Posts Tagged ‘d. wayne lukas’
Thursday, February 25th, 2010

By Ray Paulick
Todd Pletcher isn’t the only who had a big weekend last week, winning three American Graded Stakes races for 3-year-olds on Feb. 20: the Grade 2 Fasig-Tipton Fountain of Youth at Gulfstream Park with Eskendereya, the Grade 2 Risen Star Stakes at Fair Grounds with Discreetly Mine, and the Grade 3 El Camino Real Derby at Golden Gate Fields with Connemara.
Coolmore Ashford’s Giant’s Causeway sired two of the Pletcher-trained AGS winners, Eskendereya and Connemara, giving the 13-year-old Storm Cat stallion a total of three AGS winners thus far in 2010 (San Pasqual Handicap winner Neko Bay is the other one). For good measure, another top 3-year-old prospect by Giant’s Causeway, Northern Giant, finished a solid third for Pletcher’s mentor, Hall of Fame trainer D. Wayne Lukas, in the Risen Star. Only 16 days earlier, Northern Giant turned in a huge effort winning an Oaklawn Park maiden race by 11 1/4 lengths. He’s obviously a slow developing colt, the win coming in his sixth start.
On the strength of those AGS winners, Giant’s Causeway is atop the general sire list thus far in 2010 after being leading North American sire in 2009 for the first time since his first crop reached the racetrack in 2004. He was a truly outstanding racehorse and it’s no surprise that he’s developed into an elite sire. Giant’s Causeway has yet to sire his first American classic winner, but Eskendereya, who moved to the top of many Kentucky Derby lists with his Fountain of Youth victory, could easily change that.
With his weekend victories, trainer Pletcher now has won eight AGS races of 2010 with seven different horses. That’s 16% of the 50 AGS races run so far this year. Pletcher is on a brief “vacation” now, the result of a suspension stemming from a positive test at the 2008 Breeders’ Cup. His stable is deep in talent, is coming off a very strong 2009, and is ranked as the leading trainer by money won so far in 2010 (with reigning Eclipse Award winner Steven Asmussen in hot pursuit) while winning at a 27% clip. With Quality Road leading the way in the older male division, an incredibly deep roster of 3-year-old talent, and undoubtedly a talented group of 2-year-olds now going through early training, this could be a year to remember for Pletcher.



Tags: American Graded Stakes Standings, ashford stud, Connemara, coolmore, d. wayne lukas, Discreetly Mine, El Camino Real Derby, Eskendereya, fair grounds, fasig-tipton, Fountain of Youth, giant's causeway, golden gate fields, gulfstream park, hall of fame, Keeneland, kentucky derby, Neko Bay, Northern Giant, oaklawn park, Paulick Report, Quality Road, Ray Paulick, Risen Star Stakes, San Pasqual Handicap, steve asmussen, storm cat, todd pletcher Posted in American Graded Stakes Standings, Keeneland | 1 Comment »
Wednesday, September 9th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
How about this for a 2010 Kentucky Derby dream script? D. Wayne Lukas and Bob Baffert, who have had their share of ups and downs in this sport, come to Louisville with the leading two contenders for the 136 Run for the Roses. Even the old-time Derby impresario Matt Winn would have had a hard time coming up with a better story line to promote America’s most famous horse race.
It could happen, judging from the results of Monday’s two Grade 1 races for 2-year-old colts, the Three Chimneys Hopeful Stakes at Saratoga won by the Lukas-trained Dublin, and the Del Mar Futurity won by the Baffert-trained Lookin at Lucky. Both colts turned in strong performances to win their respective races, and they each have the pedigree to continue as the races get longer. It’s a long, long way, however, from the first Monday in September to the first Saturday in May, and a lot can happen. But Lukas and Baffert each are well stocked with well-bred and talented 2-year-olds, and history shows they know what it takes to win the Kentucky Derby.
It would be great for this sport if these two Hall of Famers and now-fast friends do show up at Churchill Downs with the leading Derby contenders next spring. Lukas and Baffert have been the two most recognizable faces and best spokesmen for the game when the media and general public are paying attention—during the Triple Crown.
Seven Derbies have passed since Baffert last stood in the infield winner’s circle and it’s been 10 years for Lukas. They were synonymous with the race in the 1990s, when the sport and the industry at its foundation were going through better times. Neither Lukas nor Baffert is big enough or strong enough to save the sport on their own, but their success can help move it back into the spotlight.
It was hard to believe when reading David Grening’s Daily Racing Form recap of the Hopeful that Lukas has gone nearly four years without a Grade 1 victory—his last one coming with Folklore in the 2005 Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Fillies at Belmont Park. That’s a huge drop from the 1980s and early ‘90s when “D. Wayne off the plane†was winning Grade 1 races in bunches, from coast to coast. There were the 10 consecutive North American training titles by money won, from 1983-92, and four more from 1994-97. In 2008, Lukas finished 93rd by money won. Lukas also started a horse in 20 consecutive Kentucky Derbies, from 1981-2000, a total of 38 in all (and, yes, I know, and Wayne probably would admit that some of those horses didn’t belong). But he’s been without a starter in five of the last nine Derbies, a race he won four times between 1988 and 1999.
Some of Lukas’ most important owners, like Bob Lewis and W.T. Young, died, and some others moved on to different trainers.
Baffert hasn’t experienced quite as severe a drought, but he, too, has weathered some storms in recent years. Prince Ahmed Salman and Bob Lewis were important patrons of Baffert, and his stable suffered from their deaths. Like Lukas, Baffert also lost some owners to other trainers, but he’s had some loyal ones, too, like Lookin for Lucky’s owner Mike Pegram, who convinced Baffert to make the transition to Thoroughbreds.Â
Baffert won the North American money title four consecutive years, from 1998-2001, but in three of the last four years (2005-08), he slipped out of the top 10. In six years, from 1996 (when Cavonnier fell a nose short of the Lukas-trained Grindstone, almost giving Baffert a Derby win as a rookie) to 2001, Baffert started 11 horses in the Derby. In the eight years since, he’s had just seven Derby starters. He’s won the Derby three times, with two seconds and two thirds.
D. WAYNE LUKAS STATISTICS, 2002-09
| Year |
Starts |
Wins |
Money Won |
(Rank) |
Kentucky Derby Starters |
| 2009 |
292 |
33 |
$2,003,913 |
(42) |
1 |
| 2008 |
431 |
45 |
$1,950,415 |
(93) |
0 |
| 2007 |
415 |
49 |
$2,424,503 |
(57) |
0 |
| 2006 |
450 |
41 |
$2,323,368 |
(62) |
0 |
| 2005 |
601 |
72 |
$4,585,321 |
(16) |
1 |
| 2004 |
577 |
67 |
$5,572,299 |
(15) |
0 |
| 2003 |
663 |
71 |
$4,779,832 |
(18) |
2 |
| 2002 |
474 |
82 |
$5,996,362 |
(9) |
1 |
BOB BAFFERT STATISTICS, 2002-09
| Year |
Starts |
Wins |
Money Won |
(Rank) |
Kentucky Derby Starters |
| 2009 |
344 |
66 |
$6,224,247 |
(3) |
 1 |
| 2008 |
322 |
60 |
$7,137,579 |
(12) |
 0 |
| 2007 |
430 |
73 |
$7,150,072 |
(11) |
 0 |
| 2006 |
392 |
91 |
$8,136,567 |
(6) |
 3 |
| 2005 |
467 |
94 |
$5,991,799 |
(12) |
 1 |
| 2004 |
562 |
105 |
$7,627,913 |
(5) |
0 |
| 2003 |
674 |
127 |
$9,442,281 |
(5) |
1 |
| 2002 |
686 |
133 |
$12,029,115 |
(2) |
1 |
While both came from the Quarter horse ranks, they were more rivals than friends in the 1990s when Baffert appeared on the Thoroughbred scene and threatened Lukas’ dominance over the sport. But as the years have passed and both men have mellowed, they’ve become good friends. Baffert even asked Lukas to introduce him at this year’s Hall of Fame induction ceremonies, something Lukas did with his usual flair.
Both are enjoying a revival in 2009. Baffert surged to third in the trainer money-won standings following an unforgettable Labor Day weekend at Del Mar that included three Grade 1 victories (Zensational in the Pat O’Brien, Richard’s Kid in the Pacific Classic, and Lookin at Lucky in the Del Mar Futurity—all for different owners). Lukas, though ranked 42nd by money won, is just getting his 2-year-olds going, and he has said he’s loaded, thanks to some new owners, including Legends Racing (which also has horses with Baffert and Nick Zito) and Scott Ford of Westrock Stable, along with some mainstays, including Dublin’s owners, William Mack and Robert Baker.
“This was my No. 1 pick in the sales,†Lukas said of Dublin (who was one of two Grade 1 winners at Saratoga over the weekend sold as yearlings by Gerry Dilger’s Dromoland, the other being Spinaway winner Hot Dixie Chick). “I still haven’t lost my eye in that part. I like to play in the main arena – these 2-year-olds, when they turn 3, that’s the name of the game.â€
The boys—Lukas and Baffert–are back, and I think the game is better off because of it.
Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report
Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: Bob Baffert, bob lewis, d. wayne lukas, del mar futurity, dublin, eclipse award winning trainers, hall of fame trainers, hopeful, kentucky derby, lookin at lucky, mike pegram, Paulick Report, prince ahmed salman, Ray Paulick, run for the roses, scott ford, Triple Crown, westrock stable Posted in People, Racing Greats, kentucky derby, racing hall of fame | 25 Comments »
Thursday, July 9th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
How appropriate that just a few days before the Hollywood Gold Cup, the signature event of the Southern California racetrack of lakes and flowers, the Inglewood city council has driven the last nail into the track’s proverbial coffin. The once-proud Hollywood, a place where tens of thousands of people would come out for an ordinary day of racing, where champions like Citation and Swaps and Affirmed would make headlines, where people like Cary Grant and Elizabeth Taylor could be seen reading the Daily Racing Form and rubbing elbows with the fans…that track will soon be nothing but a memory as the Bay Meadows Land Co. prepares to bring in the wrecking ball and develop it into something called Hollywood Park Tomorrow.
I yearn for Hollywood Park yesterday.
Times change, though I often wish they didn’t. The death knell for Hollywood Park came when Churchill Downs Inc. sold the track, three years ago last Tuesday to the Bay Meadows Land Co. Then CDI president Tom Meeker said California “has forsaken racing and its needs.†If things were grim for the sport in California then, how do you think it looks now, with Bay Meadows also bought and closed for development by the same Bay Meadows Land Co., and Golden Gate Fields and Santa Anita Park in the middle of owner Magna Entertainment’s bankruptcy proceedings.
But Hollywood Park yesterday was the place that solidified my love of the sport. My first racetrack experiences were in Chicago in the mid-1970s, but it wasn’t until I moved to Southern California in the spring of 1979 that I got to see the best of what racing offered.
That was the year Affirmed carried 132 pounds to victory in the Gold Cup, covering the mile and a quarter in an incredible 1:58 2/5 while pushed the whole way by the Italian champion Sirlad. It was the year a hotshot California-bred named Flying Paster, winner of the Hollywood Derby, would carry the hopes of West Coast racing fans to the Kentucky Derby, where he would be crushed by Spectacular Bid, a colt who would come West a year later and continue to dominate that same rival.
Legends like Shoemaker, Pincay, McCarron, Hawley, and McHargue populated the jockeys room, Trainer Charlie Whittingham dominated the big races, and the stands were packed to the gills every weekend. Little did I know then that the 24,930 average daily attendance from the 77-day meeting of 1979 was down considerably from just a few years earlier, when Hollywood averaged over 30,000. Santa Anita Park was getting the upper hand under the marketing innovations of Alan Balch.
Not to be outdone, track owner Marje Everett pulled out all the stops in 1980 to reverse the “sagging†business figures. On Sunday, May 4, 1980, the day after Genuine Risk beat the California-bred Rumbo in the Kentucky Derby, Hollywood Park tried something new–a “giveaway†for every paid admission, of a canvas tote bag.Â
I was one of the 80,348 on hand that day, though I didn’t even know about the tote bag giveaway. I had come to see the ongoing rivalry between ex-claimer Wishing Well (who went on to produce Horse of the Year Sunday Silence) and Country Queen in the Gamely Handicap. I’ll never forget the traffic jam on Century Boulevard trying to get into Hollywood Park that day, or the lines for concessions and betting. I managed to snag one of the tote bags, and, somehow, 29 years later I still have it. Though it’s a bit the worse for wear, the bag is a reminder for me of the glory days of the sport.
That same year, Hollywood Park introduced Pick Six wagering (they even gave away a Pick Six beach towel in the image of a $100 bill….signed by “Secretary of the Treasury Vernon O. Underwood”) , and the racing was highlighted by incredible performances from Spectacular Bid in the Mervyn LeRoy and Californian Stakes (I kept my free “Bid and The Shoe†T-shirt for years until it mysteriously shrunk and no longer fit me). Average attendance soared to 31,150 in 1980.
Hollywood Park is where I stood in awe alongside my friend and former Daily Racing Form colleague Jay Hovdey, watching a 2-year-old daughter of Seattle Slew, named Landaluce, power her way to victory in the 1982 Lassie Stakes, a race since renamed in her honor. She drew off down the stretch of the six-furlong event to win by an implausible 21 lengths, covering the distance in 1:08 flat for an up-and-coming trainer named D. Wayne Lukas. It’s the track where the first Breeders’ Cup was held in 1984, when Everett pulled a few favors with her Hollywood pals and made it a star-studded event for people and horses. It’s been a huge part of racing history since its opening in 1938. Click here for a trip through Hollywood Park’s history in the introduction to the track’s media guide.
I could go on with the memories of this track, just as I could listen all day long to the deadly accurate and gravelly voiced race calls of the late Harry Henson. It’s not the same as it used to be—few places are—and since moving to Kentucky in 1988 I don’t get there as often as I’d like to.
I loved Hollywood Park, its horses, its people and its energy, but mostly for how it made me feel about racing.
Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report
Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: affirmed, alan balch, bay meadows land company, charlie whittingham, churchill downs, country queen, d. wayne lukas, Harry Henson, hollywood gold cup, Hollywood Park, hollywood park tomorrow, inglewood city council, jay hovdey, landaluce, marje everett, Paulick Report, pick six, racing innovations, Ray Paulick, seattle slew, sirlad, spectacular bid, sunday silence, tom meeker, tote bag giveaway, wishing well Posted in California, Hollywood Park, Racing Greats | 24 Comments »
Wednesday, June 10th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
I have one framed winner’s circle photograph in my possession. It was taken in 2000 at Fair Grounds in New Orleans after William T. Young’s Shawnee Country won the Grade 3 Fair Grounds Oaks carrying his Overbrook Farm silks. I always stayed out of winner’s circle photos, even when invited, because I never thought a journalist covering a race should show the appearance of favoring one horse or owner over another. So when Mr. Young saw me down on the track, where I was waiting to do some interviews, he asked me to come in and have my picture taken. I shook my head and said politely, “No thank you, I don’t like to do that.”
“Well, that’s just plain silly,” he said, then locked his arm around my elbow and literally dragged me in to stand next to him. When the shutters clicked, Mr. Young’s arm still locked around mine, I had the look of someone who had just taken a big bite out of a lemon; I wasn’t very happy to be there after being strong-armed by an octogenarian, even though I had the utmost respect and admiration for him.
A couple of weeks after his death in January 2004, Mr. Young’s longtime secretary, Mary Agnes, called me up and asked if I wouldn’t mind stopping by the W.T. Young offices. When I got there she gave me a framed copy of the picture, the one I’d tried to forget and had never seen. Today it’s one of the most prized possessions from my years in this sport.
I thought of that New Orleans afternoon and the other times I had the great opportunity to be around this Kentucky gentleman when I learned yesterday that all of the breeding stock and most of the horses currently racing in the Overbrook Farm name will be sold at Keeneland, beginning in September with the yearlings, and continuing with the November and January breeding stock and horses of all ages sales. Eaton Sales will handle the consignment. Click here for the details.
It truly is the end of a remarkable era in Thoroughbred racing and breeding.
Young’s longtime friend and trainer, D. Wayne Lukas, said it’s akin to the automobile business losing Chrysler or General Motors (something we actually may be very close to seeing). But none of us really should have been that surprised that the operation is shutting down, and Lukas saw the writing on the wall.
“Once Bill had passed away the passion and driving force behind Overbrook lost something,” the Hall of Fame trainer said. “Bill Young was passionate about racing, adamant that Overbrook would be a first-class operation, and something to last for years to come. Once he passed away, things changed. To Bill’s credit, Junior kept it going, though it transformed more into a commercial operation.”
“Junior” would be Bill Young Jr., W.T. Young’s son, who runs the business empire his father built but who admittedly doesn’t share the passion the elder Young had for Thoroughbred racing and breeding. Bill’s son, Chris, has been in charge of the Overbrook racing stable and will continue to race horses in the Overbrook name and carry the blue and green bull’s-eye silks that have became so familiar in major races around the country. Overbrook Farm as a major breeding entity will cease to exist. The 2,400-acre Lexington farm will be leased and remain the home of the pensioned stallion Storm Cat, who made Overbrook a commercial juggernaut in the 1990s and into the current decade. Other Overbrook stallions to be relocated will be able to return to the farm as pensioners, Bill Young said.
“You’re looking at a big operation,” Lukas said. “Even with Chris’s passion, if he threw all of his energies into it he would still have a tremendous economic expense ahead of him. Without a major sire, the bottom line doesn’t make any sense. Without the passion to drive it, it doesn’t make any sense.”
Bill Young said as much in an interview yesterday. “The economics have become more challenging but it’s a challenge I could have lived with if I’d gotten pleasure from racing or raising a great racehorse,” he said. “But my background is not horse farming and I don’t have the love for it to offset the economic challenge.
“It’s been a little bit bittersweet in reaching the conclusion I reached,” he said. “My family obviously enjoyed a great experience with Overbrook, and even though the Thoroughbred business is a good business I just don’t share the passion for it. We as a family have been kicking this around for a while. Chris has more of a love than anyone in the family for the business, and his interest is in racing. He’ll continue that.”
“We’ll sell a majority of the stable,” Chris Young said. “We’ll keep some colts and fillies, though we haven’t quite decided the ongoing plans for the racing stable. I’ll breed or buy a few horses.” The Overbrook name and silks will live on, Chris Young said, “because there’s lots of good history and memories attached to them.”
Bill Young said there are no plans to sell the farm or any of the property. Though much of it is inside the Fayette County urban service boundary, Overbrook is zoned for agricultural use and Young said there are no plans to develop it “at this time.”
William T. Young came into racing and breeding late in life, after concentrating on various businesses and philanthropic activities in the Lexington community. He was in his 60s when he built Overbrook and developed an operation that won a Kentucky Derby, Kentucky Oaks and Breeders’ Cup Classic, among other races, and several Eclipse Awards. The farm was immaculately planned and laid out.
“The thing that Bill emphasized was understated elegance,” said Lukas. “He didn’t want to be ostentatious or have the farm stand out or show off. It was subtle in its elegance. He built it that way and it is one of the more beautiful farms in Kentucky: a real showplace. He tried to have it blend with the landscape.”
Lukas remembers the day when he first met Young. “He called me up and said he’d like to fly to California, and he came out with Bob Warren (Young’s longtime adviser) and we sat down and had a visit. He said, ‘I want you to become a huge part of Overbrook and do for me what you did for Gene Klein.’”
The timing was perfect, Lukas said, as Klein was getting ready to get out of the game. Though Storm Cat, who finished second for Young in the 1985 Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, had been trained by Jonathan Sheppard, Lukas developed the remainder of Overbrook’s 21 Grade 1 winners. They made quite a team, two driven men with a passion for the game.
Young liked to share his passion with others, whether it was horse racing, politics or University of Kentucky athletics. There were times during my years at the Blood-Horse that Young would call up and ask me to stop by his office to debate issues in racing that I may have written about. He was adamant, for example, that racetracks should be able to have slot machines because he didn’t think government should legislate what people can or can’t do with their time and money. I was opposed to the idea of slots at the time, not for economic reasons, but simply because I felt it was taking the moral high ground to keep racing apart from such a mindless activity. “Who are you,” he asked me politely, “to tell someone what they should or shouldn’t do?” Of course, I didn’t fail to remind him that he was a major shareholder in Churchill Downs who might benefit from slots. That didn’t seem to matter, either. “I’ve got enough money,” he said.
I never left his office feeling I’d won any of our debates, but always felt that he listened to what I said.
Young also loved to surprise people with his generosity. He and Keeneland’s Ted Bassett took a couple of longtime hourly employees from the Lexington racetrack to New York on Young’s private jet for a day of shopping, dining and theater. On another occasion he took Stone Farm’s Arthur Hancock III and a longtime employee of Idle Hour Country Club by private jet to a University of Kentucky game in Georgia. Shortly after takeoff, the jet experienced mechanical failure, and began to quickly lose altitude. The pilot said they’d have to return to Lexington, but Young pointed him toward Louisville where they could get a substitute jet. When they landed safely in Louisville, Hancock and the Idle Hour worker dropped to their knees and kissed the ground, thankful they were still alive. “Can we get a car and drive back to Lexington,” the man suggested to Hancock.
“No,” Young told them, “we’re not going to abort the mission.”
“It’s like the poem says, ‘He walked with kings but had the common touch,’” Hancock said of Young, a friend and partner in the horse business. “One time he said life would be pretty boring if we didn’t have these horses racing. I said, ‘You’re right, but I guess we’re prejudiced.’ That’s just the way he felt. He loved to compete and he liked the people, and he gave me a lot of good advice. I loved him. It’s sad, and the news about the dispersal came as a shock to me, but people have to do what they’ve got to do.”
Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report
Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: arthur b. hancock III, bill young, bill young jr., bob warren, chris young, d. wayne lukas, eaton sales, fair grounds oaks, Horse Racing, Keeneland, overbrook farm, Paulick Report, Ray Paulick, shawnee country, thoroughbred dispersals, thoroughbred racing and breeding, w.t. young, william t. young Posted in Dispersals, Kentucky, People, Thoroughbred Auctions | 6 Comments »
Monday, June 8th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
This was a Triple Crown for the little guys, and I’m not talking about jockeys.
We had a Kentucky Derby won by a 50-1 longshot, Mine That Bird, a gelding that once sold for $9,500 as a yearling. He was trained by Bennie L. "Chip" Woolley Jr., a black hat wearing cowboy from New Mexico who some years earlier befriended Mark Allen, one of Mine That Bird’s owners, in a bar fight. The trainer had saddled just one winner this year before the Derby. Anyone outside of New Mexico who knew him was probably a relative.
The Preakness was won by Rachel Alexandra, a filly bred by Dolphus Morrison, a retired businessman from Alabama with a modest breeding and racing operation. That’s right, Alabama, not exactly horse country. But it puts an addendum on the old adage that a good horse can come from anywhere. So can a good horse breeder, and Morrison has enjoyed success as a breeder even before Rachel Alexandra became a national star.
The Belmont winner, Summer Bird, was bred and owned by a couple from India who are retired medical professionals. Dr. Kalarikkal Jayaraman was a cardiologist and wife Vilasini was a pathologist who discovered a love of horse racing in Arkansas and eventually bought a farm in Ocala, Fla., where Kalarikkal Jayaraman trains the young horses before sending them to the racetrack. Summer Bird’s trainer, Tim Ice, is in his first year as a head trainer. His earliest memories of racing come from Waterford Park in West Virginia, a track that used to be the poster child for the leaky roof circuit until West Virginia got slot machines and the track was transformed into Mountaineer Park.
The only “spoiler” in the little guy Triple Crown was Jess Jackson, a billionaire winemaker from California who bought Rachel Alexandra from Morrison and a partner after her 20 ¼-length win in the Kentucky Oaks. Morrison is a traditionalist when it comes to racing, saying he didn’t think fillies belong in the Classic races, which he believes should be a showcase for future stallion prospects (that would seem to preclude geldings from running in them, too). But Morrison is also a capitalist, and was willing to sell his prized filly for the right price.
Jackson, despite his many years as a racing fan (as a young child he saw Seabiscuit run in Northern California), is not a traditionalist. He likes to see the best run against the best, especially if he has a stake in the outcome. He swooped in to Baltimore and won the Preakness with Rachel Alexandra, then exited center stage with the Medaglia d’Oro filly. Where or when she’ll resurface is anyone’s guess, but let’s hope it brings on the same dramatics as the Preakness.
Among the beaten in this Triple Crown were Dubai’s ruler, Sheikh Mohammed, who in addition to being a leading buyer at virtually every major sale throughout the world, purchased the top two 2-year-old colts in training in North America last year, Eclipse Award winner Midshipman and runner-up Vineyard Haven (shouldn’t Jess Jackson have bought a horse with that kind of name?). The sheikh, for reasons of pride, insists on training his horses in Dubai each winter and dispersing them to major races like the Kentucky Derby, a program that hasn’t yet been very successful. To Kentucky he came, he saw, he failed to conquer.
Triple Crown training king D. Wayne Lukas failed to hit the board in the three Triple Crown races, but it was good to have him back on the beat after a drought. Bob Baffert came to Churchill Downs in search of his fourth Kentucky Derby win with a live contender, Pioneerof the Nile, but after finishing a distant second behind Mine That Bird was left repeating the line from the movie “Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby”: “If you ain’t first, you’re last.” And Nick Zito, who talks of Triple Crown glory in almost Biblical terms, made appearances in the Derby and Belmont, but couldn’t muster much of a run in either race. These three Hall of Famers help make the classic races something special.
Then there is Todd Pletcher, a future Hall of Famer and multi-Eclipse Award winning-training who seems to be followed by a dark cloud whenever he comes to Churchill Downs in the springtime. Pletcher started three in this year’s Derby, failing to hit the board with any of them, and is now 0-for-24 in America’s most famous horse race. Hang in there, Todd. As a Chicago Cubs fan who was not around for their last World Series championship in 1908, I feel your pain. Cub fans have an expression that might work for you, too: Wait till next year.
Some additional thoughts from a Triple Crown notebook:
- Major stakes at Oaklawn Park produced two Triple Crown race winners, Rachel Alexandra, who won the Grade 2 Fantasy Stakes as her final prep before the Kentucky Oaks, and Summer Bird, who was third behind Papa Clem and Old Fashioned in the Grade 2 Arkansas Derby. It is amazing to many people (except for those on the Graded Stakes Committee) that the Arkansas Derby remains a Grade 2 race after producing Triple Crown races winners like Smarty Jones, Afleet Alex, Curlin and now Summer Bird in recent years.
- Sunland Park races deserve closer examination in the grading process as well. Mine That Bird came to Kentucky after two races at the New Mexico track: second in the Borderland Derby and fourth in the Sunland Derby. Gabby’s Golden Gal, winner of Saturday’s Grade 1 Acorn on the Belmont undercard, won the Sunland Park Oaks. No Sunland Park races have ever been graded by the committee, but since the addition of slot machine revenue they have dramatically increased purses and improved the quality of runners the races attract.
- Breeders should be excited about the emergence of two young Kentucky-based sires, Birdstone and Medaglia d’Oro, whose first crop of foals are now aged three. Birdstone, who upset Smarty Jones in his Triple Crown bid at the 2004 Belmont and also won the Champagne and Travers, sired Mine That Bird and Summer Bird. He stands at the Beck family’s Gainesway Farm. Medaglia d’Oro, a top racehorse over several seasons who finished a close second to longshot Sarava in the 2002 Belmont before winning the Jim Dandy and Travers, sired Rachel Alexandra. Medaglia d’Oro, who started his career at John Sikura’s Hill ‘n’ Dale, then moved to the Haisfield family’s Stonewall Stallions, was the subject of a recent bidding war involving several stallion farms, with Sheikh Mohammed’s Darley emerging last week as the winner.
- “Practice? We’re talking about practice.” Did Calvin Borel move too soon in the Belmont aboard Mine That Bird? Would some practice runs on the mile-and-a-half Belmont oval in preliminary races on Belmont Day or earlier in the week have benefited the lovable Cajun, who shrugged off his lack of experience at Belmont Park as not important while boldly guaranteeing victory for Mine That Bird? Borel became a media darling during this year’s Triple Crown, which he nearly swept on two horses. He jetted to California for the “Tonight Show With Jay Leno,” made an appearance on “Late Night With David Letterman,” was a hit during a Triple Crown luncheon and never seemed to stop talking. He did everything but ride during the week of the Belmont. But if someone had asked Calvin about practicing over the Belmont Park strip before the race, is it possible he would have said something like this?
- Business on the Triple Crown was strong in light of the poor economy. Betting on the Derby was down, not surprisingly. The morning line favorite, I Want Revenge, was scratched and wet track conditions such as those horseplayers found on Derby Day generally lead to wagering declines. Preakness betting was up significantly from 2008, though attendance took a huge hit when Magna officials changed their policy and prohibited fans from bringing their own beer into the infield. The Belmont, whose numbers boom when there is a Triple Crown on the line, did not have that advantage this year, but did well in comparison to the last non-Triple Crown year, 2007. Adding to the good news was increased television ratings for the Derby and Preakness on NBC. ABC’s Belmont Stakes telecast will almost certainly have a smaller audience than in 2008, when Big Brown was going for a Triple Crown.
How much handle from the Triple Crown is leaking to offshore bookmakers offering online wagering is anyone’s guess. These businesses do not have contracts with racetracks or horsemen’s organizations, and pay nothing to support the game. It’s beyond me why anyone who cares about horse racing would do business with these sites or (whether they are established publications, web sites, or fan blogs) accept advertising from them. They are aggressive in seeking places to advertise, and are willing to pay top dollar to market their products. Again, they put nothing back into the game. The Paulick Report refuses to accept advertising from these businesses and applauds all the other web sites and publications who have a similar policy.
Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report
Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: american graded stakes committee, arkansas derby, belmont stakes, Birdstone, Bob Baffert, Calvin Borel, chicago cubs, d. wayne lukas, dolphus morrison, fantasy stakes, gabby's golden gal, Horse Racing, horse racing business, jess jackson, kalarikkal jayaraman, kentucky derby, medaglia d'oro, midshipman, mine that bird, nick zito, offshore bookmakers, Paulick Report, preakness, Rachel Alexandra, Ray Paulick, seabiscuit, sheikh mohammed, Slot machines, Summer Bird, sunland park, talladega nights, tim ice, todd pletcher, Triple Crown, vilasini jayaraman, vineyard haven, waterford park Posted in belmont stakes, kentucky derby, preakness | 12 Comments »
Wednesday, May 20th, 2009
Todd Pletcher is almost a cinch to be elected into the National Museum of Racing Hall of Fame as soon as he becomes eligible for nomination on the ballot. The one-time D. Wayne Lukas assistant has won four Eclipse Awards as outstanding trainer in North America (2003-2007), set records for earnings by a North American trainer and won meeting titles at more than a half dozen tracks in Florida, Kentucky and New York. He once trained 100 stakes winners in a single season.
Yet Pletcher, as he hates to be reminded, has the worst record for futility in Kentucky Derby history, and his results in the other Triple Crown races and Breeders’ Cup do not yet measure up to his overall career accomplishments.
To that end, turf writer Nick Kling of the Troy Record, wrote about Pletcher’s recent Triple Crown tailspin in a piece that appeared only in the upstate New York’s May 19 print edition. With the paper’s permission, we are republishing Kling’s commentary online. – Ray Paulick
By Nick Kling
When Take The Points finished last in Saturday’s Preakness Stakes, his performance was the latest page in an incredible story being written by Todd Pletcher.
Pletcher is considered to be one of the most accomplished Thoroughbred trainers in the nation. He is held in such high esteem that he was voted Eclipse Awards as America’s outstanding trainer four years in succession (2004-2007).
Todd has been at his best at Saratoga Race Course, winning six training titles at the prestigious meet. In 2007 Pletcher trained three Eclipse-winning horses: Rags to Riches (3-year-old filly), Lawyer Ron (older male), and English Channel (turf male).
However, there is one area where Pletcher has not been so successful. His horses have been awful in Triple Crown races: the Kentucky Derby, Preakness, and Belmont Stakes. The record of futility from Pletcher-trained starters in these classic events may be unparalleled.
Over the eleven most recent Triple Crown races, beginning with the 2006 Kentucky Derby, Pletcher-trained horses have finished last four times. That is a negative batting average of 36 percent.
In reality, it is worse than that. He had starters in only nine of those races. That raises Pletcher’s absolutely last quotient to 44 percent.
Harness announcer Jack E. Lee used to say the trailing horse in a race could, "see them all." The Pletcher Triple Crown starters since 2006 who could see them all at the finish line were Keyed Entry (2006 Derby), Cowtown Cat (2007 Derby), Monba (2008) Derby, and Take The Points (2009 Preakness).
In addition, Pletcher’s 2005 Kentucky Derby starter Bandini finished 19th of 20 in that field. 2004 Belmont Stakes starter Purge finished dead last of nine starters. 2001 Belmont entrant Balto Star finished eighth of nine.
According to KentuckyDerby.com, Pletcher has started 24 horses in America’s greatest race. 21 have finished out of the money. Todd’s best Derby results have been a pair of seconds and one third.
Only D. Wayne Lukas has had more Derby starters (43) than Pletcher. Lukas, one of Pletcher’s mentors, has won the race four times. Trainer H.J. Thompson had 24 Derby entrants and four winners. Trainers Sylvester Veitch and Ron McAnally, who had 10 Derby starters, are the only other horsemen with double-digit entrants without a Kentucky Derby victory.
Using Daily Racing Form’s Formulator past performance program, I was able to find two Preakness entrants from the Pletcher barn. One was Take The Points. The other was Circular Quay, who finished fifth in 2007.
Pletcher’s only victory in a Triple Crown race came when Rags to Riches won the 2007 Belmont Stakes, beating subsequent Horse of the Year Curlin. Preparing a filly to accomplish that task was an outstanding feat of training, making Pletcher’s overall lack of success more incomprehensible.
Overall, he has had eight Belmont Stakes starters, four unplaced finishers, and three besides Rags to Riches in the money.
The Breeders’ Cup is the only other event which compares to Triple Crown races in stature. Pletcher’s relative accomplishments in Cup races is better, although not great.
According to the Breeders’ Cup website, Todd has had 55 Cup starters. They have produced three wins, six seconds, and seven thirds. Pletcher Cup starters have earned approximately $8 million in purse money, placing him in the top six among all trainers.
Horsemen such as Bobby Frankel and Bill Mott, Hall of Famers both, have Breeders’ Cup records in line with Pletcher’s Cup performance.
Trying to deduce what causes Todd’s Triple Crown flame-out is an exercise in speculation. My best guess would point to two causes.
Many of the colts in the Pletcher barn are horses bred for speed. Speed wins a lot of races, but not necessarily those at classic distances. Several have sires cut in the mold of Distorted Humor and Elusive Quality, middle distances types who have produced Derby winners nevertheless.
However, Pletcher’s high profile owners generally spend a lot of money on their stock and expect a return. Pletcher is among the top trainers in the country in terms of number of juvenile starters. Horses which break their maiden sprinting at five or six furlongs and win two-year-old stakes races at the Churchill Downs and Saratoga summer meets are unlikely to be the same animals winning Triple Crown events.
In addition, some horses from the Pletcher stable appear to have been ambitiously-spotted in Triple Crown races. A review of their past performances reveals some horses which have done most of their racing on synthetic surfaces. Others have mediocre dirt form, or have not done particularly well at longer route distances.
Make no mistake. Derby fever is an affliction which strikes many owners and trainers in spring. If that plays any part in the decisions made about Pletcher-trained horses, they are in good company.
There are some signs horsemen are beginning to rethink the idea of shoving any remotely talented three-year-old into Triple Crown races. Take The Points, for example, had earnings which qualified him for the Derby. His connections chose to wait for the Preakness.
Horsemen used to say Thoroughbreds were like strawberries — they could spoil overnight. It’s only gotten worse. Many young horses in the 21st Century have the shelf life of raw oysters. If they are put where they don’t belong, someone might get sick.
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world.
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: bill mott, bobby frankel, Circular Quay, Cowtown Cat, d. wayne lukas, eclipse awards, H. J. Thompson, Jack E. Lee, kentucky derby, Keyed Entry, Monba, Nick Kling, rags to riches, Ron McAnally, Sylvester Veitch, Take The Points, todd pletcher, Triple Crown Posted in belmont stakes, kentucky derby, preakness | 28 Comments »
Friday, March 13th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
Oaklawn Park owner Charles Cella has always been something of a contrarian, so it should really not be that big a surprise that his Hot Springs, Ark., track’s business is running contrary to national trends this year. Attendance and handle are down at most tracks, with overall betting in the United States down 6.7% for the first two months of the year. But not at Oaklawn Park.
Both attendance and handle are up for the first half of the Oaklawn meeting, leading to a purse increase that was announced last week. At the midway point of the Oaklawn season, on-track attendance is 279,189 this year compared with 269,797 in 2008, a 3% percent increase. On-track handle is also up 3%. Its exported simulcast signal has grown by 6% from 2008.
“Numbers from the first half of our season are surprisingly good,” Oaklawn president Charles J. Cella said in a press release, “especially when you consider the current economy.”
Terry Wallace the voice of Oaklawn for 35 years and the head of the media relations department, said there are several reasons the track is bucking the national trend. “We didn’t have reason to expect that we’d be up,” Wallace said. “But we’ve had cooperative weather, and I don’t think our part of the country has had the dramatic rises and falls in the economy that a lot of people in other regions have had.”
Wallace said field size is another reason business has grown, especially Oaklawn’s simulcast signal. Average number of starters at the midway point of the season is 9.86, a 5% increase over the same period last year, when average field size at this time was 9.36.
“We haven’t had many off tracks this year, either,” he said, “and the track has been playing very fair with no biases. Big fields and a consistent racetrack is what people are looking for. The Instant Racing machines have been very popular here, too; they’ve been a great success for us, and we’ve seen a significant jump in handle on that this year.
“And it doesn’t hurt to have really good horses here like Old Fashioned and Proud Spell,” he added. Proud Spell, last year’s champion 3-year-old filly lost her 2009 debut Thursday, and leading Kentucky Derby candidate Old Fashioned goes in Saturday’s Rebel Stakes.
Finally, Wallace said, Hall of Fame trainer D. Wayne Lukas, who is based at Oaklawn for the third consecutive year, has been a tremendous public relations asset.
“Wayne Lukas has been incredible,” he said. “He mixes with the crowd, both in the track grandstand and in the gaming area. People here have learned to really like him. As a result, he’s a hero around here. He’s a rock star.”
Lukas gave a motivational talk to a group in Hot Springs a couple of days before the meeting opened, Wallace said.
“He said you can never overestimate the value of kindness, and he’s showing a lot of kindness to our fans. He’s got a new thing he’s doing, and it’s become really popular. When he wins a race, he randomly finds a young person in the crowd and asks if they’d like to have their picture taken in the winner’s circle. He’ll invite the whole family down there if they want to come. And if the family wants a copy of the picture he’ll get one for them and autograph it. He has been so good to the people here. It’s been really amazing.”
Lukas is currently fourth in the trainer standings with 11 wins.
The meeting continues through April 11, with the $1-million Arkansas Derby, which has been a key Kentucky Derby prep in recent years.
Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report
Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world
Sign up for our Email flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: Charles Cella, d. wayne lukas, oaklawn park Posted in oaklawn park | 14 Comments »
Tuesday, November 11th, 2008
By Ray Paulick
To hear Carl Pascarella tell it, you’d think corporate marketers would have lined up from Louisville, Ky., all the way to New York’s Madison Avenue to bid on the Triple Crown sponsorship that Visa USA dropped in 1995 after a 10-year run. The relationship between the Triple Crown and Visa ended the same year Pascarella retired as the credit card giant’s chief executive officer.
Pascarella, speaking at a Tuesday afternoon session on Marketing & the Customer Experience at the 32nd Asian Racing Conference in Tokyo, used the familiar introduction from ABC’s “Wide World of Sports” to describe sponsorship of American racing’s highest-profile series, which begins with the Kentucky Derby on the first Saturday in May, continues two weeks later in the Preakness, and concludes three weeks after that with the Belmont Stakes.
First, there is the “thrill of victory,” Pascarella said. “From a sponsor’s standpoint, nothing gives you more of a thrill than the Kentucky Derby winner driving down the Preakness stretch with a three- or four-length lead and knowing, as a sponsor, that you’ve got legs, with another three or four weeks to promote in and outside the world of sports. It was something we could use from April on through to June.”
On the other hand, he said, there is “the agony of defeat. In six of eight years we had horses that won the first two legs and didn’t win the Belmont.” That defeat eliminated the possibility of further promotions congratulating the winner of the Visa Triple Crown Challenge and the accompanying $5-million bonus, as well as any additional races the winner might compete in, including the Travers Stakes or Breeders’ Cup.
The Triple Crown was one of several world-class sponsorships for Visa in the sports and entertainment world. “Each one of them,” Pascarella said, “had a common focus on a couple of very important things: understanding who their fan and audience was; and secondly, they understood how to drive value to that fan base. They had an unwavering commitment to both things. At Visa, we looked more to sports as being the pinnacle of entertainment for fans, or our customers. No other form of entertainment brings the same kind of excitement or elation as sports does.
“The sports that are best for our sponsorship,” Pascarella continued, “put the fan in the center of the activity. They create deeper relationships because it’s a fan-centric approach. They give the fan a way to get into the event itself.”
Pascarella recalled how much value he was able to give to Visa’s best customers — bankers and merchants — who would come to Louisville for the Kentucky Derby. “We’d bring them on a backside tour of Churchill Downs on the day before the Derby,” he said. “They’d see the horses who would be racing in the Derby the next day, meet trainers like Bobby Baffert and D. Wayne Lukas, and these people felt like they were part of it all. We were giving them something special because of a sponsorship that was invaluable. That’s what we were paying for, that extra feeling that allowed our customers to get inside the sport.
“We’re not looking at fan numbers, we are looking at fans who are engaged, fans who will be engaged with us and our products and services,” Pascarella said. “We look at selecting and evaluating sponsorships based on being able to drive consumer behavior. How have we lifted the brand, how have we changed behavior, how have we made the consumer closer to us as a result of the association? The more we win, the more we put into a sponsorship. But it’s not just about the money. It’s about the relationships you can build with your sponsor and what you can give your sponsor in return. You need mutually beneficial objectives.”
Interestingly, while Visa dropped its sponsorship of the Triple Crown, it entered into a five-year agreement with Churchill Downs to sponsor the Kentucky Derby. No company has stepped forward to sponsor the Triple Crown since Visa’s exit from the series. One reason may have been a decision by the New York Racing Association to end its association with NBC Sports, and put the Belmont on ABC/ESPN. Another may have been fragmentation within the three tracks that comprise Triple Crown Productions and a power struggle over how sponsorship revenues were divided. Currently, of course, they have nothing to divide from a Triple Crown title sponsor.
Pascarella, now an executive adviser to TPG Capital, also cautioned racing associations that the current economic climate will cause nearly every major corporation to reevaluate its advertising, marketing and sponsorship budgets. “Every economist projects a very deep and long recession,” he said. “That means your sponsors are going to be under a great deal of pressure. You need to reach out to them, even though your revenues also are going to be under pressure. If you reach out to them, and say, ‘How do we work together to get through this?’ that will go a long way.”
BRANDING GURU DAVID AAKER , professor emeritus of marketing strategy at the Haas School of Business at the University of California-Berkeley, talked about how racing can build its brand.
At a time when brand trustworthiness and quality perceptions of most brands are down significantly in the minds of the public, Aaker said there are opportunities to improve branding through increased energy. He cited the Nintendo video game brand as one recent phenomenon in the branding world. Five years ago, Aker said, Nintendo ranked 165th among brand names in Japan, moved up to 65th three y ears ago, fifth two years ago, and now ranks as the country’s leading brand, thanks to the energy created by the Nintendo Wii platform and games.
He cited five other very diverse brands that have energized themselves in recent years: 1) the Memphis Redbirds minor league baseball team; 2) the Indianapolis Motor Speedway; 3) PGA Tour golf; 4) Harley Davidson; and 5) Avon cosmetics.
All of those brands used one of two methods: energizing the business itself, or finding something with energy that is interesting and involving and attach it to the brand. “Both options are really powerful,” Aaker said.
The Memphis Redbirds, Indianapolis Speedway and Harley Davidson energized their brand by engaging their customers in multiple activities that built on the customer experience. The PGA Tour and Avon tied themselves to something with energy. The PGA Tour used Tiger Woods to its best advantage, and Avon linked its products to a breast cancer crusade and created the Avon Walk for Breast Cancer, with millions of people engaged each year. Similarly, Aaker said, Lowe’s home improvement stores attach their brand to Habitat for Humanity. In the case of Avon, he said, “Breast cancer is so important an issue and involving to the target audience that it provides Avon a way to get energy that it could never do through their products and services.”
Aaker said companies seeking to strengthen their brand should “find role models, companies in related or unrelated industries…someone who’s done it well with a brand people are talking about. What can you learn from them?”
In addition, he said, self-reflection is necessary. “What about the customer experience is boring or unpleasant? How can you mitigate that? What can be added to en rich and improve the customer experience.”
To find what he calls “branded energizers” like Avon’s breast cancer campaign, Aaker said companies should examine “what existing program has energy that fits your brand and can be connected to your brand…programs that aren’t part of the experience people are currently buying? What new program with energy can be developed that fits the brand and can be connected to the brand?”
“You have one of the most exciting events in sports and entertainment,” Aaker said. “But you need to ask yourself, ‘How can I add energy to my brand?’”
TELEVISION ADVERTISEMENTS PROMOTING RACING around the world were shown to the group and audience members were asked to vote on their favorites. The ads were divided into five categories: Celebrating the Horse; Sex and Glamour; The Punt; A Good Laugh; and The Buzz.Most provocative were ads from Australia promoting sex and glamour. Other countries featured included France, Turkey, Japan, Hong Kong, Germany, Ireland and the United States (two ads from Santa Anita were featured). Details tomorrow on the winning ad.
Tags: 32nd asian racing conference, asian racing federation, avon, avon walk for breast cancer, belmont stakes, Bob Baffert, brand energizers, brand marketing, branded energizers, Breeders' Cup, carl pascarella, churchill downs, d. wayne lukas, david aaker, dentsu, haas school of business, harley davidson, Horse Racing, indianapolis motor speedway, kentucky derby, Marketing, memphis redbirds, New York Racing Association, Paulick Report, pga tour, presakness, racing sponsorships, Ray Paulick, sports sponsorships, tokyo, travers, triple crown productions, visa, visa usa, wide world of sports Posted in Horse Racing, Industry Conferences, International Racing, Marketing, Sponsorships | 3 Comments »
Tuesday, August 19th, 2008
By Ray Paulick
In the winter and spring of 1980, as a relatively new racing fan living in Southern California I was confident that I had discovered the certain winner of that year’s Kentucky Derby: a colt named Rumbo, who had a few mental quirks but possessed a powerful stretch run.
Rumbo finished second in the Santa Anita Derby and Hollywood Derbies, but I was convinced the extra furlong of the Kentucky Derby would be all this colt would need to get the job done and confirm my brilliance as a handicapper. Besides, Codex, the winner of the two Derbies in Southern California who was trained by a new hotshot from the Quarter horse world named D. Wayne Lukas, wouldn’t be in the starting gate at Churchill Downs come the first Saturday in May. His connections didn’t think to nominate him to the Derby, and there were no supplemental entries to the race back then.
The field for that year’s Run for the Roses didn’t seem particularly strong, especially in comparison to the decade that had just ended, one that produced Triple Crown winners Secretariat, Seattle Slew and Affirmed, along with Spectacular Bid, who in my opinion should have won the Triple Crown in 1979.
Rockhill Native was the tepid Derby favorite and reigning 2-year-old champion, but just didn’t strike me as a real Derby horse. Besides, he was a gelding, and no gelding had won America’s great horserace since Clyde Van Dusen in 1929. Second choice was Plugged Nickle, winner of the Florida Derby and Wood Memorial. It just didn’t seem right to me that a horse with that name (and misspelled at that) could join the ranks of Kentucky Derby winners.
In fact, the biggest threat I saw to Rumbo was another California colt, but this one had a girl’s name, Jaklin Klugman, the sorta namesake of actor Jack Klugman.
Oh, yes, there was a real filly in that race, too, Genuine Risk, but I hardly gave her a second thought. Fillies couldn’t win the Derby. That hadn’t happened since Regret in 1915, and no filly had even tried to beat the boys since Silver Spoon finished fifth to Tomy Lee in 1959. The image of the tragic injury to the great filly Ruffian in her match race only a few years earlier against Derby winner Foolish Pleasure was still fresh in my mind. Trainer LeRoy Jolley had already tried Genuine Risk against colts, finishing third to Plugged Nickle and Colonel Moran in the Wood Memorial at Aqueduct in New York. Though it was her first career defeat after six consecutive wins, I couldn’t see Genuine Risk improving off that effort.
Besides, I was certain she’d be helpless against the mighty Rumbo down the long stretch of Churchill Downs.
That wasn’t the first time I was wrong about a horse race, and it certainly wasn’t (nor will be) the last.
Rumbo, under Laffit Pincay Jr., dropped back to trail the 13-horse field, just as I expected him to do, but he came with a strong rally around the final turn. He flew by the dueling pace-setters, Rockhill Native and Plugged Nickle and caught Jaklin Klugman inside the furlong pole. But there was nothing he could do about the filly. Jacinto Vasquez deftly guided her through early traffic, moved to the lead before reaching the top of the stretch, then easily held off Rumbo to win by a length as a 13-1 long shot.
My only consolation to being wrong was that it took an historic achievement to beat me. But my appreciation for Genuine Risk was just beginning.
Two weeks later, in the Preakness Stakes at Baltimore, Genuine Risk proved that her Derby win was no fluke. Codex, benefitting from his owner’s forgetfulness to nominate him to the first leg of the Triple Crown, was a fresh horse. On his back that day was Angel Cordero Jr., a sometimes controversial jockey who could have written a book about the tactics of race riding. The duo got the jump on Genuine Risk, stalking the early leaders and taking command on the turn for home, just as Vasquez had done on the filly in the Derby.
But as Genuine Risk launched her move on the turn for home, Cordero peeked back over his right shoulder and saw the filly coming. He allowed Codex to drift far off the rail and almost directly into the path of Genuine Risk, then flashed the whip in his right hand as the two horses brushed together at the top of the stretch. It was a move clearly intended to intimidate the filly, and it worked. Vasquez later said Cordero hit Genuine Risk in the head with his whip and did it on purpose.
Codex went on to win by 4 ¾ lengths, with Genuine Risk second. A claim of foul was dismissed by track stewards, as was an appeal to the Maryland Racing Commission by Bert and Diana Firestone, the owners of Genuine Risk. Many fans of the filly felt cheated.
Flash ahead to 2008 and ask yourself, how many owners today would persevere and run a Kentucky Derby-winning filly in the Belmont Stakes after two hard races at Churchill Downs and Pimlico, one who had no hope of becoming a Triple Crown winner? It’s hard to imagine anyone would be that sporting. The Firestones were.
But Genuine Risk was no ordinary filly. She ran back three weeks later in the Belmont in a rematch against Codex, who was made the 8-5 favorite. Rumbo, who had skipped the Preakness, was there, too, as the second choice in the betting. The fans had virtually given up on Genuine Risk, who was sent off at odds of 9-1.
Genuine Risk ran gamely over the mile and a half of the Belmont, battling Rockhill Native much of the way over a muddy racetrack. She put that foe away at the top of the stretch, but couldn’t hold off Temperence Hill, a 53-1 outsider who hadn’t contested either of the two prior Triple Crown events and was the only horse in the field wearing mud calks. Codex and Rumbo were non-factors. Genuine Risk finished a gallant second, securing her place as the greatest filly ever to compete in all three Triple Crown races.
This Kentucky-bred filly by Exclusive Native out of the Gallant Man mare Virtuous wasn’t finished yet. After a short break, she came back to narrowly lose the Maskette to Bold ‘n Determined, then won the Ruffian Handicap by a nose over Misty Gallore and It’s in the Air. It was a great year for fillies, one that also included Davona Dale and Love Sign.
But none was greater than Genuine Risk, who was made that year’s 3-year-old champion and was a first-ballot inductee in the Hall of Fame.
Genuine Risk never duplicated her racing performances as a broodmare before her death this week at the age of 31. Her fertility difficulties were a frustration to all. The expectations placed on great fillies by the public somehow don’t seem fair anyways.
Genuine Risk did more than enough in that five-week stretch in the spring of 1980 to secure her place in history.
VIDEO: Kentucky Derby, Preakness, Belmont
Copyright © 2008, The Paulick Report
Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Tags: angel cordero, belmont stakes, bert firestone, codex, d. wayne lukas, diana firestone, genuine risk, Horse Racing, jacinto vasquez, jack klugman, jaklin klugman, kentucky derby, laffit pincay, leroy jolley, Paulick Report, plugged nickle, preakness, racing hall of fame, Ray Paulick, rockhill native, rumbo, temperence hill, Triple Crown Posted in Horse Racing, Racing Greats | 4 Comments »
Monday, August 4th, 2008
John Ferguson, bloodstock advisor to Sheikh Mohammed and responsible for putting the deal together for Dubai-based Synergy Investments to purchase Fasig-Tipton earlier this year, led the way among buyers — signing five tickets for a total of $3,100,000 — at Monday night’s opening session of the company’s two day-select yearling sale at the Humphrey S. Finney Pavilion in Saratoga Springs, N.Y.
The final numbers sent a mixed message to the market, as the gross receipts declined by 9.8% but average rose 16.2% and median price increased by 10.8% from last year’s opening session. Most troublesome was the steep buyback rate of 30.6%, a sharp rise from last year’s 21.9% not sold on the first night.
Though Ferguson was the night’s leading buyer, the highest priced offering Monday, a Storm Cat filly from the Hill ‘n’ Dale Sales Agency consignment, was purchased by Team Valor International for $1,500,000. The Vanlandingham mare Totemic, a graded stakes winner and dam of three stakes winners, including Fountain of Youth Stakes winner Lil’s Lad, produced the filly.
The only other $1-million yearling on the night was an A.P. Indy colt out of the Broad Brush mare Pyramid Lake, purchased for $1,200,000 by William Farish of Lane’s End Farm, where A.P. Indy stands at stud. The colt is out of a half-sister to European Horse of the Year Peintre Celebre and was consigned by Hunter Valley Farm, agent.
Following Ferguson as the first session’s top buyer was Team Valor, the partnership run by Barry Irwin that has been very active at this sale in recent years. Team Valor bought three yearlings for $2,120,000. Third-leading buyer was Legends Racing, a newly formed partnership that is teaming with trainers D. Wayne Lukas, Nick Zito and Bob Baffert to pick out and train its horses, which bought three for $1,205,000, including a $700,000 colt by first-year sire Rock Hard Ten out of Tapstress, a Desert Wine mare. The colt was consigned by Gainesway, agent. The only other yearling by Rock Hard Ten offered Monday night was a colt out of Serena’s Sister, by Rahy, that Maverick Racing bought for $450,000 from Bridlewood Farm, with Denali Stud as agent.
Missing from the list of buyers on the first night was Demi O’Byrne, agent for the Coolmore operation of John Magnier.
Totals for Monday were 59 head sold from 85 offered (with 30.6% not sold) for $17,915,000, an average price of $303,644 and median of $230,000. Last year’s numbers from the first night were 76 sold from 96 offered (21.9% RNA) for $19,867,000, an average of $261,408 and median of $207,500.
(Note: The statistics reported above were amended by Fasig-Tipton to reflect an additional sale of Hip 93, originally listed as RNA but changed to sold for $245,000 to BTA Stable. The adjusted final figures are 60 sold for $18,160,000; $302,667 average and $235,000 median.)
Copyright © 2008, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick.
Tags: a.p. indy, Bob Baffert, d. wayne lukas, demi o'byrne, fasig-tipton, fasig-tipton saratoga, gainesway, hill 'n' dale sales, john ferguson, Lane's End, legends racing, nick zito, Paulick Report, Ray Paulick, rock hard ten, sheikh mohammed, synergy investments, team valor, william farish Posted in Thoroughbred Auctions | Comments Off
|
|