Archive for the ‘International Racing’ Category

JAPAN DIARY DAY ONE: LATE STARTS AND WARM DONUTS

Thursday, November 26th, 2009
TOKYO, Japan– It’s not just the trains that run on time in Tokyo—the buses do, too

I arrived Wednesday evening at the Keio Plaza Hotel, the official press headquarters for the Japan Cup, after a 24-journey from Kentucky. Despite the lack of a good night’s sleep since Saturday, I still had that 3 a.m. jet-leg alarm go off in my head my first night here.

The itinerary for Thursday was to meet in the lobby for a 6 a.m. bus trip to Tokyo racecourse to observe the training of the five international horses in Sunday’s Japan Cup—two-time Breeders’ Cup Turf winner Conduit and Grand Prix de Chantilly winner Scintillo from Europe, and Joe Hirsch Turf Classic winner Interpatation, Northern Dancer Turf winner Just As Well and 2008 Canadian International winner Marsh Side from North America.

I walked into the lobby earlier than my customary five minutes late, asking the bell captain at precisely 6:01 a.m. if the Japan Racing Association bus had yet arrived. “It left a minute ago,” he said. I shouldn’t have hit the snooze button.

No worries. Shinjuku Station is just a five-minute walk from the hotel, and there’s a Starbucks on the way. But Tokyo, I discovered, is not an early-morning town. Starbucks wasn’t open yet, and for good reason. The streets are deserted at that hour of the day. This is, it turns out, a city that sleeps.

THE TRAINING WENT WELL ENOUGH, and the press conference that followed was predictable. Jonathan Sheppard may be the only trainer who spoke that would pass a lie-detector test. Each trainer (or assistant) of the five international horses was asked on a scale of 1-to-100 how his Japan Cup entry was doing. All said 100%, with the exception of Sheppard, who said “about 95%.”

A brief summary of the international horses:

Scintillo seems overmatched in here, but Richard Hannon is a trainer to be respected. The son of Fantastic Light is clearly a horse who likes a distance of ground, so he should be closing in the final stages of the Japan Cup. But a victory would shock me.

Conduit. Trainer Michael Stoute hadn’t arrived yet, but his assistant said the decision was made to run in the Japan Cup following a post-Breeders’ Cup evaluation of the son of Dalakhani’s condition. I have to think the travel from Europe and back for the Breeders’ Cup, followed by the trip to Japan, might take a toll. But he’s entering stud in Japan for 2010, and this is a chance for Conduit to go out in style in front of the breeders who will have the opportunity to support him at stud.

Interpatation. Trainer Bobby Barbara and owner Elliot Mavorah (pictured, right) seem to be having the time of their lives in Tokyo, and why not? It’s an all-expense paid trip for the horse and his connections, and it’s nice to see an owner and trainer who are clearly making the best of it. Mavorah profusely thanked the JRA for extending the invitation and said he hoped the horse’s performance justifies it. Despite Interpatation’s win over Gio Ponti on a deep, deep Belmont Park turf in the Joe Hirsch, he’ll be an enormous longshot on Sunday, and the ground will be firm. Someone asked Mavorah about the name, and he told a story about how he was an Orthodox Jew and was trying to build a synagogue and needed some type of legal interpretation. He wanted to name the horse “interpretation,” but that name was taken, so he purposely spelled it wrong and that name went through.

Just As Well. Wouldn’t a Japan Cup victory be an interesting tale for this 6-year-old son of A.P. Indy, who was off nearly two years while experiencing lameness that veterinarians never could fully explain. During that time, breeder George Strawbridge elected to get rid of Just As Well and Sheppard made a deal with his longtime friend and client to buy him. “It would be a shame for someone else to get him and be successful,” Sheppard said he told Strawbridge, adding that Strawbridge wins whenever Just As Well wins because he still owns the dam and some siblings. But a Japan Cup victory would still be a tough one to explain to the boss!

Marsh Side. He was the hard-luck horse of the 2008 Japan Cup when he was scratched from the race due a fever after arriving in Japan. Trainer Neil Drysdale thinks the 6-year-old by Gone West is best suited to large turf courses like Tokyo’s, along with the courses at Woodbine and Dubai. “He’s a big horse and doesn’t run as well on the American courses with their tighter turns,” he said. Marsh Side will stay in training in 2010, said Drysdale–who was accompanied to the podium by bloodstock agent Patrick Lawley-Wakelin—unless someone is interested in standing him at stud. “I believe he deserves a chance to be a stallion,” Drysdale said. Hint-hint!

NAOHIRO GODA IS MY GO-TO GUY on all matters pertaining to Japanese racing. He is a world traveler, savvy about racing and breeding just about anywhere, but a true expert on what’s going on in Japan. Goda said 2009 will be the 12th consecutive year that pari-mutuel betting on JRA racing will be down—despite numerous measures by the government entity to increase handle through an expanded menu, a rearranged schedule of Grade 1 races in the autumn, and even a reduced takeout promotion on some major races. In 2011, the JRA will be introducing a pick five wager (similar to pick threes, pick fours, and pick sixes in the U.S.).  Multi-race wagers have previously not been legal in Japan.

The big problem, Goda said, is that Japan’s trendy youth market is less and less interested in the sport of horse racing. They are more interested in computer games and other sports, especially soccer. Betting on soccer has been introduced in the last decade, and that’s hurt horse racing, too. One of the most popular bets on soccer is a computer assisted wager that eliminates any need to think or handicap.

Horse racing isn’t the only form of gambling that is suffering in Japan. Legal betting on motorboats and bicycle racing is down, too, and the Pachinko parlors (the closest thing Japan has to slot machines) are also off.

Despite the dire news about Japanese horse racing, it’s still a pretty popular sport, as evidenced by the throng of writers and photographers on hand for Thursday morning’s workouts and press conference. Tokyo’s daily sports newspapers are devoting several pages to the Japan Cup, despite the absence of a true Japanese superstar this year. It is still big business and Sunday’s Japan Cup will be sure to draw more than 100,000 people to Tokyo race course, and handle on the race will dwarf what is wagered on Kentucky Derby or Breeders’ Cup Day in the United States.

THE JAPANESE REALLY DO GET CAUGHT UP IN FADS. Just two years ago, when my wife Carol and daughter Meg traveled with me to the Japan Cup, we came across Tokyo’s first Krispy Kreme donut shop just to the south of the Shinjuku Station. We were amazed to see the DisneyWorld-like lines outside the story, complete with a sign telling the donut-hungry public how long the wait would be to get inside (it was 45 minutes when we walked by…and, no, we didn’t wait). This morning, when I returned from the track I noticed there wasn’t a single person standing outside the Krispy Kreme shop. I guess it’s yesterday’s news. But those warm donuts are still just as tasty!

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value.
Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

JAPANE$E JACKPOT

Monday, October 19th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
One or two million dollars just doesn’t get you what it used to.

Was it that long ago that felonious financier Robert Brennan shook up racing’s Triple Crown with a $2-million bonus linking victories in three stakes at the now-defunct Garden State Park in New Jersey with a win in the Kentucky Derby? Spend a Buck went after and won that bonus following his runaway victory in the 1985 Kentucky Derby, leaving  officials at the three Triple Crown tracks apoplectic when he skipped the Preakness and Belmont Stakes. They were so worried they went out and did the unthinkable: working together to create their own bonus scheme (which has now lapsed after Visa dropped its Triple Crown sponsorship).

The original Triple Crown Challenge bonus would pay a total of $5 million in purses and bonus money to any horse that won the Triple Crown (it was upped to a $5-million bonus plus purse money in 1997), and a $1-million bonus to the horse accumulating the most points from top three finishes in all three races. The latter bonus was dropped after the 1993 Triple Crown.

The absence of a bonus hasn’t hurt the Triple Crown, although without a participation bonus there have been fewer 3-year-olds running in all three races. I guess the feeling is that the owner of a horse that wins the Triple Crown will get his bonus when he retires him to stud (assuming he’s not a gelding or filly).

This past year, several entities clamored to get 3-year-old filly superstar Rachel Alexandra and older female champ Zenyatta in the same race. Jim McIngvale, the Houston furniture store owner better known as Mattress Mac, made the first run by offering to put up $2-million for a match race at Sam Houston Race Park in his home town. That gave McIngvale 15 minutes or so of free publicity, but it was a match race that was never going to happen. (McIngvale’s Gallery Furniture recently announced it is sponsoring a new $100,000 race on the Texas Day Champions program Dec. 5 at Sam Houston, proving he’s more than a publicity seeker. McIngvale and the Houston track haven’t given up on a race involving the two fillies, either, and offered $1.5 million if they showed up to face one another during the track’s winter meeting.)

TVG then teamed up with the New York Racing Association in an effort to get Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta to both contest the Oct. 3 Beldame at Belmont Park. TVG offered to put up $400,000, which would increase the purse for the Grade 1 race to $1 million. That at least got some consideration from both camps, but it wasn’t in the cards for either Rachel Alexandra or Zenyatta.

Finally, the Breeders’ Cup gave it the old college try, offering to pad the winner’s share of the $5-million Breeders’ Cup Classic if both Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta were in the starting gate. That would have resulted in a $3.7-million winner’s share of the Classic. But Rachel’s majority owner, Jess Jackson, had already made it clear he wouldn’t run his filly on the synthetic track at Santa Anita which he disparagingly calls “plastic.”

It’s no wonder, then, that the Japan Racing Association is having a hard time getting much buzz over its Autumn International series of four Grade 1 races on consecutive Sundays, beginning Nov. 15 with the Queen Elizabeth II Commemorative Cup, and continuing with the Nov. 22 Mile Championship, the Nov. 29 Japan Cup and Dec. 6 Japan Cup Dirt. The four races offer about $13 million in total purses, plus lucrative bonuses for horses that have won or finished second in major stakes in North America, Europe, Australia or Dubai.

For example, if Kentucky Derby winner Mine That Bird won the Japan Cup Dirt, a 1 1/8-mile race run clockwise at Hanshin racecourse in Osaka, he would receive $1.37 million of the $2.9-million purse but also get a bonus of $1.37 million for his Derby win, making the victory worth a total $2.7 million. That’s about the same as the Breeders’ Cup Classic’s winner’s  share of its $5-million purse. I’d venture to say Mine That Bird would face a much softer field in Japan than he’ll see on the Pro-Ride track at Santa Anita. Of course, he could run in both races.

The Derby is but one of 12 American races whose winners would qualify for a bonus ranging from $525,000 to $1.37 million for winning the Japan Cup Dirt. Even a second-place finish for those horses in Japan would pay them a bonus between $210,000 and $550,000. Click here to see the bonus scheme for the Japan Cup Dirt.

The Japan Cup on turf has similar bonuses. That race winner could take home more than $4 million in purse money and bonuses and the second-place finisher could win as much as $1.6 million in purse and bonus money. Click here for complete information on the Japan Cup’s purse and bonus details.

Nevertheless, based on recent interest in the Japanese races from American horsemen, it’s doubtful many serious contenders will be shipped to Tokyo or Osaka to contest these rich races, bonuses or not. No American horse has won the Japan Cup since 1991, when the late Charlie Whittingham sent Golden Pheasant postward for a victory. Golden Pheasant was the fourth American horse to win the Japan Cup in the race’s first 11 years.

In recent years, the Japanese have dominated the race with horses they bred or bought in the West as yearlings, winning nine of the last 11 runnings. The quality of Japanese-bred horses has improved, largely through the importation of stallions and broodmares from Europe and the United States in the 1980s and ‘90s. I think Americans have gotten tired of sending their horses over to Japan and getting their butts kicked.

The Japan Cup dirt, inaugurated in 2000, has had just nine runnings, with eight going to Japanese-trained horses. The lone exception was in 2003 when the Doug O’Neill-trained Fleetstreet Dancer, a previously unheralded runner in California, posted a huge upset.

American horsemen have been leery of sending good horses to the Japan Cup dirt, in part over legitimate concerns that the dirt tracks in Japan are deep and sandy. In fact, when Fleetstreet Dancer won, it may have been due in part to the fact rain tightened up the racetrack.

There’s a lot of money at stake in the Japan Racing Association’s Autumn International races, but purse money apparently doesn’t carry as much weight as it used to for some horse owners. Either that, or American horses ain’t what they used to be.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

ARC WINNER THE HORSE OF A LIFETIME?

Sunday, October 4th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
The late sportswriter and commentator Heywood Hale Broun once told the story of how golfing great Jack Nicklaus was moved to tears while watching Secretariat’s 31-length victory in the 1973 Belmont Stakes—a performance that embodied the perfection that Nicklaus had sought for himself in his own sport.

I daresay more than a few people were moved to tears on Sunday—the 20th anniversary of Secretariat’s death–while watching Sea the Stars run away to an impressive victory in the Qatar Prix de l’Arc de Triomphe at Longchamp in Paris, France, the 3-year-old colt’s eighth victory in nine career starts. This son of the Green Desert stallion Cape Cross out of Arc winner and outstanding producer Urban Sea, by Miswaki, demonstrated for all the world why many are calling him the finest racehorse trained in Ireland since Nijinsky II and the best Thoroughbred seen anywhere in decades. He beat an outstanding field in the Arc, was over-eager in the early going of the mile and a half race, had to overcome traffic difficulties, and then simply outclassed his opposition with a tremendous burst of acceleration under jockey Mick Kinane.

He is what a great Thoroughbred racehorse is all about.

If Sea the Stars races again, it would be the gravy on a magnificent feast, for the Christopher Tsui-owned, John Oxx-trained superstar has done more than enough to warrant all the accolades deserving of a true world champion. He’s now won his sixth consecutive European Group 1 race, beginning with the Two Thousand Guineas in May, then moving on to the Investec Epsom Derby in June, the Coral Eclipse in July, the Juddmonte International in August, and the Tattersalls Millions Irish Champion in September. His dam, Urban Sea, who died earlier this year, won the 1993 Arc de Triomphe, and she became just the second broodmare to produce two Epsom Derby winners (her first was 2001 winner Galileo). Sea the Stars will be the most sought-after stallion prospect in many years, despite the depressed market in the breeding business.

He’s “the nearest living thing to a machine,” trainer Oxx said after Sea the Stars won the Irish Champion Stakes last month. “If any of us is still around at the end of the century, I doubt there will be too many other horses who have achieved what he has done.”

All of us are in the habit of letting our hopes get too high when a horse of this type comes along. They aren’t machines, and nearly all of them are susceptible to nagging injuries, bad luck, or simply having a bad day. Sea the Stars has avoided those pitfalls. He’s never let us down.

He may very well be the horse of a lifetime, the kind every breeder dreams of producing, every owner dreams of owning, every trainer wants to put his hands on, and every racing fan can believe in.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

SOUTH AFRICA: NATION OF GOOD HOPE

Tuesday, September 1st, 2009
By Ray Paulick
It’s a long, long way from Lexington, Ky., to Cape Town, Africa’s southern-most city, where I was invited to attend a two-day international breeders conference and share my thoughts on Thoroughbred industry trends and challenges with members of South Africa’s Cape Breeders Club.

Was it worth taking the time to go halfway ‘round the world, experiencing a frightening aborted landing during a violent electrical storm at an intermediate stop in Dakar, getting a mental wakeup call from jet lag each night at 3 a.m., and suffering with a persistent head cold for most of stay?

Absolutely!

To be invited to a far-off nation and to meet and learn from others with a passion for Thoroughbred racing and breeding was an opportunity I couldn’t pass up. During one of my semi-sleepless nights it occurred to me that I’ve now had the good fortune to experience racing in 13 countries in Africa, Asia, Australia, Europe and North and South America. 

The conference itself taught me that challenges South Africa faces are in most ways similar to those we have in the United States. For the Thoroughbred breeder, where job No. 1 is to get that mare in foal and thereby avoiding numerous pitfalls, England’s Jonathan Pycock (pictured, left, with Ray Paulick) provided sound advice during several outstanding presentations drawing on his years of experience from around the Thoroughbred world. Included among the other talks were Grant Williamson of Kentucky’s Vinery who gave a comprehensive outline of how a top-class stallion operation is managed during the breeding season; veterinarian Alasdair Cameron provided radiograph insights from an auction buyer’s perspective; Roy Gottschalk and Sybrand van den Berg discussed angular limb deformities, and Irish entrepreneur Robbie Byrne demonstrated his company’s Equisoft horse management software program. And in a compelling personal life story, Andrew Fortune spoke from the heart about how he managed to rise from the depths of a horrible drug addiction to become South Africa’s champion jockey. Yesterday I wrote about Cambridge University controversial professor emeritus W.R. “Twink” Allen’s talk promoting artificial insemination and embryo transfer.

The similarities in the Thoroughbred industry between South Africa and the U.S. are unmistakable. South Africa is drowning in simulcast products sent into the home, killing its on-track business. The takeout is too high, making it hard for punters to keep their heads above water. Bookmakers can offer better deals than the tote because it pays very little for the privilege of being in the bet-taking business. On-track attendance has fallen precipitously, turning racecourses into virtual ghost towns. The public company that owns the majority of the tracks seems to have little interest in building the sport. There are philosophical differences about marketing and how to deal with competing slot machine emporiums and casinos. Owners and breeders often have contentious differences over veterinary issues at auctions, where ethics questions arise as well. Sound familiar? It goes on and on.

Another characteristic of South African racing is the post-apartheid view that it remains an elitist white man’s game in a country that has successfully integrated and changed in so many other ways.

A visit to Cape Town’s Kenilworth racecourse for a rather non-descript day of racing demonstrated the impact of these problems. There couldn’t have been more than several hundred people throughout the facility. Some sections of the track, including a large dining room, hadn’t been occupied for weeks or months. Of those fans in attendance, many seemed more interested in the televised rugby games than the live racing.

Yet with so many things going wrong in South African racing, there are more than a few streaks of sunlight brightening the horizon. The value of South African horses, as measured by a big run-up in auction yearling averages until the past year, suggests there is good demand for the breeders’ product. South African horses have proven to be competitive around the world, including in the U.S., where Barry Irwin’s Team Valor has showcased them prominently in recent years.

No one exudes the passion and enthusiasm for the South African Thoroughbred more than publisher and breeding expert Charles Faull (pictured, left), who I had the opportunity to meet for the first time during my visit. Faull, a man with boundless energy and creativity, brought South African breeding into the modern era 30 years ago with the publication of the country’s first Stallion Register. It was described at the time by Bill Oppenheim in Racing Update as the best stallion book in the world, and Faull only made it better in subsequent editions. He boasts, in his Cape Town offices, what surely must be the most thorough library of racing and breeding information found in South Africa, and he seems to have read and absorbed just about everything the library holds.

His determination to discover what combination of bloodlines best produces a top-class racehorse is mind-boggling, matched only by his persistence to create new products that share his passion for the game. His new vision is for a Wikipedia type of web site (Thoropedia he calls it) that would have detailed pedigree and racing information on every registered Thoroughbred in history. Did I say he was ambitious?

What I liked about Faull is his insistence that racing break down its walls of elitism, become more democratic in its leadership, treat the punters or horseplayers like valued customers, increase transparency in all that the sport does, provide more comprehensive statistical information at no cost to fans, and promote and market the best that the game offers.

In some ways, Faull reflects a general optimism that I felt from many South Africans who have seen and experienced so much change in their lifetimes in the pre- and post-apartheid eras. The country itself is blessed by a rare physical beauty; the combination of the vast mountains and the two oceans that meet at the rocky southern tip of South Africa near Cape Point is as spectacular as the arid region to the north, where elephants, lions and rhino still roam freely.

Its people, of all colors, are a precious resource, too, despite many of them having lived through the terrible poverty of the townships that remain a serious challenge in all regions of the country. The country is making serious strides in the right direction, however.

South Africa was isolated from the world in the late stages of apartheid, and in some ways it remains so today. But the spirit of optimism that seems to permeate modern-day South Africa has left this weary traveler with nothing but fond memories and good feelings for the future of this country and its people.

Many thanks to the Cape Breeders Club for their generous hospitality during my stay, and especially thanks to club chair Liesl King for the kind invitation to come to Cape Town and to Adrian Todd of Worldwide Agri Exchange for his travel advice and assistance during my stay.

DID CUP RACE AGAINST THE SHEIKH’S MONEY?

Tuesday, July 7th, 2009
By Ray Paulick
There’s an old expression never to pick a fight with someone who buys ink by the barrel (people don’t get their news in print publications the way they used to, but you get the point). Similarly, it’s probably not a good idea to get into a money-measuring contest with someone who amassed a fortune selling oil by the barrel.

That’s what seems to have happened with the Breeders’ Cup, whose operating deficit and financial challenges are the subject of an outstanding article by Matt Hergarty in Wednesday’s Daily Racing Form (click here to read).

First run in 1984, the Breeders’ Cup has grown from a one-day championship of seven races worth $10 million to a two-day event with 14 races and purses totaling $25.5 million. It was the richest day of racing when it was created, and Breeders’ Cup officials have tried to maintain that status, even as the Dubai World Cup program, fueled by Sheikh Mohammed’s oil money, enthusiasm and competitive nature, grew substantially from its debut in 1996, when it offered $5.1 million in prize money.

The Dubai World Cup program exceeded the Breeders’ Cup in prize money beginning in 2000, when its purses were increased to $15.25 million for seven races, topped by the $6-million Dubai World Cup. That year’s Breeders’ Cup carried $13 million in purses (topped by the $4 million Classic). Another million in purses was added to the Breeders’ Cup in 2003, increasing the day’s prize money to $14 million for eight races (a Filly & Mare Turf race had been added to the original menu in 1999).

Dubai’s purses took another huge leap in2006, when they were increased to $21.25 million for seven races. Shortly after those hikes were announced Breeders’ Cup officials scrambled to keep up with the sheikh after worrying they might get left in cloud of desert dust. Purses for the eight Breeders’ Cup races in 2006 were increased to $20 million, including a $1-million jump for the Classic, which became a $5-million race.

The biggest difference between the Breeders’ Cup and the Dubai World Cup program is the source of funding. Nominations for foals and stallions, along with a percentage of betting handle, are the primary sources of revenue for the Breeders’ Cup. Sheikh Mohammed, the ruler of Dubai, can arbitrarily set prize money for the World Cup program. Though Dubai at one time was an oil-rich country, gas and petroleum now account for less than 10% of its revenue, according to reports. Construction, real estate and tourism are major contributors to Dubai’s current economy (though the world’s economic slowdown have hurt each of those sectors). Nevertheless, Dubai remains a wealthy country, and Sheikh Mohammed controls its purse strings. He can turn the faucet for the Dubai World Cup on or off at his pleasure.

Because wagering and event day ticketing is such an important part of the Breeders’ Cup revenue stream, officials with the organization decided to increase the number of wagering opportunities as it added to the prize money. The 2007 championships at Monmouth Park included three new races, bringing the total to 11 races worth $23 million, and the event was extended to two days. Last year, another two contests were added, bringing the total to 14 Breeders’ Cup races worth $25.5 million. That exceeded the Dubai World Cup purses—for now. However, Sheikh Mohammed has said the 2010 World Cup race will carry a $10-million purse, and it’s likely he’ll add to some of the others to make the program the richest day of racing in the world.

Meanwhile, because revenue didn’t keep up with the increased costs at the Breeders’ Cup (nominations are down, and the additional races didn’t generate as much handle as expected), the organization is running at a deficit and is considering a cut in championship purses, among other things.

Perhaps the increased number of races and the expansion from one to two days was a mistake. There is a dilution effect when there now are, for example, four championship races for 2-year-olds (two on dirt, two on turf), as opposed to the previous two; as well as when there is a sprint division, a turf sprint division and a filly and mare sprint division; or a dirt (or synthetic) sprint, mile and mile and a quarter race.

The old mindset of keeping up with the sheikhs is no longer an option. Whether or not oil is a significant contributor to Dubai’s economy anymore, Sheikh Mohammed appears to have much deeper pockets than the Breeders’ Cup. Trying to match him dollar for dollar may have gotten the Breeders’ Cup into the financial hole its now in.

So the question is: If the Breeders’ Cup is fiscally challenged, should it reconsider all those new races added to the menu and think about going back to a one-day championship?

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Savvy businesses recognize value. Advertise in the Paulick Report.

Support the Paulick Report. Make a donation today.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

WHEN IT COMES TO DOUGLAS, RACING STEWARDS SHARE THE BLAME

Tuesday, May 26th, 2009

By Ray Paulick
How many times have we seen this happen? A jockey, thinking he is on a “live” horse but with nowhere to go, makes a sudden lane switch in tight quarters at the top of the stretch, bumping or impeding another horse in the race. Oftentimes the “live” horse turns out to be a dud and is outrun to the wire, finishing out of the money. Because there is no need for an inquiry, the stewards scarcely give the incident a second look.

Sometimes, if the jockey in question is an apprentice or young journeyman, the stewards will call him or her in the next racing day to review the incident in the film room. Occasionally, the jockey might get a fine or suspension. Far too often, these incidents pass without any warnings or repercussions to the jockey. No harm, no foul, the thinking goes.

But then we have a situation in which there were severe consequences, as in Saturday’s Arlington Matron at Arlington Park near Chicago. Jamie Theriot, riding Sky Mom, was tucked in along the rail, right behind the leader, and anxious to let his horse run. Even though Rene Douglas and his mount, Born to Be, was racing shoulder to shoulder with Sky Mom, Theriot forced his way out, jostling with Douglas’ mount, and resulting in Born to Be clipping heels, throwing Douglas to the ground, and then rolling onto the fallen jockey and causing severe damage to his spine.

Moments later, the horse on the lead that Theriot was so impatient to pass, drifted off the rail while tiring, providing enough room to drive a Mack truck through. By then, however, it was too late. The damage had been done. Born to Be suffered a fatal injury, and Douglas likely had his highly successful career cut short. There’s a very good chance he’ll never walk again.

Theriot was only riding the way stewards in too many racing jurisdictions allow him to ride. Watch the replays from any track on any given day, and you’re likely to see similar moves by other jockeys — some with less experience, others with more — than the 30-year-old Theriot. 

Stewards who don’t pay attention to these incidents, who live by the “no harm, no foul” philosophy, are like the referees in a basketball game who don’t call many fouls, who “let the kids play,” at least until things get out of control. The stewards who let these incidents pass, just as much if not more than Jamie Theriot, are to blame for the accident that so severely injured Douglas.

Theriot got a 30-day suspension for his actions in the race from the stewards at Arlington Park. It’s a moot point now, but I’m curious if there would have been any disciplinary action taken against Theriot had Born to Be not clipped heels and fallen after being bumped, and Douglas not been injured. Would the same move off the rail by Theriot, but with no accident and death to a horse and injury to a jockey, have resulted in a 30-day suspension? I don’t think so.

The Illinois Racing Board stewards refused to discuss the incident with the Paulick Report or with other reporters. It is part of racing’s secret society, the one that says the public has no right to know what these “judges” are seeing and thinking during or after the running of a race. In many racing states, it’s virtually impossible to find out if stewards have taken action against jockeys, trainers or other licensees, even though the rulings are a matter of public record.

By contrast, racing officials in many international jurisdictions routinely file in-depth stewards reports on every race they see. It is part of the culture in those countries that the racing public has a right to know. In some countries, trainers are required to disclose riding instructions to racing officials in advance if they are likely to result in a change in tactics. In other countries, jockeys or trainers are quizzed when a horse has a reversal in form. Interviews with jockeys about lane changes are published. Click on the following hyperlinks to see some examples of stewards reports in Dubai, Hong Kong, Australia and Singapore.

There are at least two reasons state racing commissions across the United States should insist their stewards file similar reports.

First, it will indicate whether or not these officials are doing their jobs, or how well they are doing them. The racing public, as well as horsemen, will keep the stewards’ feet to the fire and make sure they are paying attention and performing their duties. Many of the currently unreported riding incidents may no longer be brushed aside.

Second, the betting public deserves to know what is going on in the races on which they are betting their money. This is, after all, a game with betting at the foundation, and diligence and attention by the officials who are paid to keep the game clean and on the up and up should go a long way toward building confidence among horseplayers and satisfying the public’s desire and right to know.

Racing has so many challenges now, many of which do not have immediate solutions. This is not one of those “unsolvable problems.” Disclosure and transparency by racing stewards is easy. And it’s the right thing to do.

Better performance by racing stewards, along with greater transparency, may not have saved the life of Born to Be and the career of Rene Douglas. But what is the downside to expecting more from those who are hired to enforce racing’s rules?

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Support the Paulick Report. Make a
donation today.

Visit the Paulick Report for
all the latest news throughout the racing world.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

IS BETFAIR READY TO PLAY FAIR?

Saturday, May 23rd, 2009

By Ray Paulick
Is Betfair developing a conscience? The world’s leading betting exchange, which recently dipped its toes into U.S. gambling waters with its purchase of the horse racing network and account wagering company TVG, has reportedly made a voluntary contribution to the Levy Board, the statutory group that disburses betting revenue from bookmakers, exchanges and the tote in the form of prize money for British racing.

The Guardian reported on Friday that Betfair recently made a voluntary payment of almost $2 million to the Levy Board in recognition of profits made by the exchange from clients outside of the UnIted Kingdom betting on British horse racing. The amount represents 10% of Betfair’s profits on such wagers.

Betfair has contractual obligations to the Levy Board on profits made from British punters, but this is apparently the first time the exchange made voluntary payments on gains from overseas clients betting on British racing. Betfair is based on Malta.

“We have sent a check,” Betfair spokesman Mark Davies told the Guardian, “as there is no statutory mechanism by which we can pay the levy in respect of our international business. We are doing this because we support British racing.”

That begs the question of when Betfair will begin to share its wealth with U.S. racetrack and horsemen (or , more simply,“Where’s ours?” as Australian-based pedigree consultant Byron Rogers asked when alerting me to Betfair’s voluntary payment to the Levy Board.) Though the betting exchange says it does not accept any wagers from the United States, it does offer betting on American horse racing to its international clientele. Currently, to my knowledge, Betfair does not share any profits from those bets with American racetracks or horsemen’s organizations. Negotiations have taken place between Betfair and Breeders’ Cup officials, as well as with the Thoroughbred Owners of California, but no revenue sharing deals have yet been struck.

It seems only a matter of time before American racetrack and horsemen’s organization officials link overseas wagering on American racing via Betfair to domestic contracts involving TVG.

Those who want to learn more about the relatively brief and exceedingly successful history of Betfair, a company founded in 2000 by Andrew Black and Ed Wray, might be interested in Colin Cameron’s new book: “You Bet— The Betfair Story: How Two Men Changed the World of Gambling.” Click here for details.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Support the Paulick Report. Make a
donation today.

Visit the Paulick Report for
all the latest news throughout the racing world.

Sign up for our
Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

AN EYE FOR A HORSE

Monday, February 23rd, 2009

By Ray Paulick
Few readers of the Paulick Report have probably ever heard of and fewer still have  probably ever met Japanese photographer Hisae Imai, and that’s too bad. She was an international ambassador for Thoroughbred racing and breeding who helped racing fans in Japan and elsewhere see the magic and mystique of horses through her art.

Amazingly Miss Imai was, to my understanding, legally blind. It’s something I’ve never quite understood, how someone with such poor vision could have such an exquisite eye for her subjects and create some of the most beautiful images of horses ever produced.

I first met her at the 1993 Japan Cup, when introduced by the American-based photographer of Japanese descent, Shigeki Kikkawa. She spoke about as much English as I spoke Japanese, so our conversation was extremely limited. But she handed me a packet of post cards as a small gift, and they were the most stunning and unique equine images I had ever seen – before or since. 

The photographs of Thoroughbreds racing across the plush green paddocks or the deep snowy fields in the northern Japanese island of Hokkaido were absolutely beautiful, and her racing shots were always sharp. But it was her artistic images that were unforgettable: the horses running through clouds were my favorites. She had a seemingly never-ending well of creativity that connected with people who love horses.

Miss Imai has been widely honored in Japan for her art, but I don’t think she was in it for the glory or the money (her commercial web site can be found here). She had a passion for the animals,

spending hours upon hours with them to get one special shot. She traveled the world, covering major international races on several continents. In the few extended conversations we had, she always spoke of her subjects with reverence and a heartfelt emotion.

I wish I could say I knew her life story, for I’m sure it was fascinating, but the language barrier always limited us to a greeting, a deep bow from Miss Imai, and a poorly executed bow in return from me. She was ever gracious; 15 years after our first meeting she continued to thank me for a small article I had written about her art in a series in Bloodhorse magazine on the hugely popular Japanese racing industry.

She was a short woman who almost always sported a hat from what appeared to be an unusual collection, and she had a wonderful laugh. The enormous lenses she lugged around on her shoulder almost touched the ground as she moved about, always looking to find the right place to get the perfect shot. She was never in a hurry, yet never seemed to miss anything, either. She was a perfect fit for the Japanese racing industry, whose fans have an intense interest in their Thoroughbred stars, and not just in cashing a winning ticket on them. They bought souvenirs featuring their favorite horses; photos like Miss Imai’s that looked into their soul and captured their personalities.

Miss Imai was well into her 70s when her heart failed her last Tuesday. Fortunately, her work will live on through the art she created over more than 40 years of a life dedicated to horses.

It’s sometimes easy to forget what’s at the heart of this business. In all the talk of medication, integrity, takeout, and the myriad of issues that are dealt with on a daily basis, we cannot lose sight of the fact without that beautiful Thoroughbred, we have nothing.

Hisae Imai knew that as well as anyone I’ve ever met.

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Sign up for our Email flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary from Ray Paulick

Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world.

HAVEN NO HEAVEN

Thursday, February 12th, 2009

By Ray Paulick
Desert Party won Thursday night’s UAE 2000 Guineas at Nad Al Sheba racecourse in Dubai, rallying from just off the pace under Lanfranco Dettori to score an "under wraps"  victory over Regal Ransom and pacesetter Redding Colliery. Vineyard Haven, winner of the Hopeful and Champagne Stakes last year and runner-up to Midshipman in Eclipse Award voting, finished a distant fourth in his first start in Sheikh Mohammed’s Godolphin silks. The son of Lido Palace had previously been owned by a partnership that included trainer Robert Frankel and Los Angeles Dodgers manager Joe Torre before a reported $12-million offer from the ruler of Dubai.

The winner was making his second start in Dubai for trainer Saeed bin Suroor, coming off a half-length win Jan. 22 in the Ford Flex Trophy, a prep for the Grade 3 UAE 2000 Guineas. A 3-year-old son of Street Cry out of Sage Cat, by Tabasco Cat, Desert Party began his career in the United States for trainer Eoin Harty,  breaking his maiden on Polytrack at Arlington Park in June, then beating three horses in the Grade 2 Sanford on a muddy Saratoga dirt track July 24. Desert Party finished a well beaten sixth behind Vineyard Haven in Saratoga’s Hopeful. Bred in Kentucky by David Smith and Steven Sinatra, Desert Party was a $2.1 million purchase at Fasig-Tipton’s February sale of 2-year-olds in training at Calder after Paul Pompa had purchased him for $425,000 at the 2007 Keeneland September yearling sale.

Runner-up Regal Ransom, a $675,000 purchase at the same Calder 2-year-old sale, broke his maiden at Saratoga in August but finished eighth in the Grade 1 Norfolk in his only other U.S. start. He also ran second to Desert Party in the Ford Flex, his first race in Dubai.

Vineyard Haven, purchased privately after  winning the Champagne Stakes by  5 3/4 lengths, appeared a bit rank in the early going while racing to the outside and just off the early lead of Redding Colliery. He failed to respond when asked by jockey T.E. Durcan and was never a threat down the stretch of the one-turn, one-mile contest.

VIDEO

 

WORLD’S BEST HORSES OF 2008

Tuesday, January 13th, 2009

By Ray Paulick
There are a number of ways to look at the just-released World Thoroughbred Rankings, which were compiled by racing officials/handicappers from around the globe and published by the International Federation of Horseracing Authorities. Which country had the highest representation? What about the stallions that produced the highest number of world-class runers and the trainers who developed them?

The rankings of horses from around the world are updated throughout the year, and can be viewed at the Web site of the IFHA, which maintains historical rankings as well. Click here to see the complete list of 2008 World Thoroughbred Rankings.

Leading Sires of Horses 
On World Thoroughbred Rankings
Sire Ranked
Horses
Sire’s Sire Farm Stands Located
Galileo 8 Sadler’s Wells Coolmore Ireland
Montjeu 8 Sadler’s Wells Coolmore Ireland
Sadler’s Wells 8 Northern Dancer Pensioned Ireland
Danehill 7 Danzig Deceased Ire/Aus
Kingmambo 6 Mr. Prospector Lane’s End Kentucky
Chester House 5 Mr. Prospector Deceased Kentucky
Fuji Kiseki 5 Sunday Silence Shadai Japan
Encosta de Lago 4 Fairy King Coolmore Australia
Flying Spur 4 Danehill Arrowfield Australia
Rock of Gibraltar 4 Danehill Coolmore Ireland
Tiznow 4 Cee’s Tizzy WinStar Kentucky
Agnes Tachiyon 3 Sunday Silence Shadai Japan
Cape Cross 3 Green Desert Kildangan Stud Ireland
Giant’s Causeway 3 Storm Cat Coolmore/Ashford Kentucky
Grass Wonder 3 Silver Hawk Breeders’ Stallion Station Japan
Jet Master 3 Jet Lightning Klipdrif Stud South Africa
O’Reilly 3 Last Tycoon Waikato Stud New Zealand
Rahy 3 Blushing Groom Three Chimneys Kentucky
Street Cry 3 Machiavellian Darley Kentucky
Zamindar 3 Gone West Banstead Manor Great Britain

From a nationalistic point of view, American interests dominated the standings by placing 84 U.S.-trained horses on the list of Northern and Southern Hemisphere runners, aged 3 and up, who were weighted at 115 pounds or higher. That list is headed, of course, by the 2007 Horse of the Year, Curlin, who was weighted at 130 pounds, equal to the weight assigned the Irish-trained 3-year-old, New Approach. The number of U.S.-trained horses is nearly twice as many as the 43 from Great Britain making the list, but it only stands to reason since there are far more races and graded stakes in the United States than in any other country. Following Great Britain was Australia ,with 36; Japan, 28; France, 27; Ireland, 21; Hong Kong, 13; Germany, 11; United Arab Emirates, 10; South Africa, 6; New Zealand, 3;  Spain, 3; Canada, 2; Brazil, 1; Hungary, 1; Italy, 1; and Turkey, 1.

Not surprisingly, Aidan O’Brien, the young master of Ballydoyle in Ireland, trains the most runners on the list with 14. O’Brien is private trainer for Coolmore’s John Magnier and his associates. Sir Michael Stoute and Saeed bin Suroor were next, with nine each, followed by Robert Frankel, 8, Andre Fabre, 7, and Mike de Kock, with 6.

From a sire standpoint, Coolmore was a dominating force, as the accompanying table shows, led by their trio of the pensioned legend, Sadler’s Wells, along with young stars Galileo and Montjeu, both of whom were sired by Sadler’s Wells. Each of the three was represented by eight horses on the World Rankings. Following that top trio is another stallion associated with Coolmore, Danehill, who shuttled between Australia and Ireland. He has seven horses ranked at 115 pounds or higher for 2008, and also is the sire of two of the others on this list, Flying Spur and Rock of Gibraltar.

The highest American-based sire on the list is the Lane’s End stallion Kingmambo, who is represented by six runners on the World Rankings. Next is Chester House, a son of Mr. Prospector who stood at Juddmonte Farm before his unfortunate and premature death at age 8 in 2003. He was produced by the preeminent broodmare, Toussaud, who died most recently.

The 2008 World Thoroughbred Rankings were compiled by the World Rankings Supervisory Committee (a panel of handicappers/racing secretaries affiliated to the International Federation of Horseracing Authorities) in Hong Kong in December 2008. The committee comprised :

Nigel Gray (co-chairman)
Hong Kong

Garry O’Gorman (co-chairman)
Ireland

Greg Carpenter
Australia

Gerald Sauque
France

Dominic Gardiner-Hill
Great Britain

Phillip Smith
Great Britain

Harald Siemen
Germany

Marco Rinaldi
Italy

Kazuhito Matano, Dr
Japan

Takahiro Uno
Japan

Dean Nowell
New Zealand

Mike Wanklin
Singapore

Roger Smith
South Africa

Melvin Day
UAE

Tom Robbins
USA

with the following also present as observers :

David Hunter
Australia

Steven Lym
Canada

Bahadir Gur
Turkey

Taylan Karaer
Turkey
* * * * * *

For further details on the World Thoroughbred Rankings (WTR), please contact :

Nigel Gray, co-chairman World Rankings Supervisory Committee
Head of Handicapping and Race Planning, Hong Kong Jockey Club
Telephone +852 2966 8337
Email nigel.c.gray@hkjc.org.hk

Garry O’Gorman, co-chairman World Rankings Supervisory Committee
Senior Flat Handicapper, Irish Turf Club
Telephone +353 5997 26596
Email gaogorman@eircom.net

Tom Robbins, chairman North American Ratings Committee
Vice President (Racing), Del Mar Thoroughbred Club
Telephone +1 858 792 4230
Email tomr@dmtc.com

Copyright © 2009, The Paulick Report

Visit the Paulick Report for all the latest news throughout the racing world.

Sign up for our Email Flashes to get the latest news, analysis and commentary.