rail and rallied five wide into the stretch, gaining ground with every stride as Mine That Bird, Charitable and Dunkirk battled for the lead to inside the eighth pole. But Summer Bird had all the momentum, taking the lead at the sixteenth pole and drawing away.

It was a jockeys’ race. Desormeaux, riding in his sixth Belmont and getting his first winner, has learned from some past mistakes, such as when he moved Real Quiet to the lead too soon in the 1998 Belmont. Real Quiet, bidding for the Triple Crown, was caught at the wire by Victory Gallop, losing by a nose. It’s possible he would have been disqualified had he hung on, as Desormeaux allowed Real Quiet to drift out into Victory Gallop’s lane that year. Dexormeaux had also finished third on Free House when Touch Gold spoiled Silver Charm’s Triple Crown bid in the 1997 Belmont, and second aboard Medaglia d’Oro when rushing to the early lead and caught in the late going by Sarava in 2002, as War Emblem failed in his Triple Crown bid.

Last year, Desormeaux pulled up Kentucky  Derby and Preakness winner Big Brown at the top of the stretch when it became apparent the horse was hopelessly beaten. He was widely criticized for that move. Desormeaux, in fact, for all his successes (he’s won three Eclipse Awards, three Kentucky Derbies and is a member of the National Museum of Racing Hall of  Fame), never seems that far from controversy. For much of his career, horse players felt the Louisiana native didn’t ride hard to the finish when his mounts were beaten, complaining that it cost them a placing in exotic wagers.

Borel, also from Cajun country, was riding in his first Belmont. He boasted throughout the week that Mine That Bird would win, but Desormeaux called Borel naive about the rigors of the Belmont. It turns out experience may have mattered. Even Chip Woolley, interviewed on ABC immedately after the race, said he felt Borel moved a bit too soon in the race. The same thing happened to Stewart Elliott, who lacked big-race experience, when he moved Smarty Jones to an early lead in his failed effort. Birdstone ran him down in the final strides.

Summer Bird, produced from the Summer Squall mare Hong Kong Squall, was a late starter, going unraced as a 2-year-old and not debuting until a March 1 maiden race going six furlongs at Oaklawn Park in Arkansas. Finishing fourth that day, the colt was wheeled back 18 days later in a 1 1/16-mile maiden race at Oaklawn and won by 2 1/4 lengths. Trainer Ice put him against graded stakes competition next, where Summer Bird finished third behind Papa Clem and Old Fashioned in the Grade 2 Arkansas Derby. He was 43-1 to when finishing sixth in the Kentucky Derby in a better than looked effort, after which Summer Bird’s connection opted to replace inexperienced rider Chris Rosier with Desormeaux.  

The change in riders may have made the difference, and the Jayaramans now have their first classic winner.

POST RACE-COMMENTS OF THE WINNING CONNECTIONS:

KENT DESORMEAUX
KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN

VILASINI JAYARAMAN
TIM ICE

            KENT DESORMEAUX:  (Singing) Happy birthday to you, happy birthday to you. All right, Timmy.  Oh, that’s some good water.
            THE MODERATOR:  Okay.  We’ll be getting started in just a moment or two.  We have the happy connections of Summer Bird.  Left to right we have the trainer, Tim Ice, who celebrated his 35th birthday in style with a Belmont Stakes victory.  Now, seated next to Tim, winning rider, Kent Desormeaux, his first Belmont Stakes victory of an illustrious career.  Of course the owners, Kalarikkal Jayaraman and his wife, Devi. Congratulations to all four of you.  First I’d like to start, Tim, your first year of training, you and the horse have come a long way in an awfully short period of time.  Are you overcome by emotion after such a win as this, right?
            TIM ICE:  Right now it’s just unexplainable.  I have to thank the Jayaramans both for sticking with me.  At first it was a little rough, you know.  We had a nice colt coming on the way here.  Picked up.  They sent him to me in January.  I owe everything to them.
            THE MODERATOR:  Kent, congratulations on your first Belmont Stakes win, something I’m sure a lot of people feel is long overdue. Were you surprised aboard Summer Bird to see Mine That Bird moving in front of you?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  I got to be honest with you.  I didn’t pick up Mine That Bird till the 5/16 pole.  I was riding my horse, paying attention to details, making sure he was comfortable … I don’t think there was a bias, not saying that.  Just saying with it being fair and equal throughout.  I thought an inside trip might help me.  When I did pick him up, I was a little bit disappointed.  I was like, how am I going to catch him?  He’s already in front of me.  But when I did get that opportunity, this colt just laid down and took off.  He really exploded the last, probably 500 yards, and there was never any doubt turning for home after he changed his leads.  The only way I was going to get beat if there was somebody behind me coming, he had dead aim on the leaders.
            THE MODERATOR:  KK and Devi, you ran Summer Bird in a $1 million race, the Arkansas Derby, off just a single maiden victory. Clearly you all knew your horse had some special talent.  What gave you the confidence to make that this pretty significant step up in class so boldly?
            VILASINI JAYARAMAN:  Summer Bird was well all along as two-year-old, took a long time to get to the races, not that he had any problems. He didn’t have explosive speed of a sprinter. We kept him in the farm, trained him in the farm on the track.  We thought he was a good horse.  All the rest of the work was done by Tim Ice and I thank him.  Thank you Tim, for Kent, for his beautiful ride.
            THE MODERATOR:  Tim, in addition to all that hard work up front, you made a slight adjustment going into the race. Adding blinkers certainly seemed to pay off.
            TIM ICE:  I think adding the blinkers let him focus.  I think Kent Desormeaux helped a lot.  With the blinkers and Kent, had they put it together and won the third leg of the Triple Crown.
            THE MODERATOR:  Do you know what might be next for the Summer Bird?
            TIM ICE:  I’m not sure.  We’ll discuss it, the owners and I.  We thought about trying him on the grass, but after this, we may, you know, we have some options.  We’ll sit down and discuss it.
            THE MODERATOR:  I want to throw open questions both upstairs in the Press Box and down here in the room, and I’ll repeat the question for the benefit of those who are listening upstairs.

            Q.  For Kent, if you could just discuss the difference in emotions from last year’s Belmont to this year.
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  Last year’s Belmont was like swallowing a spoon sideways, what a pill to swallow.  I go from a horse, in my heart, I thought could not lose.  He had some adversity and lack of training.  I still didn’t think he could lose.  Things happened the way they did, he didn’t respond.  I babysat him and now here today.  Tim babysat me.  I’m very fortunate to have the opportunity to ride for Tim and Drs. Jayaraman and thankful for Belmont for putting on a great show.  Mother Nature treated us well and NetJets.

            Q.  Not only did you have Big Brown last year, you had probably the toughest beat in horse racing history, aboard Real Quiet.  You were 0-for-six in the Belmont, had two disappointing races, were you starting to think there was some (inaudible) Kent Desormeaux?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  No, not at all. Especially after the first Belmont (with Real Quiet), I slept very well.  I thought that, given the opportunity, I’d do it the same way all over again.  Hindsight is 20-20.  Cornering for home, Real Quiet, I did not think I could lose.  I don’t know what he saw.  I don’t know why he gawked.  For anyone thinks he got tired, he was not, he gawked on the lead, and the only stride Victory Gallop was a head bob on the wire, because that’s when Real Quiet saw, and three strides later, I was a length in front. So it just wasn’t meant to be.  With that being said, I did also try to, you know, maintain my confidence, know that when God had it in my plan, it would happen.

            Q.  Dr. J and Mrs. Dr. J., you’ve bred a lot of good horses; could you describe anything outstanding about this horse as a foal and also as he progressed to his early training, did anything stand out to you from the get-go?
            KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN:  I believe of about 25 two years old last year, he was a standout in the room.  He was strong.  He never had any physical problems, but he didn’t have that an explosive sprint.  He was a standout.

            Q.  Who trains at the farm?  Who trains for you at the farm?
            KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN:  I do that.

            Q.  This is a question for Tim.  When I spoke to you the other day, we kind of talked about what this would mean to your young career to have a win in the Belmont Stakes.  Now that you’ve done it, can you tell me what you think?
            TIM ICE:  I don’t know yet.  I’m still taking it in and enjoying this right now.  If my career goes nowhere from here, I’ve got a Belmont win.  They can’t take it away from me.

            Q.  You also mentioned to me that you hoped you could sort of branch out of Louisiana Downs and you thought maybe within the next year or so you would look at some other locations.  Do you think this will be sped up and what are those locations you’re looking for?
            TIM ICE:  Right now I’m settled at Louisiana Downs.  Next summer we’ll probably look at other places, maybe come up here on the east coast.  Just, you know, right now we’re going to enjoy this win and figure out everything later.

            Q.  Last question, do you think you’ll bring the horse back to the Louisiana Downs?
            TIM ICE:  He’ll go back to Louisiana Downs.

            Q.  When will that be?
            TIM ICE:  He’s going to Churchill on Monday and Churchill to Louisiana Downs.

            Q.  Tim, can you describe the process, how Kent ended up on the horse, and Kent, can you talk about with his connection to your brother, did you know him pretty well?
            TIM ICE:  Well, we called Kent after the Kentucky Derby and he was already obligated in the Preakness.  So we waited.  I talked to Joe Talamo about riding him.  We got up here. We talked to a few people.  You know, they said, we needed a rider that knows the track. And nothing against Joe, you know, we found us a rider that knows Belmont and, you know, we got the job done.

            Q.  Kent, your part of the question, did you know Tim very well because of his relationship with your brother?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  The answer is yes.  I think I’m just thankful that we did have that connection.  It’s probably part of the opportunity.  But I think personally, I think Tim, the phone will ring.  He won the Belmont. His phone will ring and I want to congratulate him on doing the right thing.  He had this horse here early.  It is very, very different lay of the land here at Belmont.  We don’t call it the Big Sandy for nothing.  The track is different.  The sand is different and the horses probably get a little stoved up training here the first couple of days already.  They’re not fast like Churchill or Pimlico.  And I think he needs a pat on the back for getting the job done.  He did it right and that’s why he’s taking his picture and that’s why his phone is going to ring.

            Q.  Tim, when we talked to you Wednesday after the horse was on the track, you liked the way he moved and looked really good.  You said if he keeps his energy up, we’re going to be hard to beat.  How was it from those days on?  Was it an anxious waiting for this day?
            TIM ICE:  We took it day-to-day.  The horse was going great all week.  Anybody that come up and ask me about him, I said this horse is going to run big.  He’s a good-feeling horse.  He was fresh, you know.  He had five weeks in between the Derby and the Belmont and that helped the colt a lot.  He’s still maturing, and, you know, he proved it today. We did the right thing by skipping the Preakness and waiting on the Belmont and bringing him here early.
            THE MODERATOR:  Dr. Jayaraman, a question from upstairs in the Press Box.  You’ve had a lot of trainers throughout your owner career. Here in Tim Ice, you have a man who’s been training on his own for just a year.  Can you discuss using Tim?
            KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN:  I cannot say anything about the trainers I had in the past.  Tim has been exceptionally good.

            Q.  Kent, you had a pretty big day today. You had three wins earlier on in the afternoon in a row.  Did that give you any extra confidence going into the Belmont Stakes?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  Yeah, I was flying high as a kite until I rode Wesley and the bottom fell out.  I was really hopeful that I thought I had a big chance in that race and I really would like to have a do-over there.  It was unfortunate I had to go into the race after Wesley.  It’s what we do as jockeys, onto the next one, erase the board, move on.  I tell you what gave me confidence, I watched this horse gallop a two-minute lick last week.  He was going better the second time around than the first time.  That’s where I had had my confidence.  It was enjoyable to watch.  I thought he was doing very well.  Not only that he definitely touted himself all the way to the game, he was … dancing, never stopped dancing.

            Q.  Kent, you probably just answered the question I’m going to ask you, but how well did you know this horse before you rode him, and can you compare it to other Belmont’s you’ve ridden, how confident were you, really, in his ability to win the race?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  Well, I’d like to tell you a story, but the reality is, I breezed him, boy I had to scrub on him just to make him do things. He did work well, but he was a horse that needed a lot of encouragement.  I got him to do what Tim and I wanted to do out of the morning breeze.  Like usual.  Morning hours, there’s nothing like afternoon horses. This horse drug me around the racetrack.  I tried to use the track tactics that offered me wins in the past.  Instead of staying three or four lengths behind a horse where his nose gets filled with sand, I tried to stick it up behind somebody so he could get his full breath. Instead of the sand pelting him in the nose, it was going under his belly.  Those little things I tried to accomplish at the Big Sandy here at Belmont.  Tim had the horse breathing fire.  I was able to steer him around the racetrack.  Everything worked out. I’m thrilled to be here talking to you about my first Belmont.

            Q.  After last year’s Belmont, did you ask yourself is there anything you could have done differently, or did you simply not have the same horse?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  I kind of think I dwelled on that a little bit, just the fact that I think I say I hope that through this, horsemen will understand and have the confidence, as usual, that if I’m given the opportunity, I try not to bail.  And usually if it’s not an ending result of success, I hope that the end result, once it’s dwelled upon, the blame finds itself elsewhere …  I can’t tell you how much I’m going inside, how well it feels to have that contentment and to be able to go home and rest at ease knowing I’ve won the three American classics.

            Q.  Kent, you’ve ridden horses going for the Triple Crown in the Belmont, now you’re on one that had the five weeks rest, being on both types of horses, how different was the feel on the fresh horse and what does that say about the attempt of these guys trying to win the Triple Crown and with the new move of horses than waiting the five weeks?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  It’s a very good question, and it’s an emphatic obvious.  It’s so dramatic to me because all of the previous mounts … this horse showed me the difference.  I mean, he was toe-y, dancing, just that bit of energy that tells you, "Let me at ‘em, let me at ‘em, I can’t wait to get to them.  I want to be a racehorse."  Whereas, the other ones, they all were kind of just here we go again.

            Q.  To either of Drs. Jayaraman, you guys took a big chance on an unknown trainer that had not much experience on his own; tell us why you chose Tim and what did you see in him to give him your horses and did you have any reservations that maybe he hadn’t had any experience, as a head trainer at least.
            KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN:  I knew Tim for three or four years when he was working as assistant for other trainers, and I thought he was doing a good job.  In the past I’ve done that also without knowing the trainers very well.

            Q.  Kent, was there a point where you perhaps you were deciding to go inside or outside or were you always waiting to pull him outside. Were you thinking of a Bo-rail ride up the inside?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  Well, I actually was thinking if Borel is going to beat me, he’s going to have to come around.  It’s a Louisiana life-long lesson.  With that being said, I actually was a little disappointed.  I thought I had waited too long, because by the time we got to the three-eighths pole, I was still covered up, and we quickened, the entire field quickened, and I went from being drug behind the flight in front of me, to being just allowing him to float, and they were opening up on me.  They actually had a better turn of foot than I did at that instant.  It was only for maybe 15 strides I’d say, at least a sixteenth of a mile, I couldn’t keep up and they no longer progressed away from me and I started eating the ground up and catching them.  That’s when I looked for a path and found a seam, and he took off even faster after I was able to clear his face up and get him clear sailing where there was no objects in front of him.

            Q.  Tim, can you talk about your decision in training for you’ve been training for 15 months what was it that made you realize it was time to go out on your own?
            TIM ICE:  I was an assistant trainer for 15 years, I put in all the hours and hard work and I thought I might as well do it for myself. It took a little longer, but I think I got a thorough knowledge of the sport and what it’s about.  I worked for Keith Desormeaux, great guy, with him five years.  Cole Norman three years, Morris Nicks for two years, a few others in between.  But those are the three that influenced me the most and, you know, I have to thank those guys as well where I’m at today because they showed me a lot, taught me, they had a lot of confidence in me to hire me.  It was just a matter of you know, turning 34, it was time I working for myself.

            Q.  Doctors, could you describe your emotions during the race when the horse started to make his move and also your emotions at the end of the race, please?
            KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN:  It was great. It was like a dream winning the Belmont.

            Q.  Were you yelling?
            KALARIKKAL JAYARAMAN:  Oh, yeah, we were yelling.
            THE MODERATOR:  Same question for you, Tim.
            TIM ICE:  All I could hear was my hollering, I couldn’t hear anybody else.  It was surreal to see the red cap, blue blinkers coming on the outside, it was just a thrilling, exciting finish.

            Q.  Kent, you’ve been in this business a long, long time, do guarantees ever work?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  I’ve given them out before and had some success.  You learn in the end you usually just shoot yourself in the foot.

            Q.  Were you surprised Calvin guaranteed?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  No, not at all, and I can’t blame him for it.  I think that you start to feel like superman, you feel invincible.  I guarantee you he went into the race with that utmost feeling he could not lose, and I wouldn’t want anybody any different on my horse.

            Q.  You had that feeling you said before Real Quiet but not before Big Brown, what was the difference between those two races?
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  Big Brown was dealing with a lot of adversity, everyone knows about the foot.  No foot, no horse.  There was the lack of training in the three weeks.  I mean, you know after the Preakness moving onto this race.  There were several moments we didn’t even know if he was going to run.  That’s the answer.
            THE MODERATOR:  Anything else for team Summer Bird?  All right, well, Tim Ice, Kent Desormeaux, Dr. Jayaraman and Devi, congratulations on a terrific berth day and happy birthday to you, Tim.
            TIM ICE:  Thank you.
            KENT DESORMEAUX:  Thank you all.

            End of FastScripts
TRANSCRIPT PROVIDED BY ASAP SPORTS: ASAPSPORTS.COM

 

QUOTES FROM MINE THAT BIRD’S CONNECTIONS: 

CALVIN BOREL
CHIP WOOLLEY
            THE MODERATOR:  Okay.  We are live in the interview room with Calvin Borel who is the rider of Mine That Bird, finishing third.  There is an inquiry in progress that still has not been adjudicated regarding the second place finisher, Dunkirk.
            Calvin, can you take us through the trip on Mine That Bird?
            CALVIN BOREL:  I had a good trip. He was fine, you know.  He was a little bit more forward, you know, like I expected going around the half, you know, and down the back side, I thought he might win.  When I got to the point I still thought he was going, I told my fiance on the weekend, that horse, he got wide in the Derby, can’t keep no credit away from my little horse.  He tried.  He run his heart out, and I wouldn’t give up for nothing in the world.
            THE MODERATOR:  In an ideal world, did you make the lead sooner than you expected?
            CALVIN BOREL:  They kind of come back to me pretty quick.  But I was still comfortable, you know, I mean, from the eighth pole to the wire, I was still comfortable.  Last 40 yards he kind of threw the towel in.  When I moved him, I was happy to get over a little bit, save a little ground, no excuses.  He run his eyeballs out.
            THE MODERATOR:  Last question before I throw it out to the media.  It’s been a very emotional five weeks for you, can you describe your emotions now that it’s come to an end?
            CALVIN BOREL:  It’s been a good road.  It’s unbelievable.  First two legs, I mean, I won’t change it for nothing in the world.  I’m going to be there tomorrow morning, try again, try to get another one.
            THE MODERATOR:  Questions in the room for Calvin?  I’ll repeat them for the benefit of those listening upstairs.

            Q.  Did he take you into the race?
            CALVIN BOREL:  He kind of took me a little earlier than I wanted in the back side.  I knew the fence wasn’t good. It’s kind of keep down there.  When I eased him out, he took me a little earlier than I wanted.  So I let him go on.  The horses in front kind of stopped, like a walk the last quarter of a mile.  Like I said, you know, he tried.  He bellied down when the horse come up to the outside. So I can’t take nothing out of him, you know.  It’s very — track is deep, you know.  He just got no excuses, nothing but race track in front of us.

            Q.  Calvin, any noticeable difference in Mine That Bird’s demeanor before or during the race?
            CALVIN BOREL:  No, sir.  He was happy.  Chip … did a good job getting him ready, keeping him happy. Main thing, to get him here, we did that. He run a good race.  Where he come from, he run a good race.

            Q.  Calvin, did he seem tired to you at all?
            CALVIN BOREL:  Not really, no.  He was — I don’t think he got tired.  If anything, you know, maybe moved him a little earlier, let him get up there earlier than I was supposed to.  I wasn’t going to take the race out of him, because I knew someone was going to plod on this and beat us, that’s what happened.

            Q.  Why did you think that Summer Bird was the horse to beat?
            CALVIN BOREL:  If you watch him run in the Derby you’d see why.  I thought that was the horse to beat.  My little colt run so hard the last two races, you can’t take nothing away from him.  Chip did a good job with him, like I said. Coming for home, I thought he was home free.  He bellied down, run his little heart out.  So, please don’t knock him down.  He’s not a bad horse.
            THE MODERATOR:  We’re also now joined by Mine That Bird’s trainer, Chip Woolley.
            Chip, first and foremost, tell us how Mine That Bird came back from the race.
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  He looked good off the track.  He wasn’t dead.  He was tired, he looked okay.  Talked to Charlie just now, he’s on his way on the barn. He looked all right.
            THE MODERATOR:  Post-Derby, Calvin, was a bevy of emotion, you were very stoic.  Calvin is pretty stoic now and graceful in defeat.  What are your emotions after this five-week run?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  My emotions are real high right now.  I want to congratulate Tim Ice.  He did a great job.  We’re disappointed, down a little bit, but the colt did run a big race.  Calvin rode a good race.  Watching it live, I haven’t watched the reply, I can’t comment too much on the race, other than I thought we might have gone ahead early.  Hard to say that when you haven’t seen the replay.  I may have a whole different outlook on it when the time comes, really sit down and watch it.  I heard Calvin say the horse was kind of fresh down the backside, kind of getting up into the bridle.  That’s kind of something he hadn’t been doing in the past.  So I think he run a great race. It’s been a lot of fun.  I was a little concerned with the horse when he went to the holding barn today.  He was a hair more, a little more amped more than he had been previous races, you know.  Maybe I had him a hair too fresh.  Maybe I should have done something different when we got here.  But it’s hard to say.
            THE MODERATOR:  Okay.  People listening in the Press Box may also ask a question.  It will get relayed down here and asked.  Questions for the trainer and jockey of Mine That Bird.

            Q.  Calvin, you talked about, you know, how much will you kind of go over your performance and your ride in a race like this when you talk about did I move him too early, did I not?
            CALVIN BOREL:  Not that I moved him too early.  The horses in front come back to me quick, going that far.  It might have looked like he was a little fresher, but they’re going a mile and a half.  He was going to put me in the race a little bit more, you know … after they passed seven-eighths of a mile, they come back real quick.  I didn’t move on him till the quarter pole. I was still happy.  We just got outrun, sir.  It’s been a hard trip, a hard run. The colt’s tried every time he run.  You can’t take nothing away from him.  Like I said, maybe might have moved a little tad early.  But he took me there  …   I mean, when they moving that easy and the horses are coming back to you that fast, it might look like he got there quicker.

            Q.  Chip, do you think your horse has done enough to wrap up the championship at this juncture?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  Not by no means. He’s going to have to step up to the plate and do more before the end of the year, if he’s got any shot at it.
            THE MODERATOR:  Chip, can you fill people in on what might be the next step for Mine That Bird, or is it too soon to figure that out?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  Well, I mean, really right now what we’re aiming at is probably another race out here on the east coast somewhere.  We haven’t picked a spot yet, kind of studying everything. Going to give him a good eight weeks between races and let him freshen up. Maybe a little time off, not much. Couple weeks off and back into training, and see if we can’t aim at something over here on the east coast, and maybe his ultimate goal, of course, is going to be the Breeder’s Cup.  So maybe two outs between now and then if the horse is doing well. I’ve got a run this by Mark Allen and Dr. Block.  They’ve given me a great opportunity here.
            THE MODERATOR:  Questions for Chip and Calvin.
            David.

            Q.  Calvin, wondering any regrets about guaranteeing –
            CALVIN BOREL:  Colt run the race. He run like I thought he would.  I can’t take nothing away from him.  I love the horse to death.  He’s an animal like a human being, just like me.  He tried his heart out, went out, performed today.  I put him in a position to win and, you know, we just got outrun.  That’s it. The other horse maybe starting to come around more seasoned now and we got outrun today; don’t take nothing away from the little horse.

            Q.  Where will he be based at for his upcoming training, Chip?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  We’re not sure yet. For the next week we’ll be at Churchill. We leave Monday morning, at Churchill for a week, and make a decision.  We’re going to stay around for Stephen Foster Day, and make a decision where to go from there.
            THE MODERATOR:  More questions for Calvin Borel or Chip Woolley?  Right here.

            Q.  Do you see this as sort of the beginning for you, kind of burst on the scene and now the horse is running great all three races, any long-term plan?  We going to see you back here every year?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  Even Wayne (Lukas) don’t make it back every year.  I’m guessing not every year, but I hope to be back. It’s been a great run.  Had a wonderful time.  We’ll be back.  We’ll be scratching and trying to get back here again.

            Q.  Calvin, will you think twice before you ever guarantee again?
            CALVIN BOREL:  No.  Not really.  I thought I was on the best horse coming in.  And I was on the best horse.  Like I said, you know, when I rode him in the Derby, he run the last race and you hook him up again.  Right now he probably run a different race again.  I feel for my animals when I ride him.  I know he’s a good colt.  I know it was five weeks back to back.  If you’re not going to come here and ride with confidence, you may as well not come.  When I come to ride races like this, I come with confidence.

            Q.  Calvin, you never thought it could get bigger than what it was, what’s it been like?
            CALVIN BOREL:  It’s been a good road.  I wouldn’t change it for nothing in the world.  Thank you, Chip, and the owners and everybody for the opportunity to ride the colt back and still do business with them.  I promise, you give this colt a little time, you’ll see a little better horse.
            THE MODERATOR:  Whenever that next start is, Chip, you expect to be giving Calvin the leg up?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  Absolutely, without a doubt.

            Q.  Do you have any questions for Tim Ice now that he’s doing the ranks of rookie classic winners, Tim Ice?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  Not really.  I just welcome him in.  It’s been a fun run and he’s a deserving guy.  The guy works hard and does a good job.

            Q.  Chip, did the horse seem the same to you today as he has been?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  Yes, I think he was. Like I said, he might have been a hair higher today coming in here, just a little more amped up.  But overall, he was the same colt that led up in the Derby. He run a great race.  I’ve got to watch the replay.  The horse run a great race. He placed himself a little more up in the race.  But other than that, I mean, he just run a great race and got beat, and you have to accept that and go on.

            Q.  Along those lines, did you have any misgivings when you saw him place himself up, placing himself forward?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  I was a little concerned he was that close.  The closer he gets, the less he’s going to have him stretch.  Kind of concerned me, but that’s some of my job to make sure when he goes out, he’s not too high and he’s not dragging Calvin out there, too.

            Q.  He it seemed from my eye to be lugging out in the stretch?
            CALVIN BOREL:  No, he was getting a little tired in the end there.  But he wasn’t lugging out in the end.  I mean, it’s just a tiring track.  It’s kind of sandy, you know, that type of track isn’t like any other.  It’s not like a regular track.  It’s a sandy track.
            THE MODERATOR:  Is it possible that last couple of furlongs what we saw might have been a result of the three grueling races?
            CALVIN BOREL:  Exactly.  Might have took a little out of him the last two races, but he rode his heart out.
            THE MODERATOR:  Any final questions for Chip or Calvin?  Gentlemen, congratulations on a thrilling and unexpectedly wonderful Triple Crown run by Mine That Bird, and best of luck to both of you in the future.

            Q.  Chip, what time will you be at the barn in the morning?
            CHIP WOOLLEY:  I’ll be early.  I’ll be there between 5:30 or so.
            THE MODERATOR:  Gentlemen, thank you very much.  Congratulations, again.
           TRANSCRIPT PROVIDED BY ASAP SPORTS: ASAPSPORTS.COM

QUOTES FROM CONNECTIONS OF THE OTHER HORSES:

Todd Pletcher, trainer of runner-up Dunkirk (No. 2): "He ran well. I told Johnny (Velazquez, jockey) the same thing I told him all week - we wanted him to get into his rhythm. He made the lead very easily and we were very happy with that. At the three-eighths pole, we thought he might have been lucky."

John Velazquez, jockey of Dunkirk: "He battled every step of the way. He just got tired late, but he ran a huge race. He was definitely tired when I pulled him up, and he tied up. I hosed him down, and he seemed to be okay. I couldn’t believe I was on the lead early. There was no pace. The way he broke, he was already there on the lead, so I didn’t want to hold him back. I didn’t see Mine That Bird, and he came to me at the eighth-pole. Then, I got after my horse and he put up a real good fight and came back to beat Mine That Bird for second. He just ran his eyeballs out, but unfortunately, we just got beat."

Chip Woolley, trainer of third-place finisher Mine That Bird (No. 7): "He looked good coming off the track. He was tired, he was used, but he looked all right. I want to congratulate Tim Ice. He’s done a great job with the horse. We’re a little down, disappointed right now. I thought he might have moved a hair early, but I haven’t watched the replay. He ran a great race. It’s been a lot of fun. We’ll give him a good eight weeks off and let him freshen up. We’ll aim at something on the East Coast."

Calvin Borel, jockey of Mine That Bird: "I thought I had it won when I got to the quarter-pole. They came back to me pretty quick. When I moved, I was happy. No excuses. He ran his eyeballs out. He took me a little earlier. When I eased him out, the horses in front kind of stopped. He got out-run, no excuses. He had a lot of racetrack in front of him. He ran a good race. I don’t think he got tired. I might have let him get up earlier, but I wasn’t going to take the race out of him. Turning for home, I thought he was home-free. He ran his heart out. I put him position to win, and we just got out-run.. Don’t take anything away from the little horse.

(about guaranteeing victory): "No regrets. I thought I was on the best horse going in. I know he’s a good horse. He’s been five weeks, back to back. It’s been a good roll, and I wouldn’t change it for anything."

Kiaran McLaughlin, trainer of fourth-place finisher Charitable Man (No. 6): "It was a pretty fast pace going that far. I was confident he was going to run well. He ran well, but I thought he was good enough to win, so it’s disappointing."

Alan Garcia, jockey of Charitable Man: "He ran good, my horse. I saw Dunkirk; he went to the lead and I was waiting.. I saw Summer Bird make a move and I said, `OK, it’s time to go.’  My horse kept going, and then he got tired.  He ran a good race and I’m happy with the way he ran."

D. Wayne Lukas, trainer of fifth-place finisher Luv Gov (No. 5) and sixth-place Flying Private (No. 8): "No [excuse] that I can see, it’s sort of tough to watch it live. I want to see the replay.  I don’t know if we got a track that was conducive, but I don’t want to make any excuses, I would rather watch the replay first and see what it looks like. You know, when you watch it live up there and a mile and a half it’s pretty hard to find them out there.  I thought that horse was live that won it and I thought Dunkirk ran a beautiful race.  It wasn’t all that surprising, I thought Summer Bird had an excellent chance the way he’s been closing and we’ll salute the winners and rack ‘em up next year."

Julien Leparoux, jockey of Flying Private: "I had a very good trip actually, but my horse didn’t get there for me - I just ran out of horse."; Miguel Mena, jockey of Luv Gov: Unavailable for comment.

Eoin Harty, trainer of eighth-place finisher Mr. Hot Stuff (No. 3): "Edgar (Prado, jockey) had him in position to win, but ultimately, it wasn’t good enough"

Edgar Prado, jockey of Mr. Hot Stuff: "When Summer Bird made that move on the turn, no one was going to catch him."

Jerry Hollendorfer, trainer of ninth-place finisher Chocolate Candy (No. 1): "He pulled up good, but we had no excuses. We ship out on Monday."

Garrett Gomez, jockey of Chocolate Candy: Unavailable for comment.

Nick Zito, trainer of seventh-place finisher Brave Victory (No. 10) and 10th-place finisher Miner’s Escape (No. 9): "Brave Victory — I don’t know where, he got stepped on, but he’s got a big gash on his knee. He’ll be okay. He was moving nice the first time and he might have been a little closer. I’m not making excuses. Rajiv said Mine That Bird made a pretty quick move on them. I’m not taking anything away from the Birdstones [NOTE: Winner Summer Bird and third-place Mine That Bird were both sired by Birdstone, who won the 2004 Belmont Stakes with Zito as his trainer].

"I was kind of surprised that Dunkirk took the lead.  You know, I think if Miner’s Escape got that spot we might have run a little better but he had no excuse.  The horse stumbled a little but he recovered pretty quick. I’m not making excuses, but he had a bad break."

Jose Lezcano, jockey of Miner’s Escape: "He had a fair trip, he put himself in a good spot where I would want to be.  I thought I had striking position and at the end I don’t know if he got worn out or whatever, but he just didn’t have the winning touch."

Rajiv Maragh, jockey of Brave Victory: "I had the time of my life!  I had a good trip and he put himself in a good spot, unfortunately he just didn’t have that winning punch.  I’m a little disappointed, but he tried hard and I can’t be too mad at the horse or myself, it’s not everyday, you can’t win every race, but we had a fair shot at it."

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick