MAGNA PARENT WANTS TO CLOSE GOLDEN GATE FIELDS
Racing in Northern California, scrambling to recover from the loss of Bay Meadows racetrack, which was closed in 2008 for planned development, also faces the bulldozing of Golden Gate Fields, the parent company of bankrupt owner Magna Entertainment stated in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Tuesday.
MI Developments (MID, stock symbol MIM) is the majority shareholder in Magna Entertainment (MEC, stock symbol MECA). When Magna Entertainment filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy March 5, it revealed a $195-million stalking horse bid from MI Developments for several of the racetrack properties, including Golden Gate Fields. In an amendment to a Form 13D filing on Tuesday, MI Developments said, if successful in acquiring Golden Gate, it will “immediately commence seeking all required approvals to develop the property for commercial real estate uses.” The filing goes on to say, "Racing at Golden Gate Fields would cease prior to commencement of construction on the rezoned property.”
MI Developments and Magna Entertainment are both spinoffs from the auto parts giant, Magna International. All three companies are controlled by Thoroughbred owner and breeder Frank Stronach.
Click here to access the filing; the reference to development of Golden Gate Fields is on page two.
Drew Couto, president of Thoroughbred Owners of California, told the Paulick Report Tuesday night he had assurances as recently as last weekend that MI Developments was only pursuing development of excess property at Golden Gate, and that it would not affect horse racing. Couto said he was told the commercial development would be along the lines of developer Rick Caruso’s "Shops at Santa Anita," slated for the Arcadia track’s north parking lot.
"If this is true, this represents a serious change of position of what was expressed to me and TOC last week," Couto said. "We’ll be following up with MEC and MID to see if this is accurate."
Magna Entertainment had previously sought zoning approvals for a portion of the Golden Gate Fields property, filing plans for a retail, entertainment and lodging development in 2002 in partnership with Caruso. After a few years and a groundswell of community opposition, the push for rezoning was dropped. Many local citizens and environmental groups want the the track property, located on the eastern shoreline of the San Francisco Bay, to be turned into public parklands.
Complicating matters for potential rezoning and development is the fact Golden Gate Fields is located in two cities: the majority of the property, including the section Magna previously sought to develop, is in Albany. A smaller portion, including the stable area, is in Berkeley. Both cities are conservative when it comes to commercial development, particularly on wetlands and shoreline property.
So why would MI Developments say it will seek rezoning of the track with two municipalities that have shown limited interest in commercial development? There is some speculation MI Developments and its board are reacting to institutional shareholders who have threatened possible legal action against MI Developments directors for potential breach of fiduciary responsibility. Those shareholders have expressed previous disagreement with the company’s decision to extend credit to Magna Entertainment and pump millions of dollars into the racing operations. Golden Gate Fields would be worth much more as commercial real estate than it is as a racetrack, and its sale or development might help alleviate some of the criticism from those shareholders.
Bay Meadows, located in San Mateo, opened in 1934 and had been California’s oldest continually operating racetrack. Since being closed and meeting the wrecking ball last year, there’s been no progress on development, and a pile of rubble sits as a reminder of what once was a thriving racetrack.
Golden Gate Fields, which this year inherited most of the dates Bay Meadows ran, held its inaugural race meeting in 1941. It’s anyone’s guess when Northern California’s last major track will hold its final race.
Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report
Sign up for our Email flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick
Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world
Tags: drew couto, Frank Stronach, golden gate fields, Magna, magna bankrupt, magna bankruptcy, Magna Entertainment, magna entertainment bankrupt, magna entertainment bankruptcy, meca, mi developments, mim, Paulick Report, Ray Paulick, rick caruso, santa anita, thoroughbred owners of california
March 10th, 2009 at 7:19 pm
Big bluff by Stronach. The local community surrounding G.Gate Fields hired a consultant last year to assist in a master plan for development along the waterfront on all the property within its limits. There was no great urgency or benefit identified in this report to permit any commercial development on the G.Gate Fields real estate. A scare tactic, typical of Frank’s reign of terror.
March 10th, 2009 at 11:10 pm
Owner of the year, Frank Stronach.
March 11th, 2009 at 8:39 am
Whatever Frankie wants…Frankie gets! The spoiled child of the horsey set that is NEVER told NO! Beside that, doesn’t he tell MID what to do? His puppet boards are an insult to sound business management and any legitimate business operator.
March 11th, 2009 at 8:56 am
Ray, Get off the Stronach bash. You are like a kid in a candy store over this sad news. You, Crist, and Beyer’s blogs are doing nothing but adding fuel to the fire. Chill out. There is a lot of good racing news to be reported heading into these Derby preps. Stick with the game dude. Let the due process work its course. If I am not mistaken, NYRA filed chapter 11 in 2006, rife with corruption, and the story lasted about a day. The power of the press is dangerous. Leaning one way or the other can sway readers and effect drastic change. (2008 election for example) Attitudes towards our industry are nose diving. Now is the time to use your platform to reverse this trend, not heap a bunch of manure on an overloaded wheelbarrow.
March 11th, 2009 at 10:20 am
Ghostzapper is Ray supposed to just ignore filings made by MDI which suggest a good chance of No. Cal loosing its last TB race course? It is not Frank bashing, rather it is putting some well deserved light on a corporation’s backroom dealings which are selling this sport up the river.
Everyone would love to live in a world of good-news only but I frankly think everyone should know just how real the threats are to lose GGF. There were people supporting Bay Meadows going away because of the economic benefits sold by a developer. That didn’t materialize and hopefully the loss of that track should be an alarm bell to the folks in Albany CA with GGF under threat too.
March 11th, 2009 at 11:15 am
Would be sad to see GG close, even if racing in the Bay Area has lost most of what was left of it’s lure when Bay Meadows shut down (with the housing bubble finally burst it seems even more of waste now). Without GG it’s hard to imagine how the Northern California fair circuit could go on, and this would be a fundmental loss for racing purists.
At Ghostzapper: Just because one chooses to ignore a problem it doesn’t seize to exist.
March 12th, 2009 at 1:53 pm
As I mentioned earlier on this string, presuming you can belive Mr. Dennis Mills from MID, Golden Fate Fields will be racing for quite some time per the companies remarks today. yes indeed there is plenty of overreacting and posturing about this MEC bankruptcy going on in the press/blogs.