Posts Tagged ‘gary contessa’

By Ray Paulick
The good news at the Ocala Breeders’ Sales company’s February select sale of 2-year-olds in training is that Thoroughbred racing continues to hold a fascination with people who have worked hard, enjoyed a certain measure of success, and want to live out a longtime dream to have their own racing stable.

That was the case with Chuck and Maribeth Sandford, who stepped up in a big way with their first auction purchase, a $475,000 colt by Tiznow who topped the one-day OBS sale in Ocala on Tuesday. The Sandfords come from Marengo, Ill., a small farming community in the northern Illinois cornbelt; they built a business from scratch that has been highly successful (click here to learn about their business), and in the last year have made the transition from horse racing fans to owners.

That’s welcome news for anyone in the Thoroughbred trade, especially at a time when many existing owners are cutting back on their stables. There has always been turnover in the ranks of owners, or among buyers at public auction, but for the industry’s future health it has to continue to have a magnetic appeal that attracts individuals like Chuck and Maribeth Sandford who have a dream.

How much turnover in buyers was there at this year’s one-day sale? In 2009, there were 19 individual buyers who spent $150,000 or more at the OBS February auction. Of those 19, only two spent at that level in 2010, and both made considerable cutbacks—West Point Thoroughbreds, through agent Buzz Chace going from six purchases for $1,260,000 in 2009 to three for $340,000 in 2010; and Dogwood Stables, going from five for $545,000 in 2009 to five for $355,000 in 2010.

Last year’s second-leading buyer behind West Point was Westrock Stable, which spent $595,000 for four horses. Westrock was not listed as a buyer this year. A number of other buyers who bought at least one horse in 2009 were not among 2010 buyers, including Coolmore associate Demi O’Byrne, Sheikh Mohammed’s chief bloodstock adviser John Ferguson, the Sanan family’s Padua Stables, and trainers Ken McPeek and Gary Contessa.

Fortunately, in the absence of so many 2009 buyers, there were purchases totaling $150,000 or more from 11 entities in 2010  that were not among the leading buyers last year, including Amy Tarrant’s Hardacre Farm, the sale’s leading buyer with two purchases for $675,000; the Sandfords, second leading buyer with their one purchase; California-based agent Hubert Guy, third-leading buyers with four purchases for $465,000; Let’s Go Stable, fourth-leading buyer with one purchase for $400,000; and the Steinbrenner family’s Kinsman Farm, seventh-leading buyer with two purchases for $300,000.

A boutique sale with only 160 horses catalogued cannot be used as a reliable barometer for the health of the Thoroughbred marketplace. But the results of Tuesday’s sale followed the forecast of Leprechaun Racing’s Mike Mulligan, a major pinhooker who also serves as president of the National Association of Two-Year-Old Consignors. Mulligan told the Paulick Report last week that buyers in past years who might spend $60,000 to $80,000 apiece for eight or nine horses at a 2-year-old sale are more likely now to cut back on the number purchased but focus more on higher quality, thus spending more per horse. That’s why this year’s sale saw a much steeper decline in the median price, dropping 25.6% from $90,000 to $66,000, than in the average price, which fell by 8.2%, from $106,115 to $97,182 (click here for the full results). And with more people focusing on the high-end horses and creating more competition at that level, there are going to be shoppers who were turned away without getting what they wanted. That may bode well for consignors who have the goods in upcoming auctions.

Copyright © 2010, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.



Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

The following quotes were released by NYRA after a puzzling ending to a much anticipated 2010 debut for Eightfiveinafifty.

 
Timothy Kreiser, winning trainer of Peppi Knows (No. 3): “Everything went well, obviously what happened with [No. 2 Eightyfiveinafifty], I don’t know.  It helped things, I guess, maybe it didn’t.  It would have been nice to see that horse run just to see what we had there.  We can’t do anything about that, he ran his race and we’re really happy.  The rider did everything perfect – he didn’t rush him, he just settled him down.  With that horse out – that’s what all the talk was about – so if he’s out of it, you think you have a heck of a chance.  We took advantage of it.” 
 
Richard Migliore, winning jockey aboard Peppi Knows (No. 3): “It worked out real good for us.  We got to save ground when the other horse didn’t make the turn.  He’s just a real nice handy little horse.  He’s not a whole lot to look at, but he has a big heart.  Anytime he felt the presence of the other horse, he ran on a little more.  I just hope Jorge’s alright.” 
 
Gary Contessa, trainer of favored Eightyfiveinafifty, who bolted during the first turn, unseating rider Jorge Chavez: “The horse is okay.  He has a two-inch cut on his right hind leg, and he’ll need a couple of stitches, but he was walking sound.  I’m completely mystified as to what happened.  I don’t know if it was the horse, the jockey, or an equipment malfunction. The bit was broken and the rein was shredded – the equipment was in shambles – but I don’t know if that happened during the race or after he bolted.  He’s handled the turns fine in the mornings.  I have no idea what happened.”
 
Note: Jockey Jorge Chavez was conscious and taken by ambulance to North Shore University Hospital for further evaluation.   

By Ray Paulick
When the committee that doles out Eclipse Awards of Merit or Special Eclipse Awards announced the other day that Thoroughbred Retirement Foundation founder and longtime chairman Monique Koehler would be a recipient of a Special Eclipse Award next month, my first thought was, “What took so long?”

But then I remembered this is an industry predicated on past performances, and the past performances suggest that recognition of people and organizations dedicated to the health and welfare of retired racehorses comes reluctantly and over time.

I first became aware of the TRF more than 20 years ago, some five years after Koehler started the organization in 1982. I was working for a Thoroughbred publication and was asked to come up with a list of potential story ideas to be used for upcoming features. I called some friends in different parts of the country looking for ideas and one of them told me about this fascinating operation based at an upstate New York prison that took in retired racehorses and stabled them at the prison, where inmates would care for them. It was a proverbial win-win situation: good for the horses, good for the rehabilitation of the inmates.

When I suggested to the editor that a feature on the TRF be considered, I thought for sure I’d get two thumbs up. I was stunned when he told me, “Oh, we can’t do that. We don’t want people to find out what really happens to all those horses when they’re done racing.”

It was my first exposure to one of the sport’s dirty little secrets, that ex-racehorses often wind up in a slaughterhouse somewhere, destined for a dinner plate overseas, or perhaps as food for a dog or other animal. Turns out the glue factory was more than a cliché.

Monique and the TRF’s longtime executive director, Diana Pikulski, have fought hard for the organization’s mission to be recognized, much less accepted, in the Thoroughbred media and by the industry they have done so much to help. As the TRF grew, admitting more horses into a prison program that expanded to other states and to satellite farms, the struggle became an economic one of how to feed and care for the thousands of Thoroughbreds retired from the racetrack each year.

Gradually, they picked up important advocates, like the late John Hettinger, whose money, influence and outspoken passion for the cause advanced the TRF and its mission. Many similar organizations popped up around the country, but the TRF to this day remains the largest national charity devoted to helping retired Thoroughbred racehorses.

Critics, including, ironically, the American Association of Equine Practitioners, an organization also devoted to the health and welfare of horses, have pooh-poohed the TRF and similar organizations, saying their efforts to save horses represent a drop in the bucket when compared to the total number of unwanted Thoroughbreds. But should the fact that not all Thoroughbreds can be saved from slaughter or neglect prevent rescue and retirement organizations from saving those they can, and often placing them in second careers as performance or pleasure horses?

I don’t think so, and I believe the AAEP has been on the wrong side of this issue for many years. (Disclosure: I served on the AAEP board of directors in a non-veterinary “industry seat” for three years where I tried to be an advocate for rescue/retirement groups. I currently am a member of the TRF board.)

The efforts of Koehler, Pikulski, Hettinger, web publisher and horseman Alex Brown and many others have raised awareness to this issue, and some of racing’s largest institutions now recognize that supporting racehorse retirement is not only the right thing to do, but the smart thing to do for the industry’s tarnished image among the general public.

Along the way, trainers like Nick Zito, Todd Pletcher, Gary Contessa and the late John Russell stepped forward as advocates, along with owners and breeders like Gary Biszantz, Madeline Auerbach and the late Trudy McCaffery (there are many more who have stepped up). Numerous breeders and stallion farms have supported fundraisers through the donation of stallion seasons.

Richard Fields, the majority owner of Suffolk Downs, showed tremendous leadership when instituting a policy at the New England racetrack banning trainers who dump horses into auctions where the animals usually are destined for slaughter. Churchill Downs and Magna Entertainment developed policies and positions of support for racehorse retirement, and most recently the New York Racing Association adopted a policy and pledged funds to assist the retirement of horses. The Jockey Club has taken a strong position of support, and that was a most significant development.

There are holdouts, including the National Thoroughbred Racing Association, whose silence and lack of leadership on the issue is a sore spot with many people. But as Monique Koehler knows more than anyone else, these things take time.

So rather than criticizing the committee that took more than a quarter of a century to recognize Monique Koehler for starting a national movement that represents so much that is good about the people in this industry, I say “thank you” to the organizations that voted her this award: the Daily Racing Form, National Turf Writers Association and even the NTRA.

More importantly, if they could talk, the thousands of horses that have been or will be saved as a result of Monique’s tireless dedication and advocacy would say thank you as well.

The best way you can thank Monique is by supporting the TRF through a donation. Click here to learn more about the organization and here to make a donation.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

Liberation Farm celebrates the many horsemen and horsewomen who strive each day to make things better for horses and those who work with them.  To learn more about Liberation Farm, click here.